HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED 2015 Regular Session HOUSE CONCURRENT RESOL UTION NO. 18 BY REPRESENTATIVE CARTER Prefiled pursuant to Article III, Section 2(A)(4)(b)(i) of the Constitution of Louisiana. EDUCATION/FINANCE: Provides for legislative approval of the MFP formula for the 2015-2016 fiscal year 1 A CONCURRENT RESOL UTION 2To provide for legislative approval of the formula developed by the State Board of 3 Elementary and Secondary Education pursuant to Article VIII, Section 13(B) of the 4 Constitution of Louisiana to determine the cost of a minimum foundation program 5 of education in all public elementary and secondary schools as well as to equitably 6 allocate the funds to parish and city school systems, and adopted by the board on 7 March 6, 2015. 8 WHEREAS, the minimum foundation program formula for Fiscal Year 2015-2016 9adopted by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education on March 6, 2015, and 10submitted to the legislature for approval on March 13, 2015, in accordance with applicable 11law reads as follows: 12 PROPOSED 13 FY 2015-16 MINIMUM FOUNDATION PROGRAM FORMULA 14 The FY 2015-16 Minimum Foundation Program (MFP) formula was adopted 15 by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education on March 6, 2015. The 16 formula determines allocations for city, parish, or other public school systems or 17 schools. The definition of city, parish, or local public school systems and schools 18 shall include city or parish school systems, Recovery School District including 19 operated and Type 5 charter schools, Louisiana School for Math, Science, and the 20 Arts (LSMSA), New Orleans Center for Creative Arts (NOCCA), New Type 2 21 Charter schools, Legacy Type 2 Charter schools, Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) Page 1 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 schools, and Louisiana State University and Southern University Lab schools. The 2 formula is divided into four calculations as follows: 3 Level 1 determines the minimum cost of education based on the education 4 needs of each student. The cost includes funding for students enrolled in city and 5 parish school systems, Recovery School District operated and Type 5 Charter 6 schools, and New Type 2 Charter schools. The cost is then shared equitably between 7 the State and the city and parish school systems based on the ability of the systems 8 to support education in their communities through local sales and property tax 9 revenues. 10 Level 2 provides an incentive for city and parish school systems to support 11 education in their communities above the minimum level of financial support 12 required. 13 Level 3 provides specific legislative education funding to city and parish 14 school systems for continuing teacher and support worker pay raises, the Hold 15 Harmless provision, and mandated operating costs. 16 Level 4 provides additional funding including: 17 • Supplementary funding to meet specific needs at city, parish, or other 18 local school systems and schools including Foreign Associate 19 Teacher Salary and Stipends Allocation, Career Development 20 Allocation, High Cost Services Allocation, and Supplemental Course 21 Allocation. 22 • Allocations for State-Approved public school systems or schools 23 including Legacy Type 2 Charter schools, Louisiana State University 24 and Southern University Lab schools, New Orleans Center for 25 Creative Arts (NOCCA), Louisiana School for Math, Science, and 26 Arts (LSMSA), and Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) schools. 27 • Mid-Year Allocation Adjustments to account for mid-year increases 28 and decreases in students in all city, parish, or other local public 29 school systems or schools. Page 2 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 State MFP funds shall only be expended for educational purposes. 2 Expenditures for educational purposes are those expenditures related to the 3 operational and instructional activities of city, parish, or other public school systems 4 or schools to include: instructional programs, pupil support programs, instructional 5 staff programs, school administration, general administration, business services, 6 operations and maintenance of plant services, student transportation services, food 7 services operations, enterprise operations, community services operations, facility 8 acquisition and construction services and debt services as defined by Louisiana 9 Accounting and Uniform Governmental Handbook, Bulletin 1929. 