Florida 2023 Regular Session

Florida House Bill H6009

Introduced
2/10/23  
Refer
2/21/23  
Refer
2/21/23  
Refer
2/21/23  

Caption

Relief/Michael Barnett/Department of Children and Families

Impact

The bill highlights significant issues surrounding child welfare and domestic violence responses by state agencies. It serves as a public acknowledgment of the DCF’s shortcomings in handling a case rife with indicators of potential harm. This funding aims to address the suffering endured by Barnett and R.B. as a result of systemic failures, which exemplifies the need for improved protective measures and review processes within DCF. If passed, it may set a precedent for future cases where families seek compensatory options due to similar failures in state agencies’ duties.

Summary

House Bill 6009 pertains to the allocation of financial relief to Michael Barnett, who is the natural parent and legal guardian of R.B. This bill is a direct response to a tragic incident involving domestic violence that led to severe consequences for the family. The legislation recognizes a failure on the part of the Department of Children and Families (DCF) to act appropriately in a situation where numerous warning signs were present. Specifically, the bill stipulates an appropriation of $296,400 from the General Revenue Fund to compensate Barnett for damages and injuries sustained due to the DCF's negligence.

Contention

Notably, the bill arose from a court case in which a settlement was reached following the deaths in the Whyte-Dell family shooting. Critically, the findings indicated that the department had multiple opportunities to intervene but failed to do so, raising questions about accountability in child protective services. The limitation on attorney fees—capped at 25% of the total compensation awarded—reflects an effort to ensure that a maximum amount is available for the beneficiaries. Nevertheless, stakeholders may debate the appropriateness of such limitations in other contexts of legal settlements.

Companion Bills

FL S0090

Same As Relief of Michael Barnett/Department of Children and Families

Similar Bills

TX HB2492

Relating to the family allowance, treatment of exempt property, and an allowance in lieu of exempt property in the administration of a decedent's estate.

CA AB1221

Children’s advocacy centers.

CA SB18

Bill of Rights for the Children and Youth of California: joint legislative committee.

CA SB1447

Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles.

CA AB1737

Children’s camps: safety.

CA AB555

California state preschool programs: reimbursement amounts: adjustment factors.

CA AR68

Relative to Children’s Environmental Health Month 2021.

CA AR123

Relative to Children’s Environmental Health Month.