Hawaii 2024 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SB1499 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.
OldNewDifferences
11 THE SENATE S.B. NO. 1499 THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023 STATE OF HAWAII A BILL FOR AN ACT RELATING TO TARO. BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF HAWAII:
22
33 THE SENATE S.B. NO. 1499
44 THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023
55 STATE OF HAWAII
66
77 THE SENATE
88
99 S.B. NO.
1010
1111 1499
1212
1313 THIRTY-SECOND LEGISLATURE, 2023
1414
1515
1616
1717 STATE OF HAWAII
1818
1919
2020
2121
2222
2323
2424
2525
2626
2727
2828
2929
3030
3131 A BILL FOR AN ACT
3232
3333
3434
3535
3636
3737 RELATING TO TARO.
3838
3939
4040
4141
4242
4343 BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF HAWAII:
4444
4545
4646
4747 SECTION 1. The legislature finds that Hawaii imports eighty-five per cent of its food and is considered highly vulnerable in issues of food security. Climate change significantly increases this vulnerability with sea level rise and intensified weather patterns in the Pacific, such as droughts, hurricanes, and floods. In the search for proactive adaptive mechanisms to mitigate climate change and increase food security in Hawaii, the legislature finds that kalo, or taro, and loi kalo, or wetland taro systems, are recognized for their culturally-grounded foundational role in food security and their functionality and resilience as riparian buffers and sediment retention basins. Underground foods, such as taro, can often survive hurricane or flood events and be harvested to address immediate food shortages where the capacity to store and cook food can be retained. The legislature additionally finds that the department of agriculture has identified staple starches as the greatest food security risk in the State. Taro is one of Hawaii's highest yielding staple starch food crops, producing ten thousand pounds and twenty thousand pounds per acre per annum under wet and dry cultivation, respectively. As a hypoallergenic complex carbohydrate, taro plays an essential role in the health of families, particularly for native Hawaiians, in its traditional forms of cooked taro, poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo. Yet, the cost of these foods remains inaccessible to families most in need of these important staple starch foods. In 2016, at the International Union of Conservation of Nature World Conservation Congress, the governor pledged to double food production in Hawaii by 2030 as part of Hawaii's commitment to its residents and the world and in order to begin to address this inequity at home. Significant headway has yet to be made towards this goal. The legislature further finds that taro is severely underproduced in the State. The 2021 marketing survey of the Hawaii department of agriculture reported four hundred eighteen acres of taro in wetland and dryland production. An equal amount of acreage is estimated to be unreported or in subsistence taro cultivation. Annual reported production averages four million tons. However, imported taro exceeds two million, leaving a wide gap between in-state production, out-of-state imports, and local demand. The legislature also finds that small farms on twenty acres or less, inclusive of taro and all other types of vegetable and fruit production, make up the majority of farms in Hawaii (ninety-six per cent) and produce a significant portion of locally-grown and locally-consumed food on each island. The 2017 census of agriculture reports that the average small-scale farmer in Hawaii makes less than $40,000 per year, with losses of almost $10,000 annually due to the highly inflated costs of farming, including imported equipment, materials and inputs, land, lease rent rates, and water. There is an urgent need to better support small farmers. The legislature further finds that, in its report to the 2010 legislature, the taro security and purity task force made several recommendations to make taro farming affordable, including improving access to land, water, mentoring, and economic incentives. The counties of Maui and Kauai have enacted ordinances that exempt kuleana lands in active taro production from county taxes. These ordinances provide limited relief to some taro farms but are not available in all counties or to all taro growers and are insufficient for young farmers to offset the typically low incomes experienced in taro farming. The legislature affirms that taro is inextricably linked to Hawaiian identity and cultural integrity. The ongoing survival and revitalization of taro production is vital to family and community health and well-being in the Native Hawaiian community and beyond. Taro farming and taro farms are an iconic visual image for Hawaii that demands protection. Pursuant to section 5-15.5, Hawaii Revised Statutes, taro is recognized as the official plant of the State for these reasons and more. Cooked