Hawaii 2022 Regular Session

Hawaii House Bill HCR48 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
1-HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES H.C.R. NO. 48 THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022 H.D. 1 STATE OF HAWAII HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION REQUESTING THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION TO CONSIDER EFFORTS TO MITIGATE HIGH ENERGY BURDENS FOR LOW- AND MODERATE-INCOME CUSTOMERS AND INPUT BY THE CONSUMER ADVOCATE AND INVESTIGATE HOW TO INTEGRATE CONSIDERATIONS OF ENERGY EQUITY AND JUSTICE ACROSS ITS WORK.
1+HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES H.C.R. NO. 48 THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022 STATE OF HAWAII HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION requesting the public utilities commission to consider efforts to mitigate high energy burdens for low- and moderate-income customers and investigate how to integrate considerations of energy equity and justice across its work.
22
33 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES H.C.R. NO. 48
4-THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022 H.D. 1
4+THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022
55 STATE OF HAWAII
66
77 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
88
99 H.C.R. NO.
1010
1111 48
1212
1313 THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022
1414
15-H.D. 1
15+
1616
1717 STATE OF HAWAII
1818
1919
2020
2121
2222
2323
2424
2525
2626
2727
2828
2929 HOUSE CONCURRENT
3030
3131 RESOLUTION
3232
3333
3434
3535
3636
37-REQUESTING THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COMMISSION TO CONSIDER EFFORTS TO MITIGATE HIGH ENERGY BURDENS FOR LOW- AND MODERATE-INCOME CUSTOMERS AND INPUT BY THE CONSUMER ADVOCATE AND INVESTIGATE HOW TO INTEGRATE CONSIDERATIONS OF ENERGY EQUITY AND JUSTICE ACROSS ITS WORK.
37+requesting the public utilities commission to consider efforts to mitigate high energy burdens for low- and moderate-income customers and investigate how to integrate considerations of energy equity and justice across its work.
3838
3939
4040
4141
4242
4343
4444
45- WHEREAS, many households in Hawaii have difficulty paying energy bills and suffer energy insecurity, in which they are faced with difficult choices, such as whether to sacrifice food or medicine to be able to pay for energy; and WHEREAS, the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism found that "household electricity burden the percentage of household income spent on electricity bills is one of the key elements contributing to a household's energy insecurity, especially for low-income households"; and WHEREAS, consequently, households with lower incomes are faced with higher levels of energy insecurity; and WHEREAS, forty-two percent of households in the State live below the ALICE (asset limited, income constrained, employed) threshold, meaning that almost half of all families in Hawaii are struggling to make ends meet, even though they are employed; and WHEREAS, additionally, nine percent of these ALICE families are living in poverty, and this trend has progressively worsened in recent years due to the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic; and WHEREAS, rising temperatures and humidity due to climate change have increased the need for air conditioning, resulting in the need for more electricity and further exacerbating the situation of energy insecurity for residents; and WHEREAS, Hawaii's electricity rates are the highest in the nation, at close to three times the national average; and WHEREAS, although the federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program is available for bill assistance, an average of only twenty percent of qualifying households actually receive benefits, leaving an obvious unmet need for bill assistance or rate relief to those in privation; and WHEREAS, the State's electric utilities do not offer utility specific low- to moderate-income discount rates and have limited, if any, bill assistance options; and WHEREAS, in recognition of these and other disparities contributing to high electricity burdens, some state utilities in Arizona, California, Georgia, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Vermont are authorized to offer lower rates to low- and limited-income customers to reduce residential electricity burden and ensure continued access to electrical power; and WHEREAS, when comparing electricity burden maps in the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism's electricity burden report to the Hawaii Statewide Energy Project Directory provided by the Hawaii State Energy Office, a substantial number of the current and planned energy project locations are in or near areas that have higher electricity burdens; and WHEREAS, the communities that serve as geographic hosts for major energy projects receive the same project benefit of secure provision of service as all other ratepayers, yet must live with the burdens associated with hosting those projects and are neither offered compensation for doing so nor are generally meaningfully engaged in the planning process; and WHEREAS, the burdens host communities shoulder include high concentrations of particulate air emissions, loss of open space, loss of other land uses, environmental concerns, and projects that are maligned with the host community's localized needs and priorities for provision of electrical service; and WHEREAS, without intentional and informed planning, progression toward the State's clean energy goals may therefore come at the expense of already burdened communities; and WHEREAS, current circumstances necessitate an explicit focus on energy and climate justice to ensure that the benefits and burdens of energy infrastructure development in the face of climate change are equitably distributed; and WHEREAS, the Public Utilities Commission has worked on and continues to work on energy resource issues through its docket