Illinois 2023-2024 Regular Session

Illinois Senate Bill SB0380

Introduced
2/2/23  
Refer
2/2/23  
Refer
3/2/23  
Report Pass
3/9/23  
Engrossed
3/31/23  
Refer
4/11/23  
Refer
4/11/23  
Report Pass
4/19/23  
Enrolled
5/19/23  
Chaptered
8/4/23  

Caption

CIVIL LAW-TECH

Impact

The enactment of SB 0380 introduces civil actions against healthcare providers who commit fertility fraud, allowing patients to seek legal remedy for violations that could have occurred at any time, even retroactively. This retroactive application is noteworthy, as it enables patients harmed before the bill's enactment to pursue justice. By doing so, the bill seeks to strengthen accountability within the medical field regarding assisted reproductive treatment, establishing clear guidelines for ethical practices and enhancing patient rights.

Summary

Senate Bill 0380, also known as the Illinois Fertility Fraud Act, aims to address a significant ethical issue concerning fertility treatments. The bill asserts that fertility fraud, defined as the use of a healthcare provider's own reproductive material without the informed consent of the patient, has caused considerable harm to individuals involved. This is particularly relevant as many patients discover such violations years later through DNA testing, leading to severe emotional and relational repercussions. The bill's proponents emphasize the necessity of informed consent, aligning medical practices with patient trust and care standards.

Sentiment

Support for SB 0380 is strong among advocates for reproductive rights and medical ethics, viewing it as a vital step towards safeguarding patient autonomy. Opponents, however, may highlight concerns about liability and the potential for excessive lawsuits against medical professionals, questioning whether the bill could have unintended consequences for fertility practices. Overall, the sentiment reflects a significant alignment towards protecting individuals' rights to informed consent in healthcare, specifically concerning sensitive reproductive issues.

Contention

Debate surrounding SB 0380 is centered on the balance of protecting patient rights while ensuring that providers are not unduly burdened by litigation. Proponents argue that the need for clear protections against unethical practices far outweighs potential drawbacks, emphasizing the importance of trust in the provider-patient relationship. Critics, however, caution of the risks associated with broad legal implications, particularly regarding the history of medical practice and future reproductive services. This contention reflects broader discussions on medical accountability and ethics within reproductive health.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

IL SB1467

FERTILITY FRAUD ACT

IL HB95

Health Care Providers - Assisted Reproductive Treatment - Informed Consent and Fraud

IL HB1554

To Create The Assisted Reproductive Technology Reporting Act.

IL HB402

AN ACT relating to assisted reproduction.

IL HR1346

Providing for consideration of the bill (H.R. 7056) to prohibit the limitation of access to assisted reproductive technology, and all medical care surrounding such technology.

IL SB108

AN ACT relating to assisted reproduction.

IL HB64

AN ACT relating to assisted reproduction.

IL S0027

Reproductive Rights

IL HB3132

Relating to reporting requirements for assisted reproductive technology, including in vitro fertilization.

IL SB2447

Relating to reporting requirements for assisted reproductive technology, including in vitro fertilization.

Similar Bills

IL SB1467

FERTILITY FRAUD ACT

IL HB5290

HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES COUNCIL

IL SB1829

INC TX-STATE AND LOCAL DEDUCT

IL HB0998

INC TAX-CANNABIS

IL HB3737

INC TX-HEALTH INSURANCE

IL HB3324

INC TX-WAGERING LOSSES

IL HB2734

INC TX-OVERTIME DEDUCTION

IL HB1899

INC TX-OVERTIME DEDUCTION