taro, poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo are locally-made traditional food products that are unique to Hawaii and Hawaiian culture, with the exception of cooked taro known in the Pacific, Asia, and other parts of the world. The legislature additionally finds that, in 1901, the first legislature of the Territory of Hawaii recognized the role that taro played in feeding the nation by passing Senate Bill No. 87 to encourage the cultivation of taro by exempting taro and the cultivation of taro from all state taxes. While Senate Bill No. 87 was never signed into law, its intentions were clear in encouraging the production of more taro. The legislature also finds that, in recognition of the critical importance of protecting and perpetuating the traditional practice of taro farming as part of Hawaii's cultural identity and its role in local food security, there is a compelling interest in enacting a law in the present day that is similar to Senate Bill No. 87. Accordingly, the purpose of this Act is to create stronger economic incentives to protect the Hawaiian traditions of taro and taro farming, to encourage new taro farmers, improve the livelihoods of existing taro farmers, and reduce the cost of poi and other healthy taro-based foods for local families by: (1) Exempting income derived from the business of taro cultivation or production of taro products from the income tax; and (2) Exempting from the general excise tax the gross proceeds or income received from the sale of any product resulting from the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro. SECTION 2. Chapter 235, Hawaii Revised Statutes, is amended by adding a new section to be appropriately designated and to read as follows: "§235- Taro cultivation and production; exemption. (a) Except as provided in section 235-2.4 (relating to "unrelated business taxable income") and sections 235-61 to 235-67 (relating to withholding and collection of tax at source), the income of qualified taxpayers engaged in the business of taro cultivation and production of taro products shall not be taxable; provided that the exemption provided under this section shall not apply to the sale or proceeds of the sale of taro lands. (b) For the purposes of this section, taro cultivation and production of taro products include the following activities: (1) The cultivation of taro plants, taro corm, leaf, and taro huli on taro farms or portions of farms dedicated to taro plants, taro corm, leaf, and taro huli; (2) The planting of taro on taro lands, including the practice of rotating between fallow lands to lands in active taro production by each individual grower; and (3) The preparation of taro products produced with taro and taro leaf. (c) The department of taxation may consult with the office of Hawaiian affairs in the administration of the exemption provided under this section. (d) For the purposes of this section: "Cooked taro" means raw taro that is steamed, baked, or boiled to render it edible and safe to eat. "Kulolo" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting primarily of grated taro, coconut milk, and sugar or honey, which is baked or steamed into a dense pudding. "Laulau" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting of meat or starch that is wrapped in taro leaves, which may or may not be wrapped in ti leaf, and steamed. "Luau" means raw taro leaf. "Luau" or "luau stew" also means a traditional Hawaiian food, consisting primarily of cooked taro leaf and Hawaiian salt, which may also contain meat or meat broth and other ingredients. "Poi" means a traditional Hawaiian staple food, made from cooked taro and water, and milled or pounded into a paste. "Qualified taxpayer" means an individual engaged in: (1) The production of taro or taro products for sale, or the use of land for taro farming; and (2) The manufacturing, compounding, canning, preserving, milling, processing, refining, or preparing taro for sale. "Raw taro" means uncooked taro corm. "Taro corm" means the starchy underground portion of the taro plant. "Taro corm" is known as "kalo" in the Hawaiian language. "Taro huli" means a taro top, as used for planting, where the upright stem is cut below the leaf and below the top of the corm of the taro, such that it includes a piece of the corm at its base where roots can emerge. "Taro products" includes taro huli, raw or cooked taro, and the traditional Hawaiian foods of poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo." SECTION 3. Chapter 237, Hawaii Revised Statutes, is amended by adding a new section to be appropriately designated and to read as follows: "§237- Exemption for the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro. (a) There shall be exempted from, and excluded from the measure of, the taxes imposed by this chapter all of the gross proceeds or income received from the sale of any product resulting from the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro, or