proceedings, such as docket no. 2019-0323, which is investigating distributed energy resource policies pertaining to the Hawaiian Electric Companies; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the House of Representatives of the Thirty-first Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2022, the Senate concurring, that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to consider efforts to mitigate high energy burdens for low- and moderate-income customers and input by the Consumer Advocate and investigate how to integrate considerations of energy equity and justice across its work; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to examine: (1) Low- and moderate-income rate discounts, bill credits, and direct payments and whether these would be appropriate in the State; (2) Expanded availability of utility bill assistance programs and whether adequate payment plan arrangements are available to low- and moderate-income customers who are facing economic challenges, such as loss of employment; (3) Measures to protect low- and moderate-income households, senior citizens, and households with infants from service disconnections, including reporting requirements for all utilities on the number of customers annually disconnected due to non-payment; (4) The advantages and disadvantages of rate design, program offerings, and the requirements of community benefits agreements to address energy burden, energy insecurity, and environmental and energy justice concerns related to energy projects and programs; and (5) Other customer-centric solutions to lessen the energy burden on low- and moderate-income customers and determine appropriate benefits above and beyond those accrued to the overall electric grid for communities that serve as geographic hosts to utility scale energy projects; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to establish the necessary proceeding or proceedings to conduct this examination; provided that the proceedings are not duplicative, but rather focus on the need for integration of energy equity and justice in the ongoing and future work of the Public Utilities Commission; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to submit a report to the Legislature of its findings and recommendations, including any proposed legislation, no later than twenty days prior to the convening of the Regular Session of 2023; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that certified copies of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Chairperson of the Public Utilities Commission and Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs Consumer Advocate. Report Title: Public Utilities Commission; Low- and Moderate-Income Customers; Energy Burden; Energy Equity and Justice
45+ WHEREAS, many households in Hawaii have difficulty paying energy bills and suffer energy insecurity, in which they are faced with difficult choices, such as whether to sacrifice food or medicine to be able to pay for energy; and WHEREAS, the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism found that "household electricity burden the percentage of household income spent on electricity bills is one of the key elements contributing to a household's energy insecurity, especially for low-income households"; and WHEREAS, consequently, households with lower incomes are faced with higher levels of energy insecurity; and WHEREAS, forty-two percent of households in the State live below the ALICE (asset limited, income constrained, employed) threshold, meaning that almost half of all families in Hawaii are struggling to make ends meet, even though they are employed; and WHEREAS, additionally, nine percent of these ALICE families are living in poverty, and this trend has progressively worsened in recent years due to the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic; and WHEREAS, rising temperatures and humidity due to climate change has caused increased need for air conditioning, resulting in the need for more electricity and further exacerbating the situation of energy insecurity for residents; and WHEREAS, Hawaii's electricity rates are the highest in the nation, at close to three times the national average; and WHEREAS, although the federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program is available for bill assistance, an average of only twenty percent of qualifying households actually receive benefits, leaving an obvious unmet need for bill assistance or rate relief to those in privation; and WHEREAS, the State's electric utilities do not offer utility specific low- to moderate-income discount rates and have limited, if any, bill assistance options; and WHEREAS, in recognition of these and other disparities contributing to high electricity burdens, some state utilities in Arizona, California, Georgia, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Vermont are authorized to offer lower rates to low- and limited-income customers to reduce residential electricity burden and ensure continued access to electrical power; and WHEREAS, when comparing electricity burden maps in the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism's electricity burden report to the Hawaii Statewide Energy Project Directory provided by the Hawaii State Energy Office, a substantial amount of the current and planned energy project locations are in or near areas that have higher electricity burdens; and WHEREAS, the communities that serve as geographic hosts for major energy projects receive the same project benefit of secure provision of service as all other ratepayers, yet must live with the burdens associated with hosting those projects and are neither offered compensation for doing so nor are generally meaningfully engaged in the planning process; and WHEREAS, the burdens host communities have shouldered include high concentrations of particulate air emissions, loss of open space, loss of other land uses, environmental concerns, and projects that are maligned with the host community's