Relating To State Boating Facilities.
The bill allows the Board of Land and Natural Resources to lease the Ala Wai small boat harbor in its entirety for private development, operation, and management, either through public auction, request for proposals, or direct negotiation. This shift towards public-private partnerships is expected to enhance the overall condition of the harbor, as it capitalizes on the management experience exemplified by the already successful private management at Kewalo Basin harbor. Supporters argue that this approach will create an inviting atmosphere for both residents and tourists, ultimately benefiting local economies and improving user experience.
House Bill 210, introduced in the Hawaii legislature, proposes the establishment of a state boating facility lease program specifically for the Ala Wai small boat harbor on Oahu. The bill aims to address longstanding operational challenges faced by the Division of Boating and Ocean Recreation (DOBOR), which has struggled with inadequate staffing and funding to fulfill its statutory mandates regarding ocean recreation management and maintenance of state small boat harbors. The Act recognizes over $1.1 billion in deferred maintenance costs, exacerbated by inflation and rising construction expenses, which has resulted in facilities remaining in significant disrepair and user conflicts arising from mismanagement and inadequate oversight.
Despite the potential benefits, the bill has faced contention regarding the implications of privatizing state-managed facilities. Critics are concerned that outsourcing management to private entities may result in reduced access or increased costs for local users, with priorities shifting from public interest to profit-driven motives. Additionally, there are fears that the long-term leases, expiring by June 30, 2045, could bind future legislative actions and opportunities to address community needs and environmental concerns effectively. Ensuring that public interests are maintained over commercial gains remains a key point of debate among lawmakers and constituents.