10 I. FORMULA CALCULATIONS 11 A. Level 1: Calculate State and Local Cost Allocation 12 1. Determine Educational Costs 13 Eligible students from the following school systems and schools will be 14 counted in both the Base and Weighted Student Memberships: 15 1. City and Parish school systems 16 2. State-Approved Public Schools - The student counts of the following 17 state-approved schools shall be included in the membership and 18 weighted student counts of the city or parish school system in which 19 the student resides: 20 a) New Type 2 Charter schools, 21 3. Recovery School District - The student membership and weighted 22 student counts of schools transferred to the Recovery School District, 23 both operated and Type 5 Charter schools, shall continue to be 24 included in the membership and weighted student counts of the city 25 or parish school system from which jurisdiction of the school was 26 transferred. 27 STEP ONE: Determine the Number of Eligible Students for the Base Count 28 The formula first counts each of the students enrolled on February 1 to determine 29 the cost of education services. The formula utilizes the February 1 Student 30 Membership Count to allocate funding beginning in July. The students eligible to Page 3 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 be counted are identified in the Student Membership Definition adopted by the State 2 Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. These students are counted as one 3 (1.0) in the formula. 4 STEP TWO: Determine the Number of Students Eligible for the Weighted 5 Student Count 6 The formula recognizes that providing educational services to meet the needs of 7 particular students is more costly than regular educational services. Each special 8 characteristic or need is given a numerical value referred to as a weight. The special 9 needs of each student are taken into consideration by multiplying the student count 10 for each eligible child (1.0) by each of the weights. This calculation provides 11 additional students that are then added to the February 1 Student Membership Count 12 to equal the Total Weighted Student Membership Count. The students and units 13 eligible to be counted are identified in the Student Membership Definition adopted 14 by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. 15 The following are the additional costs recognized by the formula: 16 Low Income and English Language Learner Weight - The formula recognizes 17 that students living in poverty or students with a native language other than English 18 are more likely to require additional educational services to be successful. To 19 recognize that these services require additional costs, students that qualify for free 20 or reduced price meals under the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) 21 School Food Service Program guidelines, or an alternative count as defined in the 22 Student Membership Definition, and students identified as an English Language 23 Learner are provided a weight of 22%. 24 Career and Technical Education Weight - The formula recognizes that the cost 25 of providing materials and equipment, and teacher credentialing and training, for 26 Career and Technical Education courses is above and beyond the cost of traditional 27 academic education. Each secondary career and technical education course in which 28 a student is enrolled in both the fall and spring semesters is provided a weight of 6%. 29 Special Education Weight – The formula addresses the extra cost associated 30 with the delivery of services required in order to meet the needs of students with Page 4 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 disabilities. Students with disabilities that have an Individualized Education Plan 2 (IEP) developed according to State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education 3 regulations are provided a weight of 150%. 4 Gifted and Talented Weight -The formula recognizes the cost of providing 5 educational services to Gifted and Talented students that have an Individualized 6 Education Plan (IEP) developed according to State Board of Elementary and 7 Secondary Education regulations and are provided a 60% weight. 8 Economy of Scale Weight – This weight is provided for city or parish school 9 systems to recognize a base amount of funding for fixed overhead costs that should 10 be provided when student populations equal 7,500 students or less. The Economy of 11 Scale Weight is calculated as a curvilinear weight of 20% at a student membership 12 count of zero down to 0% at a student membership count equal to or greater than 13 7,500. To calculate this weight, the February 1 Student Membership Count for each 14 city and parish school system is subtracted from 7,500 and divided by 37,500. The 15 result of this calculation is then multiplied by each system's February 1 Student 16 Membership Count to determine the weighted students. 