Hawaii 2025 Regular Session

Hawaii Senate Bill SCR185 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.

Old	New	Differences
1	1	THE SENATE S.C.R. NO. 185 THIRTY-THIRD LEGISLATURE, 2025 STATE OF HAWAII SENATE CONCURRENT RESOLUTION urging the LEGISLATURE to conduct mandatory inquiries into all fatalities and serious injuries that occurred to children involved in child welfare services.
2	2
3	3	THE SENATE S.C.R. NO. 185
4	4	THIRTY-THIRD LEGISLATURE, 2025
5	5	STATE OF HAWAII
6	6
7	7	THE SENATE
8	8
9	9	S.C.R. NO.
10	10
11	11	185
12	12
13	13	THIRTY-THIRD LEGISLATURE, 2025
14	14
15	15
16	16
17	17	STATE OF HAWAII
18	18
19	19
20	20
21	21
22	22
23	23
24	24
25	25
26	26
27	27
28	28
29	29	SENATE CONCURRENT
30	30
31	31	RESOLUTION
32	32
33	33
34	34
35	35
36	36
37	37	urging the LEGISLATURE to conduct mandatory inquiries into all fatalities and serious injuries that occurred to children involved in child welfare services.
38	38
39	39
40	40
41	41
42	42
43	43
44	44
45	45	WHEREAS, the Department of Human Services (DHS), Child Welfare Services Branch has experienced a troubling number of child fatalities and serious injuries resulting from systemic failures, including neglect in foster care placements and unsafe reunifications; and WHEREAS, nineteen child fatalities or serious injuries have been reported since 1997 and over ten million dollars have been paid out in lawsuits so far; and WHEREAS, in the case of Reubyne, who was beaten in 1997 and is still in a vegetative state, DHS was sued for negligence and settled for two million dollars; and WHEREAS, in the case of Peter Boy Kema, who was murdered in 1997 though his body was never found, his family was involved in multiple Child Welfare Services cases and ultimately reunified; however, a Special Masters report states that the Department should never have reunified, the father was convicted, and a lawsuit is pending; and WHEREAS, in 1999 a Waianae family was given permanent guardianship over a group of children, who after reaching adulthood, successfully sued DHS following the parents' conviction for assault and sexual abuse in 2005; and WHEREAS, in the case of Alexis Cabantang, who was left with permanent disabilities after she was beaten and nearly died in 2005, her guardian was sentenced to twenty years in prison and the Department of Education was successfully sued for failure to report her injuries to Child Welfare Services; and WHEREAS, in the case of Cyrus Belt, who was thrown over a freeway overpass in Honolulu in 2008, the responsible party was sentenced to life in prison and DHS settled a lawsuit brought by the father for not intervening despite having been notified six days prior that the mother was using methamphetamine; and WHEREAS, in the case of Braden McVeigh, who was murdered in 2009 after being reunited with his father over the objections of the grandmother, DHS was successfully sued; and WHEREAS, in 2012, Zion McKeown was beaten to death at the age of four after being reunified with the parents despite multiple warnings against reunification; and WHEREAS, in the case of Ronela Pascual, who was critically injured in 2008 after reunification which left her unable to communicate until her death in 2013 at the age of eleven; and WHEREAS, in the case of Zachary Durto-Burgess, who was beaten to death after being reunified with his parents in 2010, his parents were sentenced to life in prison; and WHEREAS, Zack Morris was convicted of sexual abuse and DHS was successfully sued by the boys who were placed in his foster home despite suspicions of child abuse in other states; and WHEREAS, Fabian Garcia died in her foster home on Big Island due to blunt force trauma and has yet to receive justice; and WHEREAS, Shaelyn Stone was withdrawn from public school and died of starvation in 2017; thereafter, her parents and grandparent were all convicted of manslaughter; and WHEREAS, a seven day old infant died of brain damage at Tripler Hospital after an older sibling similarly died of injuries, and the parents were later convicted of murder for both children in 2020; and WHEREAS, in 2020 a lawsuit was filed against DHS for overlooking systemic abuse in a foster home where the eleven adopted children were forced into slave labor, molested, and starved before a teen child ultimately killed the abusive adoptive mother; and WHEREAS, Ariel Sellers was murdered in 2021 at the age of six after being starved, gagged, and kept in a dog cage by her adoptive parents who are currently in jail awaiting second degree murder charges; and WHEREAS, in 2021 an infant was declared deceased after Child Welfare Services had been called in to investigate the situation months earlier but decided not to open a case; and WHEREAS, Bula Mahoe was charged with sexual abuse of his parents' foster children; and WHEREAS, Caitano used foster children to conduct an illegal drug ring in 2022, and was ultimately indicted for that offense along with sexual abuse and physical abuse; and WHEREAS, Geanna Bradley was found dead in her home in 2024 after being starved and physically abused by her guardians, who are now charged with second degree murder, and another child in the home was found in very serious condition; and WHEREAS, repeated failures to act upon warnings and ensure child safety have resulted in preventable deaths and injuries; and WHEREAS, despite a 2005 policy directive (DHS 2005-PA-3) requiring safety concerns to be immediately reported to judges, these warnings have often been ignored; and WHEREAS, lawsuits for some of the child fatality and serious injury cases have been successful, but they are complex, expensive, and time-consuming, while