localized needs and priorities for provision of electrical service; and WHEREAS, without intentional and informed planning, progression toward the State's clean energy goals may therefore come at the expense of already burdened communities; and WHEREAS, current circumstances necessitate an explicit focus on energy and climate justice to ensure that the benefits and burdens of energy infrastructure development in the face of climate change are equitably distributed; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the House of Representatives of the Thirty-first Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2022, the Senate concurring, that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to consider efforts to mitigate high energy burdens for low- and moderate-income customers and investigate how to integrate considerations of energy equity and justice across its work; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to examine: (1) Low- and moderate-income rate discounts, bill credits, and direct payments and whether these would be appropriate in the State; (2) Expanded availability of utility bill assistance programs and whether adequate payment plan arrangements are available to low- and moderate-income customers who are facing economic challenges, such as loss of employment; (3) Measures to protect low- and moderate-income households, senior citizens, and households with infants from service disconnections, including reporting requirements for all utilities on the number of customers annually disconnected due to non-payment; (4) The advantages and disadvantages of rate design, program offerings, and the requirements of community benefits agreements to address energy burden, energy insecurity, and environmental and energy justice concerns related to energy projects and programs; and (5) Other customer-centric solutions to lessen the energy burden on low- and moderate-income customers and determine appropriate benefits above and beyond those accrued to the overall electric grid for communities that serve as geographic hosts to utility scale energy projects; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to establish the necessary proceeding or proceedings to conduct this examination; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to submit a report to the Legislature of its findings and recommendations, including any proposed legislation, no later than twenty days prior to the convening of the Regular Session of 2023; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Chairperson of the Public Utilities Commission. OFFERED BY: _____________________________ Report Title: Public Utilities Commission; Low- and Moderate-Income Customers; Energy Burden; Energy Equity and Justice
4646
4747 WHEREAS, many households in Hawaii have difficulty paying energy bills and suffer energy insecurity, in which they are faced with difficult choices, such as whether to sacrifice food or medicine to be able to pay for energy; and
4848
4949
5050
5151 WHEREAS, the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism found that "household electricity burden the percentage of household income spent on electricity bills is one of the key elements contributing to a household's energy insecurity, especially for low-income households"; and
5252
5353
5454
5555 WHEREAS, consequently, households with lower incomes are faced with higher levels of energy insecurity; and
5656
5757
5858
5959 WHEREAS, forty-two percent of households in the State live below the ALICE (asset limited, income constrained, employed) threshold, meaning that almost half of all families in Hawaii are struggling to make ends meet, even though they are employed; and
6060
6161
6262
6363 WHEREAS, additionally, nine percent of these ALICE families are living in poverty, and this trend has progressively worsened in recent years due to the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic; and
6464
6565
6666
67- WHEREAS, rising temperatures and humidity due to climate change have increased the need for air conditioning, resulting in the need for more electricity and further exacerbating the situation of energy insecurity for residents; and
67+ WHEREAS, rising temperatures and humidity due to climate change has caused increased need for air conditioning, resulting in the need for more electricity and further exacerbating the situation of energy insecurity for residents; and
6868
6969
7070
7171 WHEREAS, Hawaii's electricity rates are the highest in the nation, at close to three times the national average; and
7272
7373
7474
7575 WHEREAS, although the federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program is available for bill assistance, an average of only twenty percent of qualifying households actually receive benefits, leaving an obvious unmet need for bill assistance or rate relief to those in privation; and
7676
7777
7878
7979 WHEREAS, the State's electric utilities do not offer utility specific low- to moderate-income discount rates and have limited, if any, bill assistance options; and
8080
8181
8282
8383 WHEREAS, in recognition of these and other disparities contributing to high electricity burdens, some state utilities in Arizona, California, Georgia, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, and Vermont are authorized to offer lower rates to low- and limited-income customers to reduce residential electricity burden and ensure continued access to electrical power; and
8484
8585
8686
87- WHEREAS, when comparing electricity burden maps in the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism's electricity burden report to the Hawaii Statewide Energy Project Directory provided by the Hawaii State Energy Office, a substantial number of the current and planned energy project locations are in or near areas that have higher electricity burdens; and