17 STEP THREE: Determine Total Weighted Student Membership Count 18 Formula: 19 Total Weighted Student Membership Count 20 Equals 21 February 1 Student Membership Count (1.0) 22 Plus 23 Low Income and English Language Learner Weight 24 Career and Technical Education Weight 25 Special Education Weight 26 Gifted and Talented Weight 27 Economy of Scale Weight 28 STEP FOUR: Identify the State and Local Base Cost Per Pupil 29 Formula: Page 5 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 The State and Local Base Cost Per Pupil shall equal $3,961 plus 2 1.375percent times $3,961 for a total of $4,015. 3 STEP FIVE: Determine Total MFP Educational Costs 4 Formula: 5 Total MFP Educational Costs 6 Equals 7 Total Weighted Student Membership Count 8 Multiplied by 9 State and Local Base Cost Per Pupil 10 2. Determine State and Local Cost Allocation 11 The Total MFP Educational Costs are shared between the State and the city or 12 parish school systems. The ability of school systems to support the cost of education 13 in their communities is measured by the potential to raise local revenue. This 14 potential contribution is measured by the following three factors using the latest 15 available data as reported through the Annual Financial Report (AFR) as required by 16 R.S. 17:92: 17 1. Local Property Tax Revenue Contribution 18 2. Local Sales Tax Revenue Contribution 19 3. Other Local Revenue Contribution 20 STEP ONE - Determine the Local Property Tax Revenue Contribution 21 Formula: 22 Local Property Tax Revenue Contribution 23 Equals 24 State Computed Property Tax Millage (debt and non-debt) 25 Times 26 Net Assessed Property Value 27 Net Assessed Property Value Increase Cap - If a school system's Net Assessed 28 Property Value has increased equal to or greater than 10% over the prior year Net 29 Assessed Property Value, then the growth in the Net Assessed Property Value is 30 capped at 10%. This cap is applied on a year-to-year basis comparing the current Page 6 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 year Net Assessed Property Value to the prior year uncapped Net Assessed Property 2 Value. 3 Computed Property Tax Millage - The Computed Property Tax Millage is 4 calculated annually at the rate necessary to maintain a state and local allocation ratio 5 of 65%/35%. 6 STEP TWO - Determine the Local Sales Tax Revenue Contribution 7 Formula: 8 Local Sales Tax Revenue Contribution 9 Equals 10 Computed Sales Tax Base (debt and non-debt) (including TIF areas) 11 Multiplied By 12 State Computed Sales Tax Rate 13 Mid-Year Rate Increases - If a local school system's sales tax goes into effect 14 during the fiscal year, the tax rate is prorated to an annual rate applicable for the total 15 revenue generated. 16 Sales Tax Increase Cap - If a system's Computed Sales Tax Base increased 17 equal to or greater than 15% over the Computed Sales Tax Base calculated in the 18 prior year formula, then the growth in the Computed Sales Tax Base will be capped 19 at 15% over the amount used in the prior year formula. This cap will be applied on 20 a year-to-year basis comparing the current year sales tax base to the prior year 21 uncapped sales tax base. 22 Computed Sales Tax Rate - The Computed Sales Tax Rate is calculated 23 annually at the rate necessary to maintain a state and local allocation ratio of 24 65%/35%. 25 STEP THREE - Determine Other Local Revenue Contribution 26 Formula: 27 Other Local Revenue Contribution 28 Equals 29 State Revenue in lieu of taxes 30 Plus Page 7 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 Federal Revenue in lieu of taxes 2 Plus 3 50% of Earnings on Property 4 STEP FOUR - Determine Local Cost Allocation 5 Formula: 6 Local Cost Allocation 7 Equals 8 Property Tax Contribution 9 Plus 10 Sales Tax Contribution 11 Plus 12 Other Revenues Contribution 13 STEP FIVE - Determine State Cost Allocation 14 Formula: 15 State Cost Allocation 16 Equals 17 Total State and Local Cost 18 Minus 19 Local Cost Allocation 20 Minimum State Cost Allocation - In no event shall the State Cost Allocation 21 be less than 25% of Total Level 1 Cost for any city or parish school system. 22 B. Level 2: Incentive for Local Effort 23 Level 2 provides incentives for city and parish school systems that contribute a 24 greater proportion of local revenues towards the cost of education in their 25 communities by increasing local property and sales tax revenues. This effort is 26 measured using the latest available data for the following sources of revenue as 27 reported in the Annual Financial Report (AFR) as required in R. S. 17:92. 