in the meantime, there is no assurance that preventative measures have been taken by DHS; and WHEREAS, Hawaii does have a child death review panel per the federal Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) requirements, but there is no disclosure to the public or assurance that the circumstances of a death or injury have been addressed for future prevention; and WHEREAS, unlike Hawaii, states like California, Florida, and Colorado publish detailed information online about such cases and some even mandate these disclosures to ensure transparency and accountability, particularly when there has been previous state involvement; and WHEREAS, studies of child deaths over decades have resulted in four main causes: (1) Failure of communication between staff and agencies; (2) Inexperience and lack of skill of individual social workers; (3) Failure to follow established procedures; and (4) Inadequate resources to meet demands; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate of the Thirty-third Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2025, the House of Representatives concurring, that the Senate Committee on Health and Human Services and House Committee on Human Services and Homelessness are urged to conduct mandatory inquiries into all fatalities and serious injuries that occurred to children involved in Child Welfare Services; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that these inquiries must include a comprehensive review of systemic failures, resource allocation, departmental accountability, and the identification of measures to prevent further harm; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the goal of these inquiries should be to ensure full transparency, prompt and thorough action, and the establishment of safeguards that prioritize the safety and well-being of all children under the Department of Human Services' care; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Legislature is committed to enacting laws in response to the results of the mandated inquiries that ensure similar transparency and accountability as seen in other states, such as Colorado, to uphold the public trust and prevent future tragedies; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that certified copies of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Director of Human Services, President of the Senate, Speaker of the House of Representatives, Chair of the Senate Committee on Health and Human Services, and Chair of the House Committee on Human Services and Homelessness. OFFERED BY: _____________________________ Report Title: Child Fatalities and Serious Injuries; Legislative Inquiry
46	46
47	47	WHEREAS, the Department of Human Services (DHS), Child Welfare Services Branch has experienced a troubling number of child fatalities and serious injuries resulting from systemic failures, including neglect in foster care placements and unsafe reunifications; and
48	48
49	49
50	50
51	51	WHEREAS, nineteen child fatalities or serious injuries have been reported since 1997 and over ten million dollars have been paid out in lawsuits so far; and
52	52
53	53
54	54
55	55	WHEREAS, in the case of Reubyne, who was beaten in 1997 and is still in a vegetative state, DHS was sued for negligence and settled for two million dollars; and
56	56
57	57
58	58
59	59	WHEREAS, in the case of Peter Boy Kema, who was murdered in 1997 though his body was never found, his family was involved in multiple Child Welfare Services cases and ultimately reunified; however, a Special Masters report states that the Department should never have reunified, the father was convicted, and a lawsuit is pending; and
60	60
61	61
62	62
63	63	WHEREAS, in 1999 a Waianae family was given permanent guardianship over a group of children, who after reaching adulthood, successfully sued DHS following the parents' conviction for assault and sexual abuse in 2005; and
64	64
65	65
66	66
67	67	WHEREAS, in the case of Alexis Cabantang, who was left with permanent disabilities after she was beaten and nearly died in 2005, her guardian was sentenced to twenty years in prison and the Department of Education was successfully sued for failure to report her injuries to Child Welfare Services; and
68	68
69	69
70	70
71	71	WHEREAS, in the case of Cyrus Belt, who was thrown over a freeway overpass in Honolulu in 2008, the responsible party was sentenced to life in prison and DHS settled a lawsuit brought by the father for not intervening despite having been notified six days prior that the mother was using methamphetamine; and
72	72
73	73
74	74
75	75	WHEREAS, in the case of Braden McVeigh, who was murdered in 2009 after being reunited with his father over the objections of the grandmother, DHS was successfully sued; and
76	76
77	77
78	78
79	79	WHEREAS, in 2012, Zion McKeown was beaten to death at the age of four after being reunified with the parents despite multiple warnings against reunification; and
80	80
81	81
82	82
83	83	WHEREAS, in the case of Ronela Pascual, who was critically injured in 2008 after reunification which left her unable to communicate until her death in 2013 at the age of eleven; and
84	84
85	85
86	86
87	87	WHEREAS, in the case of Zachary Durto-Burgess, who was beaten to death after being reunified with his parents in 2010, his parents were sentenced to life in prison; and
88	88
89	89
90	90
91	91	WHEREAS, Zack Morris was convicted of sexual abuse and DHS was successfully sued by the boys who were placed in his foster home despite suspicions of child abuse in other states; and
92	92
93	93
94	94
95	95	WHEREAS, Fabian Garcia died in her foster home on Big Island due to blunt force trauma and has yet to receive justice; and
