Louisiana 2010 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SCR81

Introduced
5/13/10  
Passed
5/13/10  

Caption

Requests the Louisiana State Law Institute to study and make recommendations on the implementation of laws in Louisiana relative to surrogacy agreements.

Impact

The resolution signals a recognition of the complexities surrounding surrogacy agreements, which involve ethical, social, and contractual dimensions. By urging the Louisiana State Law Institute to investigate these matters, SCR81 could potentially lead to the establishment of clearer legal structures governing surrogacy, addressing the void that currently exists. This could significantly affect existing laws by either amending them to accommodate regulated surrogacy or reinforcing the stance against such agreements, depending on the recommendations made by the law institute.

Summary

SCR81 is a Senate Concurrent Resolution from Louisiana requesting the Louisiana State Law Institute to study and make recommendations regarding the implementation of laws related to surrogacy agreements in the state. The resolution highlights the current legal framework which considers surrogacy agreements null and void as they are deemed contrary to public policy. Given the rise of surrogacy arrangements as alternatives for couples facing infertility, this bill seeks to open discussions on how best to regulate these agreements while safeguarding the interests of all parties involved, particularly that of the child.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SCR81 appears to be a proactive approach to a growing societal issue, as there is a burgeoning interest in surrogacy practices nationally. By initiating a study, the legislature is acknowledging the evolving family dynamics and the necessity of providing legal clarity. However, the sentiment could become contentious depending on the proposed regulations, as surrogacy often brings forth a mix of opinions ranging from strong support based on parental desire to significant ethical and moral objections.

Contention

A notable point of contention around SCR81 lies in balancing the rights and protections of the involved parties—intended parents, surrogates, and the children born from such arrangements. There are deeply rooted concerns about the ethical implications of commodifying childbirth and the potential exploitation of surrogates. Additionally, resolving the legal uncertainties regarding parental rights and responsibilities can be contentious, with varying perspectives on how best to legislate these agreements. The outcome of the Louisiana State Law Institute's study may spark further debate on these critical issues.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

MI HB5207

Family law: other; surrogate parenting act; repeal, and establish the assisted reproduction and surrogacy parentage act. Creates new act & repeals 1988 PA 199 (MCL 722.851 - 722.863). TIE BAR WITH: HB 5208'23, HB 5209'23, HB 5210'23, HB 5211'23, HB 5212'23, HB 5213'23, HB 5214'23, HB 5215'23

NC S885

Parentage Protection for Families

WV SB575

Assisted Reproduction Act

MN HF4564

Assisted reproduction rights and responsibilities updated, gestational surrogacy agreement requirements created, genetic surrogacy agreement requirements created, and genetic donation recordkeeping and information sharing provided.

MN HF2219

Traditional and gestational surrogacy arrangements regulated, and crime of operating a for-profit surrogacy agency created.

NM HB305

Surrogacy & Parental Determination

MA S947

To ensure legal parentage equality

MN HF5453

Traditional and gestational surrogacy arrangements regulated, and crime to operate a for-profit surrogacy agency created.