of any taro product of which the primary ingredient is taro or taro leaf. This exemption shall solely and only apply to farmers and direct producers of taro and taro products. (b) As used in this section: "Cooked taro" means raw taro that is steamed, baked, or boiled to render it edible and safe to eat. "Kulolo" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting primarily of grated taro, coconut milk, and sugar or honey, which is baked or steamed into a dense pudding. "Laulau" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting of meat or starch that is wrapped in taro leaves, which may or may not be wrapped in ti leaf, and steamed. "Luau" means raw taro leaf. "Luau" or "luau stew" also means a traditional Hawaiian food, consisting primarily of cooked taro leaf and Hawaiian salt, which may also contain meat or meat broth and other ingredients. "Poi" means a traditional Hawaiian staple food, made from cooked taro and water, and milled or pounded into a paste. "Primary ingredient" means the ingredient of highest percentage in a product and listed first on the product's label. "Raw taro" means uncooked taro corm. "Taro corm" means the starchy underground portion of the taro plant. "Taro corm" is known as "kalo" in the Hawaiian language. "Taro huli" means a taro top, as used for planting, where the upright stem is cut below the leaf and below the top of the corm of the taro, such that it includes a piece of the corm at its base where roots can emerge. "Taro products" includes taro huli, raw or cooked taro, and the traditional Hawaiian foods of poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo." SECTION 4. New statutory material is underscored. SECTION 5. This Act shall take effect on January 1, 2024; provided that section 2 shall apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2023. INTRODUCED BY: _____________________________
4848
4949 SECTION 1. The legislature finds that Hawaii imports eighty-five per cent of its food and is considered highly vulnerable in issues of food security. Climate change significantly increases this vulnerability with sea level rise and intensified weather patterns in the Pacific, such as droughts, hurricanes, and floods. In the search for proactive adaptive mechanisms to mitigate climate change and increase food security in Hawaii, the legislature finds that kalo, or taro, and loi kalo, or wetland taro systems, are recognized for their culturally-grounded foundational role in food security and their functionality and resilience as riparian buffers and sediment retention basins. Underground foods, such as taro, can often survive hurricane or flood events and be harvested to address immediate food shortages where the capacity to store and cook food can be retained.
5050
5151 The legislature additionally finds that the department of agriculture has identified staple starches as the greatest food security risk in the State. Taro is one of Hawaii's highest yielding staple starch food crops, producing ten thousand pounds and twenty thousand pounds per acre per annum under wet and dry cultivation, respectively. As a hypoallergenic complex carbohydrate, taro plays an essential role in the health of families, particularly for native Hawaiians, in its traditional forms of cooked taro, poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo. Yet, the cost of these foods remains inaccessible to families most in need of these important staple starch foods. In 2016, at the International Union of Conservation of Nature World Conservation Congress, the governor pledged to double food production in Hawaii by 2030 as part of Hawaii's commitment to its residents and the world and in order to begin to address this inequity at home. Significant headway has yet to be made towards this goal.
5252
5353 The legislature further finds that taro is severely underproduced in the State. The 2021 marketing survey of the Hawaii department of agriculture reported four hundred eighteen acres of taro in wetland and dryland production. An equal amount of acreage is estimated to be unreported or in subsistence taro cultivation. Annual reported production averages four million tons. However, imported taro exceeds two million, leaving a wide gap between in-state production, out-of-state imports, and local demand.
5454
5555 The legislature also finds that small farms on twenty acres or less, inclusive of taro and all other types of vegetable and fruit production, make up the majority of farms in Hawaii (ninety-six per cent) and produce a significant portion of locally-grown and locally-consumed food on each island. The 2017 census of agriculture reports that the average small-scale farmer in Hawaii makes less than $40,000 per year, with losses of almost $10,000 annually due to the highly inflated costs of farming, including imported equipment, materials and inputs, land, lease rent rates, and water. There is an urgent need to better support small farmers.