96	96
97	97
98	98
99	99	WHEREAS, Shaelyn Stone was withdrawn from public school and died of starvation in 2017; thereafter, her parents and grandparent were all convicted of manslaughter; and
100	100
101	101
102	102
103	103	WHEREAS, a seven day old infant died of brain damage at Tripler Hospital after an older sibling similarly died of injuries, and the parents were later convicted of murder for both children in 2020; and
104	104
105	105
106	106
107	107	WHEREAS, in 2020 a lawsuit was filed against DHS for overlooking systemic abuse in a foster home where the eleven adopted children were forced into slave labor, molested, and starved before a teen child ultimately killed the abusive adoptive mother; and
108	108
109	109
110	110
111	111	WHEREAS, Ariel Sellers was murdered in 2021 at the age of six after being starved, gagged, and kept in a dog cage by her adoptive parents who are currently in jail awaiting second degree murder charges; and
112	112
113	113
114	114
115	115	WHEREAS, in 2021 an infant was declared deceased after Child Welfare Services had been called in to investigate the situation months earlier but decided not to open a case; and
116	116
117	117
118	118
119	119	WHEREAS, Bula Mahoe was charged with sexual abuse of his parents' foster children; and
120	120
121	121
122	122
123	123	WHEREAS, Caitano used foster children to conduct an illegal drug ring in 2022, and was ultimately indicted for that offense along with sexual abuse and physical abuse; and
124	124
125	125
126	126
127	127	WHEREAS, Geanna Bradley was found dead in her home in 2024 after being starved and physically abused by her guardians, who are now charged with second degree murder, and another child in the home was found in very serious condition; and
128	128
129	129
130	130
131	131	WHEREAS, repeated failures to act upon warnings and ensure child safety have resulted in preventable deaths and injuries; and
132	132
133	133
134	134
135	135	WHEREAS, despite a 2005 policy directive (DHS 2005-PA-3) requiring safety concerns to be immediately reported to judges, these warnings have often been ignored; and
136	136
137	137
138	138
139	139	WHEREAS, lawsuits for some of the child fatality and serious injury cases have been successful, but they are complex, expensive, and time-consuming, while in the meantime, there is no assurance that preventative measures have been taken by DHS; and
140	140
141	141
142	142
143	143	WHEREAS, Hawaii does have a child death review panel per the federal Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA) requirements, but there is no disclosure to the public or assurance that the circumstances of a death or injury have been addressed for future prevention; and
144	144
145	145
146	146
147	147	WHEREAS, unlike Hawaii, states like California, Florida, and Colorado publish detailed information online about such cases and some even mandate these disclosures to ensure transparency and accountability, particularly when there has been previous state involvement; and
148	148
149	149
150	150
151	151	WHEREAS, studies of child deaths over decades have resulted in four main causes:
152	152
153	153
154	154
155	155	(1) Failure of communication between staff and agencies;
156	156
157	157
158	158
159	159	(2) Inexperience and lack of skill of individual social workers;
160	160
161	161
162	162
163	163	(3) Failure to follow established procedures; and
164	164
165	165
166	166
167	167	(4) Inadequate resources to meet demands; now, therefore,
168	168
169	169
170	170
171	171	BE IT RESOLVED by the Senate of the Thirty-third Legislature of the State of Hawaii, Regular Session of 2025, the House of Representatives concurring, that the Senate Committee on Health and Human Services and House Committee on Human Services and Homelessness are urged to conduct mandatory inquiries into all fatalities and serious injuries that occurred to children involved in Child Welfare Services; and
172	172
173	173
174	174
175	175	BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that these inquiries must include a comprehensive review of systemic failures, resource allocation, departmental accountability, and the identification of measures to prevent further harm; and
176	176
177	177
178	178
179	179	BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the goal of these inquiries should be to ensure full transparency, prompt and thorough action, and the establishment of safeguards that prioritize the safety and well-being of all children under the Department of Human Services' care; and
180	180
181	181
182	182
183	183	BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Legislature is committed to enacting laws in response to the results of the mandated inquiries that ensure similar transparency and accountability as seen in other states, such as Colorado, to uphold the public trust and prevent future tragedies; and
184	184
185	185
186	186
187	187	BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that certified copies of this Concurrent Resolution be transmitted to the Director of Human Services, President of the Senate, Speaker of the House of Representatives, Chair of the Senate Committee on Health and Human Services, and Chair of the House Committee on Human Services and Homelessness.
188	188
189	189
190	190
191	191
192	192
193	193
194	194
195	195	OFFERED BY: _____________________________
196	196
197	197
198	198
199	199	OFFERED BY:
200	200
201	201	_____________________________
202	202
203	203
204	204
205	205
206	206
207	207
208	208
209	209
210	210
211	211
212	212
213	213	Report Title:
214	214
215	215	Child Fatalities and Serious Injuries; Legislative Inquiry