28 1. Total Sales Taxes 29 2. Total Property Taxes 30 3. State and Federal Revenue in Lieu of Taxes Page 8 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 4. 50% Earnings on Property Revenue 2 STEP ONE - Determine Eligible Local Revenue 3 Formula: 4 Eligible Local Revenue 5 Equals 6 Total Sales Tax Revenue 7 Plus 8 Total Property Tax Revenue 9 Plus 10 State and Federal Revenue in Lieu of Taxes 11 Plus 12 50% of Earnings on Property Revenue 13 STEP TWO - Determine Local Revenue Eligible for Incentive 14 Formula: 15 Local Revenue Eligible for Incentive 16 Equals 17 Eligible Local Revenue 18 Minus 19 Local Cost Allocation 20 STEP THREE - Determine the Limit on Revenue Eligible for Incentive 21 Formula: 22 Limit on Revenue Eligible for Incentive 23 Equals 24 Total State and Local Cost Allocation 25 Multiplied by 26 34% 27 STEP FOUR - Determine Local Support of Level 2 Incentive 28 Formula: 29 Local Support of Level 2 Incentive 30 Equals Page 9 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 Lesser of Local Revenue Eligible for Incentive or Limit on Local Revenue 2 Eligible for Incentive 3 Multiplied by 4 Local Cost Allocation Percentage (Level 1) 5 Multiplied by 6 Level 2 Incentive Factor 7 Level 2 Incentive Factor - The Level 2 Incentive Factor determines the amount 8 of local support required in Level 2. In FY 14-15, the Level 2 Incentive Factor is 9 established at 1.72. 10 STEP FIVE – Determine State Cost of Level 2 Incentive 11 Formula: 12 State Support of Level 2 Incentive 13 Equals 14 Lesser of Local Revenue Eligible for Incentive or Limit on Local Revenue 15 Eligible for Incentive 16 Minus 17 Local Support of Level 2 Incentive 18 C. Level 3: Legislative Allocations 19 Level 3 provides funding for three programs that address funding for school systems 20and schools regarding teacher and support worker pay raises, Hold Harmless funding, and 21mandated operating costs, and are in addition to allocations provided in Level 1 and 2. 22These allocations are as follows: 23 Formula: 24 Total Level 3 Legislative Allocations 25 Equals 26 Continuation Pay Raises 27 Plus 28 Hold Harmless Enhancement 29 Plus 30 Mandated Costs in Health Insurance, Retirement, and Fuel Page 10 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 STEP ONE: Calculate Continuation Funding for Pay Raises 2 1.Certificated Personnel Pay Raises were implemented in four recent years to assist 3 in increasing Teacher and Principal pay to the Southern Regional Average. 4 These funds continue to be provided directly to systems and schools to support 5 these increased salaries. 6 a.Certificated Personnel Pay Raises provided in 2001-02, 2006-07, 2007-08, 7 and 2008-09 will continue for each school system and school based on the 8 calculated per pupil amount times the February 1 Student Membership 9 Count. 10 2.Noncertificated Support Worker Pay Raises were implemented in three recent 11 years to assist with increasing these salaries. 12 a.Noncertificated Support Worker Pay Raises provided in 2002-03, 2006-07, 13 and 2007-08 will continue for each school system and school based on the 14 calculated per pupil amount times the February 1 Student Membership 15 Count. 16 3.This provision applies to city and parish school systems, Recovery School 17 District, New Orleans Center for Creative Arts (NOCCA), Louisiana School for 18 Math, Science, and the Arts (LSMSA), Legacy Type 2 Charter Schools, New 19 Type 2 Charter Schools, Louisiana State University and Southern University Lab 20 schools, and Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ). 21 STEP TWO: Calculate Hold Harmless Enhancement 22 Participating School Systems - The following school systems have a remaining 23 Hold Harmless or "overfunded" allocation: Concordia, East Baton Rouge, 24 Evangeline, Iberville, Jefferson, Plaquemines, St. Charles, St. James, and West 25 Feliciana. 26 Allocation Adjustment - After subtracting amounts attributable to insurance 27 supplements and legislative pay raises provided between FY 1993-94 and FY 28 1998-99 from the FY 2006-07 Hold Harmless amount, a revised Hold Harmless 29 amount is calculated. Each of the remaining Hold Harmless school systems will 30 receive a reduction of 10% to their remaining Hold Harmless allocation. On an Page 11 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 annual basis, any Hold Harmless system may choose to reduce the remaining balance 2 by an amount greater than 10% through formal notification to the Louisiana 3 Department of Education. This request must take place no later than June 30th each 4 year. 5 Redistribution Allocation - The annual 10% reduction amount will be 6 redistributed in a per pupil amount to all non-hold harmless systems. 