Hawaii 2022 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SCR112 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.

Old	New	Differences
1	1	THE SENATE S.C.R. NO. 112 THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022 STATE OF HAWAII SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION urging the governor to comply with the Hawaii Supreme Court ruling in Kalima v. State of Hawaii and stop OPPOSING the payment of damages to beneficiaries harmed by the State's breach of trust.
2	2
3	3	THE SENATE S.C.R. NO. 112
4	4	THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022
5	5	STATE OF HAWAII
6	6
7	7	THE SENATE
8	8
9	9	S.C.R. NO.
10	10
11	11	112
12	12
13	13	THIRTY-FIRST LEGISLATURE, 2022
14	14
15	15
16	16
17	17	STATE OF HAWAII
18	18
19	19
20	20
21	21
22	22
23	23
24	24
25	25
26	26
27	27
28	28
29	29	SENATE CONCURRENT
30	30
31	31	RESOLUTION
32	32
33	33
34	34
35	35
36	36
37	37	urging the governor to comply with the Hawaii Supreme Court ruling in Kalima v. State of Hawaii and stop OPPOSING the payment of damages to beneficiaries harmed by the State's breach of trust.
38	38
39	39
40	40
41	41
42	42
43	43	WHEREAS, the Hawaiian Home Lands Trust Individual Claims Review Panel (Panel) was established in 1991 pursuant to chapter 674, Hawaii Revised Statutes, to provide native Hawaiian beneficiaries of the Hawaii Home Lands Program to pursue their claims for breach of trust through administrative and judicial venues; and WHEREAS, the Panel did not complete its work by 1999 and the legislative action to extend the Panel's work was vetoed by the Governor that same year, leaving over four thousand claims by 2,721 claimants in limbo; and WHEREAS, in 1999, a lawsuit brought by beneficiaries of the Hawaiian Home Lands Trust was filed in the First Circuit Court, titled Kalima v. State of Hawaii, which was affirmed by the First Circuit Court as a class action case in 2000 and that order was appealed by the State in 2001; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii Supreme Court in Kalima v. State of Hawaii ruled in 2006 that claimants have a right to sue for monetary damages in circuit court for breaches of trust that occurred between 1959 through 1998; and WHEREAS, in 2007, the claimants' motion for certification of subclasses was granted with the largest subclass for those on the waiting list, comprising of nearly seventy percent of all class members; and WHEREAS, in 2009, the First Circuit Court ruled that the State had breached its trust obligations to Hawaiian home lands beneficiaries on the waiting list and was financially liable for the delays in beneficiaries receiving homesteads; and WHEREAS, in 2011, the First Circuit Court determined that a waiting list subclass-wide damages model would be adopted that would measure each applicants damages by the length of time that they waited for a homestead; and WHEREAS, in 2018, the First Circuit Court's final judgment ruled in favor of the waiting list subclass of native Hawaiian beneficiaries and the State immediately appealed the decision contending that it did not breach its trust obligations to claimants and therefore should not be liable for damages; and WHEREAS, in 2020, the Hawaii Supreme Court ruled that the State breached its duties as trustee of the Hawaii Home Lands Trust, that the fair market value model is an adequate method for approximating actual damages from the time beneficiaries applied to be on the waitlist, and that the State bears the burden of proving if an individual beneficiary is entitled to reduced damages for any reason; and WHEREAS, the Hawaii Supreme Court stated that, "[i]t is clear to us that the State, by mismanaging the Trust, failing to keep adequate records, and continuing to litigate this case for decades, is creating a situation in which it would be difficult to accurately assess damages"; and WHEREAS, Kalima v. State of Hawaii is still being contentiously litigated in the First Circuit Court because the State seems unwilling to amicably and responsibly settle any outstanding issues about administering the claims process and calculating the damages for eligible claimants; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate of the Thirty-first Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2022, the House of Representatives concurring, that the Governor is urged to expeditiously comply with the Hawaii Supreme Court ruling in Kalima v. State of Hawaii and stop opposing the payment of damages to beneficiaries harmed by the State's breach of trust; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Governor. OFFERED BY: _____________________________ Report Title: Hawaiian Home Lands; Beneficiaries; Damages; Governor