87+ WHEREAS, when comparing electricity burden maps in the Department of Business, Economic Development, and Tourism's electricity burden report to the Hawaii Statewide Energy Project Directory provided by the Hawaii State Energy Office, a substantial amount of the current and planned energy project locations are in or near areas that have higher electricity burdens; and
8888
8989
9090
9191 WHEREAS, the communities that serve as geographic hosts for major energy projects receive the same project benefit of secure provision of service as all other ratepayers, yet must live with the burdens associated with hosting those projects and are neither offered compensation for doing so nor are generally meaningfully engaged in the planning process; and
9292
9393
9494
95- WHEREAS, the burdens host communities shoulder include high concentrations of particulate air emissions, loss of open space, loss of other land uses, environmental concerns, and projects that are maligned with the host community's localized needs and priorities for provision of electrical service; and
95+ WHEREAS, the burdens host communities have shouldered include high concentrations of particulate air emissions, loss of open space, loss of other land uses, environmental concerns, and projects that are maligned with the host community's localized needs and priorities for provision of electrical service; and
9696
9797
9898
9999 WHEREAS, without intentional and informed planning, progression toward the State's clean energy goals may therefore come at the expense of already burdened communities; and
100100
101101
102102
103- WHEREAS, current circumstances necessitate an explicit focus on energy and climate justice to ensure that the benefits and burdens of energy infrastructure development in the face of climate change are equitably distributed; and
103+ WHEREAS, current circumstances necessitate an explicit focus on energy and climate justice to ensure that the benefits and burdens of energy infrastructure development in the face of climate change are equitably distributed; now, therefore,
104104
105105
106106
107- WHEREAS, the Public Utilities Commission has worked on and continues to work on energy resource issues through its docket proceedings, such as docket no. 2019-0323, which is investigating distributed energy resource policies pertaining to the Hawaiian Electric Companies; now, therefore,
108-
109-
110-
111- BE IT RESOLVED by the House of Representatives of the Thirty-first Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2022, the Senate concurring, that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to consider efforts to mitigate high energy burdens for low- and moderate-income customers and input by the Consumer Advocate and investigate how to integrate considerations of energy equity and justice across its work; and
107+ BE IT RESOLVED by the House of Representatives of the Thirty-first Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2022, the Senate concurring, that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to consider efforts to mitigate high energy burdens for low- and moderate-income customers and investigate how to integrate considerations of energy equity and justice across its work; and
112108
113109
114110
115111 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to examine:
116112
117113
118114
119115 (1) Low- and moderate-income rate discounts, bill credits, and direct payments and whether these would be appropriate in the State;
120116
121117
122118
123119 (2) Expanded availability of utility bill assistance programs and whether adequate payment plan arrangements are available to low- and moderate-income customers who are facing economic challenges, such as loss of employment;
124120
125121
126122
127123 (3) Measures to protect low- and moderate-income households, senior citizens, and households with infants from service disconnections, including reporting requirements for all utilities on the number of customers annually disconnected due to non-payment;
128124
129125
130126
131127 (4) The advantages and disadvantages of rate design, program offerings, and the requirements of community benefits agreements to address energy burden, energy insecurity, and environmental and energy justice concerns related to energy projects and programs; and
132128
133129
134130
135131 (5) Other customer-centric solutions to lessen the energy burden on low- and moderate-income customers and determine appropriate benefits above and beyond those accrued to the overall electric grid for communities that serve as geographic hosts to utility scale energy projects; and
136132
137133
138134
139- BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to establish the necessary proceeding or proceedings to conduct this examination; provided that the proceedings are not duplicative, but rather focus on the need for integration of energy equity and justice in the ongoing and future work of the Public Utilities Commission; and
135+ BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to establish the necessary proceeding or proceedings to conduct this examination; and
140136
141137
142138
143139 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Public Utilities Commission is requested to submit a report to the Legislature of its findings and recommendations, including any proposed legislation, no later than twenty days prior to the convening of the Regular Session of 2023; and
144140
145141
146142
147- BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that certified copies of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Chairperson of the Public Utilities Commission and Department of Commerce and Consumer Affairs Consumer Advocate.
143+ BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Chairperson of the Public Utilities Commission.
148144
149145
146+
147+
148+
149+
150+
151+ OFFERED BY: _____________________________
152+
153+
154+
155+OFFERED BY:
156+
157+_____________________________
150158
151159
152160
153161
154162
155163 Report Title:
156164
157165 Public Utilities Commission; Low- and Moderate-Income Customers; Energy Burden; Energy Equity and Justice