5656
5757 The legislature further finds that, in its report to the 2010 legislature, the taro security and purity task force made several recommendations to make taro farming affordable, including improving access to land, water, mentoring, and economic incentives. The counties of Maui and Kauai have enacted ordinances that exempt kuleana lands in active taro production from county taxes. These ordinances provide limited relief to some taro farms but are not available in all counties or to all taro growers and are insufficient for young farmers to offset the typically low incomes experienced in taro farming.
5858
5959 The legislature affirms that taro is inextricably linked to Hawaiian identity and cultural integrity. The ongoing survival and revitalization of taro production is vital to family and community health and well-being in the Native Hawaiian community and beyond. Taro farming and taro farms are an iconic visual image for Hawaii that demands protection. Pursuant to section 5-15.5, Hawaii Revised Statutes, taro is recognized as the official plant of the State for these reasons and more. Cooked taro, poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo are locally-made traditional food products that are unique to Hawaii and Hawaiian culture, with the exception of cooked taro known in the Pacific, Asia, and other parts of the world.
6060
6161 The legislature additionally finds that, in 1901, the first legislature of the Territory of Hawaii recognized the role that taro played in feeding the nation by passing Senate Bill No. 87 to encourage the cultivation of taro by exempting taro and the cultivation of taro from all state taxes. While Senate Bill No. 87 was never signed into law, its intentions were clear in encouraging the production of more taro.
6262
6363 The legislature also finds that, in recognition of the critical importance of protecting and perpetuating the traditional practice of taro farming as part of Hawaii's cultural identity and its role in local food security, there is a compelling interest in enacting a law in the present day that is similar to Senate Bill No. 87.
6464
6565 Accordingly, the purpose of this Act is to create stronger economic incentives to protect the Hawaiian traditions of taro and taro farming, to encourage new taro farmers, improve the livelihoods of existing taro farmers, and reduce the cost of poi and other healthy taro-based foods for local families by:
6666
6767 (1) Exempting income derived from the business of taro cultivation or production of taro products from the income tax; and
6868
6969 (2) Exempting from the general excise tax the gross proceeds or income received from the sale of any product resulting from the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro.
7070
7171 SECTION 2. Chapter 235, Hawaii Revised Statutes, is amended by adding a new section to be appropriately designated and to read as follows:
7272
7373 "§235- Taro cultivation and production; exemption. (a) Except as provided in section 235-2.4 (relating to "unrelated business taxable income") and sections 235-61 to 235-67 (relating to withholding and collection of tax at source), the income of qualified taxpayers engaged in the business of taro cultivation and production of taro products shall not be taxable; provided that the exemption provided under this section shall not apply to the sale or proceeds of the sale of taro lands.
7474
7575 (b) For the purposes of this section, taro cultivation and production of taro products include the following activities:
7676
7777 (1) The cultivation of taro plants, taro corm, leaf, and taro huli on taro farms or portions of farms dedicated to taro plants, taro corm, leaf, and taro huli;
7878
7979 (2) The planting of taro on taro lands, including the practice of rotating between fallow lands to lands in active taro production by each individual grower; and
8080
8181 (3) The preparation of taro products produced with taro and taro leaf.
8282
8383 (c) The department of taxation may consult with the office of Hawaiian affairs in the administration of the exemption provided under this section.
8484
8585 (d) For the purposes of this section:
8686
8787 "Cooked taro" means raw taro that is steamed, baked, or boiled to render it edible and safe to eat.
8888
8989 "Kulolo" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting primarily of grated taro, coconut milk, and sugar or honey, which is baked or steamed into a dense pudding.
9090
9191 "Laulau" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting of meat or starch that is wrapped in taro leaves, which may or may not be wrapped in ti leaf, and steamed.
9292
9393 "Luau" means raw taro leaf. "Luau" or "luau stew" also means a traditional Hawaiian food, consisting primarily of cooked taro leaf and Hawaiian salt, which may also contain meat or meat broth and other ingredients.
9494
9595 "Poi" means a traditional Hawaiian staple food, made from cooked taro and water, and milled or pounded into a paste.