44	44
45	45	WHEREAS, the Hawaiian Home Lands Trust Individual Claims Review Panel (Panel) was established in 1991 pursuant to chapter 674, Hawaii Revised Statutes, to provide native Hawaiian beneficiaries of the Hawaii Home Lands Program to pursue their claims for breach of trust through administrative and judicial venues; and
46	46
47	47
48	48
49	49	WHEREAS, the Panel did not complete its work by 1999 and the legislative action to extend the Panel's work was vetoed by the Governor that same year, leaving over four thousand claims by 2,721 claimants in limbo; and
50	50
51	51
52	52
53	53	WHEREAS, in 1999, a lawsuit brought by beneficiaries of the Hawaiian Home Lands Trust was filed in the First Circuit Court, titled Kalima v. State of Hawaii, which was affirmed by the First Circuit Court as a class action case in 2000 and that order was appealed by the State in 2001; and
54	54
55	55
56	56
57	57	WHEREAS, the Hawaii Supreme Court in Kalima v. State of Hawaii ruled in 2006 that claimants have a right to sue for monetary damages in circuit court for breaches of trust that occurred between 1959 through 1998; and
58	58
59	59
60	60
61	61	WHEREAS, in 2007, the claimants' motion for certification of subclasses was granted with the largest subclass for those on the waiting list, comprising of nearly seventy percent of all class members; and
62	62
63	63
64	64
65	65	WHEREAS, in 2009, the First Circuit Court ruled that the State had breached its trust obligations to Hawaiian home lands beneficiaries on the waiting list and was financially liable for the delays in beneficiaries receiving homesteads; and
66	66
67	67
68	68
69	69	WHEREAS, in 2011, the First Circuit Court determined that a waiting list subclass-wide damages model would be adopted that would measure each applicants damages by the length of time that they waited for a homestead; and
70	70
71	71
72	72
73	73	WHEREAS, in 2018, the First Circuit Court's final judgment ruled in favor of the waiting list subclass of native Hawaiian beneficiaries and the State immediately appealed the decision contending that it did not breach its trust obligations to claimants and therefore should not be liable for damages; and
74	74
75	75
76	76
77	77	WHEREAS, in 2020, the Hawaii Supreme Court ruled that the State breached its duties as trustee of the Hawaii Home Lands Trust, that the fair market value model is an adequate method for approximating actual damages from the time beneficiaries applied to be on the waitlist, and that the State bears the burden of proving if an individual beneficiary is entitled to reduced damages for any reason; and
78	78
79	79
80	80
81	81	WHEREAS, the Hawaii Supreme Court stated that, "[i]t is clear to us that the State, by mismanaging the Trust, failing to keep adequate records, and continuing to litigate this case for decades, is creating a situation in which it would be difficult to accurately assess damages"; and
82	82
83	83
84	84
85	85	WHEREAS, Kalima v. State of Hawaii is still being contentiously litigated in the First Circuit Court because the State seems unwilling to amicably and responsibly settle any outstanding issues about administering the claims process and calculating the damages for eligible claimants; now, therefore,
86	86
87	87
88	88
89	89	BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate of the Thirty-first Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2022, the House of Representatives concurring, that the Governor is urged to expeditiously comply with the Hawaii Supreme Court ruling in Kalima v. State of Hawaii and stop opposing the payment of damages to beneficiaries harmed by the State's breach of trust; and
90	90
91	91
92	92
93	93	BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a certified copy of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Governor.
94	94
95	95
96	96
97	97
98	98
99	99
100	100
101	101	OFFERED BY: _____________________________
102	102
103	103
104	104
105	105	OFFERED BY:
106	106
107	107	_____________________________
108	108
109	109
110	110
111	111
112	112
113	113	Report Title:
114	114
115	115	Hawaiian Home Lands; Beneficiaries; Damages; Governor