Florida 2023 Regular Session

Florida House Bill H1309

Introduced
3/1/23  
Refer
3/6/23  
Refer
3/6/23  
Refer
3/6/23  
Refer
3/31/23  

Caption

Child Maintenance Restitution

Impact

The bill could significantly alter the landscape of child support calculations in Florida by introducing a system of restitution that obligates convicted offenders to contribute financially to their victims' minor children. This includes potential modifications to existing laws surrounding child support and restitution, specifically tailored to address circumstances where the death of a caretaker results from criminal activity. The implementation of monthly payments is designed to provide immediate and ongoing financial support to affected families, which could relieve some of the burdens placed on state resources in cases where children are orphaned by violence.

Summary

House Bill 1309, titled 'Child Maintenance Restitution', proposes to establish a legal framework requiring defendants convicted of specific crimes resulting in the death of a parent or guardian to provide financial support to their surviving minor children. The bill defines 'child maintenance restitution' as a mandated obligation designed to ensure continuous monetary support for the child’s care, education, and upbringing until they reach the age of 18. Courts will assess the amount of restitution based on a variety of factors, including the needs of the child and their surviving guardian, aiming to reflect the standard of living the child is accustomed to prior to the offense. The bill aims to bridge the gap in support for children left behind by deceased victims of violent crimes.

Sentiment

Overall, the sentiment surrounding HB 1309 appears to be supportive among legislators and advocates for children's rights. Proponents argue that it establishes a necessary legal obligation for offenders, promoting accountability and care for vulnerable children. Critics may raise concerns about the practical enforceability of such restitution orders and discuss potential implications for defendants who may already face financial burdens due to their legal situations. However, the overarching narrative remains focused on the importance of ensuring the well-being of children following tragic events caused by criminal acts.

Contention

Notable points of contention may arise regarding how the courts will determine the appropriate amount of restitution, given the subjective nature of financial support needs and the potential for disputes between the surviving guardians and the convicted offenders. Additionally, questions regarding the administrative capacities for enforcing these restitution orders and the implications for previously established civil judgments may emerge as part of the broader discussion on the bill's practicality and equitable application.

Companion Bills

FL S1090

Similar To Fees/Income Deduction Orders

FL S1092

Similar To Child Maintenance Restitution

Similar Bills

FL H0079

Child Maintenance Restitution

HI SB2724

Relating To Victim Restitution.

HI SB225

Related To Driving Under The Influence.

HI HB711

Related To Driving Under The Influence.

HI SB3295

Related To Driving Under The Influence.

HI SB2017

Relating To Financial Support Of A Child After Driving Under The Influence.

AR HB1131

To Provide For Restitution For A Homicide Victim's Surviving Dependent Child When The Defendant Was Driving Or Boating While Intoxicated At The Time Of The Homicide; And To Establish Bentley's Law.

HI SB45

Relating To Restitution.