9696
9797 "Qualified taxpayer" means an individual engaged in:
9898
9999 (1) The production of taro or taro products for sale, or the use of land for taro farming; and
100100
101101 (2) The manufacturing, compounding, canning, preserving, milling, processing, refining, or preparing taro for sale.
102102
103103 "Raw taro" means uncooked taro corm.
104104
105105 "Taro corm" means the starchy underground portion of the taro plant. "Taro corm" is known as "kalo" in the Hawaiian language.
106106
107107 "Taro huli" means a taro top, as used for planting, where the upright stem is cut below the leaf and below the top of the corm of the taro, such that it includes a piece of the corm at its base where roots can emerge.
108108
109109 "Taro products" includes taro huli, raw or cooked taro, and the traditional Hawaiian foods of poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo."
110110
111111 SECTION 3. Chapter 237, Hawaii Revised Statutes, is amended by adding a new section to be appropriately designated and to read as follows:
112112
113113 "§237- Exemption for the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro. (a) There shall be exempted from, and excluded from the measure of, the taxes imposed by this chapter all of the gross proceeds or income received from the sale of any product resulting from the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro, or of any taro product of which the primary ingredient is taro or taro leaf. This exemption shall solely and only apply to farmers and direct producers of taro and taro products.
114114
115115 (b) As used in this section:
116116
117117 "Cooked taro" means raw taro that is steamed, baked, or boiled to render it edible and safe to eat.
118118
119119 "Kulolo" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting primarily of grated taro, coconut milk, and sugar or honey, which is baked or steamed into a dense pudding.
120120
121121 "Laulau" means a traditional Hawaiian food consisting of meat or starch that is wrapped in taro leaves, which may or may not be wrapped in ti leaf, and steamed.
122122
123123 "Luau" means raw taro leaf. "Luau" or "luau stew" also means a traditional Hawaiian food, consisting primarily of cooked taro leaf and Hawaiian salt, which may also contain meat or meat broth and other ingredients.
124124
125125 "Poi" means a traditional Hawaiian staple food, made from cooked taro and water, and milled or pounded into a paste.
126126
127127 "Primary ingredient" means the ingredient of highest percentage in a product and listed first on the product's label.
128128
129129 "Raw taro" means uncooked taro corm.
130130
131131 "Taro corm" means the starchy underground portion of the taro plant. "Taro corm" is known as "kalo" in the Hawaiian language.
132132
133133 "Taro huli" means a taro top, as used for planting, where the upright stem is cut below the leaf and below the top of the corm of the taro, such that it includes a piece of the corm at its base where roots can emerge.
134134
135135 "Taro products" includes taro huli, raw or cooked taro, and the traditional Hawaiian foods of poi, luau, laulau, and kulolo."
136136
137137 SECTION 4. New statutory material is underscored.
138138
139139 SECTION 5. This Act shall take effect on January 1, 2024; provided that section 2 shall apply to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2023.
140140
141141
142142
143143 INTRODUCED BY: _____________________________
144144
145145 INTRODUCED BY:
146146
147147 _____________________________
148148
149149
150150
151151
152152
153153 Report Title: Taro; Cultivation and Production; Traditional Hawaiian foods; Income Tax; General Excise Tax; Exemption Description: Exempts income derived from the business of taro cultivation or production of taro products from the income tax. Exempts from the general excise tax the gross proceeds or income received from the sale of any product resulting from the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro. The summary description of legislation appearing on this page is for informational purposes only and is not legislation or evidence of legislative intent.
154154
155155
156156
157157
158158
159159 Report Title:
160160
161161 Taro; Cultivation and Production; Traditional Hawaiian foods; Income Tax; General Excise Tax; Exemption
162162
163163
164164
165165 Description:
166166
167167 Exempts income derived from the business of taro cultivation or production of taro products from the income tax. Exempts from the general excise tax the gross proceeds or income received from the sale of any product resulting from the cultivation and production of unprocessed taro.
168168
169169
170170
171171
172172
173173
174174
175175 The summary description of legislation appearing on this page is for informational purposes only and is not legislation or evidence of legislative intent.