7 STEP THREE: Determine Allocation for Increasing Mandated Costs in Health 8 Insurance, Retirement, and Fuel 9 City and parish school systems shall receive a minimum of $100.00 for each 10 student in the prior year February 1 membership to offset these increasing 11 operational costs. 12 The following formula is applied to determine the Level 1, 2, and 3 State Cost 13 Allocation Per Pupil: 14 Formula: 15 Level 1, 2, and 3 State Cost Allocation Per Pupil 16 Equals 17 Level 1 State Cost Allocation Per Pupil 18 Plus 19 Level 2 State Cost Allocation Per Pupil 20 Plus 21 Level 3 State Cost Allocation Per Pupil 22 D. Level 4: Supplementary Allocations 23 1. Specific Needs Allocations provide funding for four allocations for specific 24 purposes and is in addition to system level allocations from Levels 1, 2, and 3. These 25 allocations are as follows: 26 Formula: 27 Total Level 4 Supplementary Allocations 28 Equals 29 Foreign Language Associate Program Salary and Stipend Allocation 30 Plus Page 12 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 Career Development Allocation 2 Plus 3 High Cost Services Assistance Allocation 4 Plus 5 Supplemental Course Allocation 6 STEP ONE: Calculate Foreign Language Associate Salary and Stipend 7 Allocation 8 Salary Allocation - Any city, parish, or other public school system or school 9 employing a Foreign Language Associate or a graduate of the Escadrille Louisiane 10 program shall receive a supplemental allocation from State Board of Elementary and 11 Secondary Education of $21,000 per teacher. The state shall maintain support of the 12 Foreign Language Associate program at a maximum of 300 Foreign Language 13 Associates employed in any given year. 14 These teachers shall be paid by the employing city, parish, or other local public 15 school system or school at least the state average classroom teacher salary (without 16 PIP) by years of experience and degree beginning with year three. Of the $21,000 17 allocation, $20,000 shall be allocated to the school where the teacher is employed 18 and the funds used to support the total cost of the teacher salary, and the remaining 19 amount shall be associated with costs of VISA sponsorship pursuant to State Board 20 of Elementary and Secondary Education regulations. 21 Stipend Allocation - First year teachers will receive an installation incentive of 22 an additional $6,000; second and third year teachers will receive a retention incentive 23 of an additional $4,000. These amounts must be provided to each Foreign Associate 24 Teacher or Escadrille Louisiane graduate by each school district or school in which 25 they are employed. 26 STEP TWO: Career Development Allocation 27 The cost of providing materials and equipment, and teacher credentialing and 28 training to attain a statewide industry-based credential is above and beyond the cost 29 typically required for high school courses. An allocation will be provided to support Page 13 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 the development of these technical courses required for statewide credentials in city 2 and parish school systems and other public schools. 3 The first step in the allocation is to calculate six percent (6%) of the MFP State 4 and Local Base Cost Per Pupil to determine the Career Development Per Pupil 5 Amount. The Career Development Per Pupil Amount will be provided for each 6 qualifying student course enrollment in grades 9 through 12. 7 If a city and parish school system receives less than $25,000 from the Career 8 Development Per Pupil Amount, then the city or parish school system will be 9 provided an economies of scale minimum allocation of $25,000. If local public 10 school systems and schools containing grades 9-12 receive less than $10,000 from 11 the Per Pupil allocation, then the other public schools containing grades 9-12 will be 12 provided an economies of scale minimum allocation of $10,000. 13 Formula: 14 Career Development Allocation Per Pupil 15 Equals 16 MFP State and Local Base Cost Per Pupil 17 Multiplied By 18 Six Percent (6%) 19 Formula: 20 Career Development Allocation 21 Equals 22 Career Development Allocation Per Pupil 23 Multiplied By 24 Number of Student Enrollments in Qualifying Courses in Grades 9 through 25 12 26 STEP THREE: Calculate High Cost Services Assistance 27 High cost services for students with disabilities generate a particular budget 28 challenge for city, parish, and other public school systems and schools. 