Hawaii 2025 Regular Session

Hawaii House Bill HR75

Introduced
3/6/25  

Caption

Urging The Legislature To Conduct Mandatory Inquiries Into All Fatalities And Serious Injuries That Occurred To Children Involved In Child Welfare Services.

Impact

The bill aims to initiate thorough investigations into these incidents to identify the root causes of the failures that have allowed such tragedies to occur. Key points of focus include communication breakdowns among staff and agencies, inexperience of social workers, failure to follow established procedures, and inadequate resources within the Department. These inquiries are intended to promote transparency and ensure that similar systemic failures do not recur, promoting a more robust support system for vulnerable children.

Summary

House Resolution 75 (HR75) urges the legislature of Hawaii to conduct mandatory inquiries into fatalities and serious injuries that have occurred to children involved in Child Welfare Services. The resolution arises from troubling reports of systemic failures within the Department of Human Services (DHS), particularly regarding neglect in foster care and unsafe reunifications that have led to numerous tragic outcomes. There have been at least nineteen reported cases of fatalities or serious injuries since 1997, leading to substantial financial settlements and lawsuits against the state, highlighting a concerning trend of negligence within the system.

Contention

A notable aspect of the discussion surrounding HR75 is the comparison to practices in other states, such as California, Florida, and Colorado, which have implemented more transparent and accountable systems for handling child welfare cases and have experienced fewer tragic outcomes. There is a call for the state legislature to take more proactive measures, including enacting laws based on the inquiry findings, to uphold public trust in the welfare system effectively. The resolution acknowledges past legal actions as complex and lengthy, emphasizing the need for a more immediate and preventive approach to child safety.

Conclusions

If passed, HR75 could significantly influence state law by ensuring that systemic failures are addressed comprehensively, which may lead to new legislative measures aimed at improving child welfare practices. This could potentially set a precedent for accountability and oversight, reshaping the interaction between the state and its child welfare systems, ensuring that children's safety and well-being become paramount in the policies enacted by the legislature.

Companion Bills

HI HCR82

Same As Urging The Legislature To Conduct Mandatory Inquiries Into All Fatalities And Serious Injuries That Occurred To Children Involved In Child Welfare Services.

Similar Bills

TX HB2492

Relating to the family allowance, treatment of exempt property, and an allowance in lieu of exempt property in the administration of a decedent's estate.

CA AB1221

Children’s advocacy centers.

CA SB18

Bill of Rights for the Children and Youth of California: joint legislative committee.

CA SB1447

Hospitals: seismic compliance: Children’s Hospital Los Angeles.

CA AB1737

Children’s camps: safety.

CA AB555

California state preschool programs: reimbursement amounts: adjustment factors.

CA AR68

Relative to Children’s Environmental Health Month 2021.

CA AR123

Relative to Children’s Environmental Health Month.