Louisiana 2010 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HB474

Introduced
3/29/10  

Caption

Prohibits use of radar detectors in commercial motor vehicles

Impact

The legislation seeks to create a safer driving environment on public roads by eliminating tools that might enable commercial drivers to evade law enforcement detection for speeding. By enforcing a ban on radar detection devices, lawmakers hope to deter reckless driving behavior within the commercial vehicle sector. This change will likely have implications on how commercial drivers plan their routes and manage their speed, with the aim of maintaining strict compliance with speed limits designated for commercial transportation.

Summary

House Bill 474, sponsored by Representative Thibaut, proposes significant amendments to the regulations governing commercial motor vehicles by prohibiting the use or possession of radar detectors within these vehicles while operating on public highways or right-of-ways. The bill specifically defines commercial motor vehicles and establishes clear guidelines regarding the permitted areas and devices that may be in use. Violations of this law are subject to fines, making it a regulatory measure that aims to enhance road safety and compliance among commercial drivers.

Sentiment

Feedback surrounding HB 474 appears to be largely supportive among safety advocates and law enforcement agencies, who view the bill as a proactive approach to preventing speed-related accidents involving commercial vehicles. However, there may also be concerns from the commercial trucking industry about the implications this may have on their operations, particularly regarding the perceived fairness of penalties imposed for violations. Overall, the sentiment portrays a balance between the public interest in road safety and the operational freedoms of commercial drivers.

Contention

Some points of contention raised in discussions around the bill relate to the effectiveness of banning radar detectors as a means of ensuring safe driving practices. Critics may argue that simply prohibiting devices does not address the underlying issues of driver training and enforcement of existing speeding laws. There may also be discussions about the financial burden placed upon drivers who are fined for non-compliance. Thus, while the bill indicates a step towards stricter regulations for commercial vehicles, the debate centers on its appropriateness and potential efficacy in achieving desired safety outcomes.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA HB475

Prohibits the possession of alcoholic beverages within the cab of any commercial motor vehicle

LA SB1370

Civil penalties; commercial motor vehicles

LA SCR1001

Photo radar prohibition

LA HB2282

Prohibition; photo radar

LA SB1134

Prohibition; photo radar.

LA SB1234

Prohibition; photo radar

LA SB1003

Prohibition; photo radar

LA HB180

Radar detectors; use and sale of devices to detect radar, etc.

LA SB785

Modifies provisions relating to limitations on certain commercial motor vehicles

LA H0405

Regulation of Commercial Motor Vehicles

Similar Bills

MA H2689

Relative to the requirement of fuel gas alarms/detectors

PA HB1522

Requiring the installation and maintenance of fuel gas detectors in certain buildings; providing for building owner responsibilities; and imposing penalties.

CT HB06609

An Act Concerning Extended Producer Responsibility For Smoke Detectors.

CT HB06386

An Act Concerning Extended Producer Responsibility For Tires, Smoke Detectors And Certain Gas Cylinders.

HI SB1667

Relating To Transportation.

TX HB3209

Relating to carbon monoxide detectors in certain properties.

CA AB2744

Vehicles: pedestrian, bicycle, and vehicle safety.

TX HB3391

Relating to rainwater harvesting and other water conservation initiatives.