29 In an effort to assist with these expenses, an allocation will be provided to city, 30 parish, and other public school systems and schools which submit documentation as Page 14 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 required by the Louisiana Department of Education substantiating that the current 2 cost of services for a specific student including estimated costs for new services, or 3 new students, exceeds three times the most recent state average total expenditure per 4 pupil amount. 5 Once costs associated with providing services for a student with disabilities have 6 been verified, the city or parish school system or other public schools will be eligible 7 to receive an allocation to assist with these costs. The allocation will be limited by 8 the amount budgeted for the High Cost Services Assistance Allocation. So as to be 9 equitably distributed, the total allocation provided to city and parish school systems 10 versus other public schools shall be proportional to the share of total qualifying 11 applications submitted by city and parish school systems versus other public schools. 12 Based on the $9. 4 million available, all entities within each group, city and parish 13 school systems and other public school systems, shall receive the same percent of the 14 requested allocation. The High Cost Services requested for reimbursement will be 15 reduced by the MFP state and local amount allocated on behalf of each student from 16 Levels 1, 2, and 3. 17 STEP FOUR: Calculate Supplemental Course Allocation 18 Pursuant to R.S. 17:4002.1 through 4002.6, the Supplemental Course Allocation 19 shall provide for the cost of secondary courses specifically approved by the State 20 Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. For each city and parish school 21 system and other public school, the allocation shall equal the number of students 22 enrolled in grades 7 through 12 as of February 1 each year multiplied by $35 per 23 pupil. 24 Formula: 25 Supplemental Course Allocation for School Systems or Other Public Schools 26 Equals 27 Supplemental Course Allocation Per Pupil 28 Multiplied By 29 Number of Students in Grades 7 through 12 Page 15 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 If the entire allocation is not committed by the city or parish public school 2 system or other public school by a date set forth by the Louisiana Department of 3 Education, the original allocation will be reduced by the uncommitted amount. The 4 total uncommitted amount from each city or parish public school system or other 5 public school will be reallocated to those city or parish public school systems or 6 other public schools that obligated one hundred percent of their original allocation 7 based on criteria set forth by the Louisiana Department of Education. 8 2. Allocations for Other Public Schools 9 STEP ONE: Louisiana State University and Southern University Laboratory 10 Schools 11 1.State Cost Allocation 12 a. The February 1 Student Membership count at the Louisiana State 13 University and Southern University Lab Schools shall be multiplied 14 by the Average State Cost Allocation Per Pupil to equal the Louisiana 15 State University and Southern University Lab Schools State Cost 16 Allocation. 17 b. Funds appropriated for these schools shall be allocated to the 18 institution of higher education operating such a school. Each such 19 institution of higher education shall ensure the equitable expenditure 20 of such funds to operate such schools. 21 STEP TWO: Legacy Type 2 Charter Schools 22 A Legacy Type 2 Charter school is a Type 2 Charter school approved before July 1, 23 2008 by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. 24 1.State Cost Allocation 25 a. Any Legacy Type 2 Charter school shall annually be allocated funds 26 as determined by applying the formula contained in R. S. 17:3995. 27 b. The State Cost Allocation equals the number of students multiplied 28 by the State Per Pupil for the system where the school is located. 29 2.Local Cost Allocation Page 16 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 a. Any Legacy Type 2 Charter school shall annually be allocated funds 2 as determined by applying the formula contained in R. S. 17:3995. 3 b. The Local Cost Allocation equals the number of students multiplied 4 by the Local Per Pupil for the system where the school is located. 5 c. For any student enrolled in a Legacy Type 2 Charter school, the 6 Local Cost Allocation shall be funded by the State. 