Iowa 2023-2024 Regular Session

Iowa Senate Bill SF2096

Introduced
1/23/24  
Introduced
1/23/24  
Engrossed
2/20/24  
Refer
1/23/24  
Enrolled
4/3/24  
Engrossed
2/20/24  
Enrolled
4/3/24  

Caption

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive bodies. Effective date: 07/01/2024.

Impact

Should the bill be enacted, its effects would be noticeable in the makeup of state-appointed commissions and bodies responsible for various functions, including regulatory and advisory roles. By allowing appointments without the constraints of gender ratios, proponents believe that it would enable a broader pool of candidates to be considered, thereby enhancing the capability and expertise of these bodies. However, it could lead to a decrease in representation for women if not balanced by other policies or incentives for equal representation.

Summary

Senate File 2096 aims to repeal the gender balance requirements for appointive bodies in Iowa. The bill proposes significant amendments to existing laws that mandate gender balance in the composition of various commissions and boards. It seeks to eliminate the stipulations outlined in sections 69.16 and 69.16A of the Iowa Code regarding gender representation, thereby aligning appointments more closely with qualifications rather than gender specifications. This change comes with the intent to provide more flexibility in appointments, potentially improving the efficiency of governance by focusing on merit over demography.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SF 2096 appears to be divisive. Supporters contend that the bill promotes a more meritocratic approach to appointments, arguing that qualified individuals should hold positions irrespective of gender. Conversely, critics express concern that repealing gender balance requirements might reduce the representation and voices of women in critical decision-making roles, potentially regressing progress made toward gender equity in leadership within state governmental bodies.

Contention

Key points of contention include the delicate balance between ensuring qualified appointments versus maintaining gender diversity in public representation. Critics have highlighted that the removal of gender balance requirements could undermine previous efforts to promote representation of women in leadership positions, stressing the historical underrepresentation of women in various state agencies. On the other hand, supporters argue that meritocracy should not be sacrificed for demographics, indicating a clash of priorities between adherence to gender diversity and the pursuit of professional qualifications in appointments.

Companion Bills

IA HSB670

Related A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive bodies.(See HF 2540.)

IA HF2540

Similar To A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive bodies.(Formerly HSB 670.)

Previously Filed As

IA HSB670

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive bodies.(See HF 2540.)

IA HF2540

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive bodies.(Formerly HSB 670.)

IA SSB1037

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive boards, commissions, committees, and councils.(See SF 136.)

IA SF136

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive boards, commissions, committees, and councils.(Formerly SSB 1037.)

IA HF2306

A bill for an act relating to the membership of the commission of veterans affairs. (Formerly HF 2143.) Effective date: 07/01/2024.

IA SF2385

A bill for an act relating to boards, commissions, committees, councils, and other entities of state government, and including effective date and transition provisions. (Formerly SSB 3172.) Effective date: 07/01/2024, 07/01/2025.

IA SSB3172

A bill for an act relating to boards, commissions, committees, councils, and other entities of state government, and including effective date and transition provisions.(See SF 2385.)

IA HF954

A bill for an act relating to the conduct of elections, and including effective date and retroactive applicability provisions. (Formerly HSB 281.) Effective date: 07/01/2025, 01/01/2026. Applicability date: 01/01/2024.

IA SF2331

A bill for an act relating to publication requirements for official publications, and including effective date provisions. (Formerly SSB 3107.) Effective date: 04/10/2024, 07/01/2024, 07/01/2025.

IA HF2466

A bill for an act relating to the administration of elections. (Formerly HSB 628.) Effective date: 07/01/2024.

Similar Bills

IA HSB670

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive bodies.(See HF 2540.)

IA HF2540

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive bodies.(Formerly HSB 670.)

IA SF136

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive boards, commissions, committees, and councils.(Formerly SSB 1037.)

IA SSB1037

A bill for an act repealing gender balance requirements for appointive boards, commissions, committees, and councils.(See SF 136.)

CA AB13

Public Utilities Commission: membership: reports.

PA HB746

In Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission, further providing for organization of commission; and, in Pennsylvania Game Commission, further providing for organization of commission.

MN HF68

Per diems increased for boards, councils, and commissions.

MN SF2205

Per diem increases for certain boards, councils and commissions relating to natural resources