Louisiana 2012 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SB484

Introduced
3/12/12  

Caption

Provides relative to human trafficking, trafficking of children for sexual purposes, and the commercial sexual exploitation of children. (gov sig)

Impact

The bill aims to enhance law enforcement's ability to combat human trafficking through various means, including the authorization for wiretaps during trafficking investigations and mandated training for officers to recognize and respond to incidents of trafficking effectively. The amendments also ensure that victims of trafficking have access to reparation services, further integrating victim support within legislative frameworks. Furthermore, the bill establishes stricter regulations for those involved in the prostitution of minors and stipulates harsher penalties for prior offenders, contributing to a more formidable legal structure against repeat offenses.

Summary

SB484 focuses on strengthening laws against human trafficking, particularly trafficking involving children for sexual purposes. The bill proposes significant amendments to existing laws concerning crimes such as prostitution, pornography involving juveniles, and solicitation. By increasing penalties for offenses that involve minors, particularly those under the age of 14, the legislation underscores a stricter approach to safeguarding vulnerable populations. Additionally, it introduces provisions that prevent certain defenses in prosecutions relating to these offenses, such as the defense of consent or mistaken age which previously could have been used by defendants.

Sentiment

The general sentiment surrounding SB484 appears to be one of support for its protective stance on children and vulnerable populations. Advocates for child welfare and anti-trafficking measures have praised the bill's comprehensive approach to tackling these severe crimes. However, there are concerns regarding the balance between stringent penalties and rehabilitation opportunities for offenders, particularly those who may have been victims themselves. This duality in perception indicates that while the urgency to protect minors is undisputed, the implementation of such laws requires careful consideration of broader implications on justice and rehabilitation.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the implications of the stricter penalties on minors who may become involved in these offenses. Critics argue that while the bill aims to deter such crimes, it may inadvertently criminalize juveniles who are also victims of trafficking. This raises essential discussions regarding the treatment of minors within the legal system and the need for a supportive rather than purely punitive approach. Additionally, there is apprehension about the effectiveness and ethical ramifications of implementing wiretaps and similar surveillance tactics in trafficking investigations.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

LA HB49

Provides relative to human trafficking, trafficking of children for sexual purposes, and the commercial sexual exploitation of children (EN INCREASE GF EX See Note)

LA HB5

Provides relative to penalties for certain sex offenses (EN SEE FISC NOTE GF EX)

LA HB1025

Provides relative to human trafficking, trafficking of children for sexual purposes, and commercial sexual exploitation (EN INCREASE GF EX See Note)

LA SB90

Expands crime of human trafficking to specific elements regarding trafficking of persons under the age of twenty-one engaged in commercial sexual activity. (8/1/16)

LA HB163

Provides relative to victims of certain sex-related crimes (EN INCREASE SD RV See Note)

LA HB268

Amends terminology regarding pornography involving juveniles

LA HB494

Provides for the classification of criminal offenses and criminal penalties based on the class of the offense

LA HB96

(Constitutional Amendment) Provides relative to state civil service, including providing that employees hired on or after January 1, 2020, shall be in the unclassified service