7 3.The exclusion of any portion of local revenues specifically dedicated by the 8 legislature or by voter approval to capital outlay or debt service shall be 9 applicable only to a charter school housed in a facility or facilities provided 10 by the district in which the charter school is located. 11 STEP THREE: Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) Schools 12 1. Eligible Schools - Any elementary and secondary school operated by the 13 Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) in a secure care facility shall be considered a public 14 elementary or secondary school and, as such, the Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) 15 shall be annually appropriated funds for these students. 16 2. Eligible Students - Each student counted in the prior year average daily 17 membership, as defined by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education 18 in the Student Membership Definition, is calculated by dividing the number of days 19 the student is under the guidance and direction of teachers by the total instructional 20 days during the specified school year. 21 3. Allocation - The Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) shall annually be allocated 22 funds for the eligible students. For each student enrolled in these schools, both a 23 State Cost Allocation and a Local Cost Allocation shall be provided. 24 4. State Cost Allocation 25 a. The State Cost Allocation is equal to the State Cost Allocation Per 26 Pupil for the system where each student resided prior to adjudication multiplied by 27 the prior year average daily membership of the Office of Juvenile Justice schools. 28 b. The State Cost Allocation Per Pupil allocation shall be adjusted based 29 on a factor determined by the Louisiana Department of Education to provide for the Page 17 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 differential in the number of educational days provided to the students in the custody 2 of the Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ). 3 c. Additionally, the State Cost Allocation Per Pupil shall be adjusted based 4 on a factor determined by the Louisiana Department of Education to recognize the 5 increased number of special education students in the Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) 6 schools relative to the state average special education student population. 7 d. The average daily membership will be reconciled on an annual basis using 8 the latest available data. 9 5. Local Cost Allocation 10 a. Each student counted in the prior year average daily membership, as 11 defined by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education, shall be 12 provided for and funded from the minimum foundation program a Local Cost 13 Allocation Per Pupil equal to the Local Per Pupil for the district where the student 14 resided prior to adjudication. 15 b. The Local Cost Allocation is equal to the Local Cost Allocation Per Pupil 16 for the system were each student resided prior to adjudication multiplied by the prior 17 year average daily membership of the Office of Juvenile Justice schools. 18 c. For the purpose of the Local Cost Allocation Per Pupil, the average daily 19 membership of the Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) shall be included in the 20 membership counts of the city, parish, or other local public school board in which 21 the student resided prior to adjudication to the Office of Juvenile Justice. 22 d. For a district(s) that shares local revenue, the allocation for the Office of 23 Juvenile Justice will be completed before the calculation of local revenues. 24 e. The Local Cost Allocation Per Pupil shall be funded with a transfer of the 25 MFP monthly amount representing the Local Cost Allocation Per Pupil from the city, 26 parish, or other local public school board in which the attending students resided 27 prior to adjudication to the Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ). 28 f. The average daily membership will be reconciled on an annual basis using 29 the latest available data. Page 18 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 3. Mid-Year Student Allocations 2 1. Student counts in October and February may result in mid-year allocation 3 adjustments for the following: 4 City and parish school systems, Recovery School District, New Type 2 5 Charter schools, Legacy Type 2 Charter schools, Louisiana State University 6 and Southern University Lab schools, Louisiana School for Math, Science 7 and the Arts (LSMSA), and New Orleans Center for Creative Arts 8 (NOCCA). 9 2. If the current year October 1 Mid-Year Student Count is more or less than 10 the prior year February 1 student count, an adjustment to the current year 11 allocation shall be made for each student gained or lost. The October 12 adjustment equals the number of students gained or lost times the annual 13 State Cost per pupil allocation amount for the system or school in which the 14 change occurred. The February adjustment equals the number of students 15 gained or lost times one-half of the State Cost per pupil allocation for the 16 system or school in which the change occurred. 17 3. Individual adjustments shall be made for increases or decreases in the 18 October or February Mid-Year Student Counts for the Recovery School 19 District, the system of prior jurisdiction, and Type 5 Charter schools. 20 4. Mid-Year adjustments for the Recovery School District shall utilize the 21 final State Cost per pupil allocation for the system of prior jurisdiction. 22 5. If the Recovery School District qualifies for an October Mid-Year 23 Adjustment to the State Cost per pupil allocation, a Mid-Year adjustment 24 shall also be made to the Local Cost per pupil allocation for the system of 25 prior jurisdiction. The October Local Cost per pupil allocation shall be 26 recalculated based on updated revenue data for the system of prior 27 jurisdiction. There shall be no recalculation of the Local Cost per pupil 28 allocation in conjunction with the February 1 student count. 29 6. City, parish or other public school systems or schools in the first year of 30 operation are not eligible for an October Mid-Year Adjustment. However, Page 19 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 their allocation will be finalized using October 1 data. The newly opened 2 city, parish or other public school systems or schools will qualify for the 3 February 1 mid-year adjustment. 4 7. October and February Mid-Year Adjustments shall be combined and 5 applied in the March through June payments. 6 Total MFP State Cost Allocation 7 Formula: 8 Total MFP State Cost Allocation 9 Equals 10 Level 1 State Cost Allocation 11 Plus 12 Level 2 State Cost Allocation 13 Plus 14 Level 3 State Cost Allocation 15 Plus 16 Level 4 State Cost Allocation 17 II. FORMULA CALCULATIONS FOR STATE-APPROVED PUBLIC 18 SCHOOLS 19 A. RECOVERY SCHOOL DISTRICT 20 1. State Cost Allocation 21 a. Once all final calculations are made, the final State Cost Allocation 22 Per Pupil Amount for the city or parish school system which counted 23 the Recovery School District students will be multiplied by the 24 February 1 Recovery School District Student Membership Count to 25 equal the Recovery School District State Cost Allocation. 26 b. In a system with one or more Type 3B charter schools, if the Type 3B 27 charter is not its own LEA, the local school system shall distribute 28 minimum foundation program formula funds to each Type 3B charter 29 school in the system pursuant to calculations determined by the 30 Louisiana Department of Education. If the Type 3B charter is its Page 20 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 own LEA, such payments shall be made to the Type 3B charter 2 school by the Louisiana Department of Education. Such calculations 3 shall include differentiated funding weights for certain students, 4 including students identified as being eligible for special education 5 services. The calculations shall ensure equity so that each Type 3B 6 charter school in the system receives a per-pupil amount equal to the 7 amount a Type 5 charter school located in the same parish or school 8 system boundary would have received from the Recovery School 9 District (RSD). 10 2. Local Cost Allocation 11 a. In addition to the State Cost Allocation, the Recovery School District shall 12 receive an applicable Local Cost Allocation. 13 Formula: 14 Local Cost Allocation Per Pupil 15 Equals 16 Projected Local Revenues from District of Prior Jurisdiction 17 Divided by 18 Total School District Membership (Recovery School District Student 19 Membership Count plus Student Membership Count for the system of prior 20 jurisdiction plus New Type 2 Charter school students residing in the 21 jurisdiction) 22 b. To begin the fiscal year, the Local Cost allocation is based on eligible 23 projected local revenues for the most recent prior fiscal year from the city or parish 24 school district that had jurisdiction of the school prior to its transfer. 25 c. For purposes of the Recovery School District calculation, local revenue 26 is defined to include revenue from the following sources, excluding any portion 27 which has been specifically dedicated by the legislature or by voter approval to 28 capital outlay or debt service, per the definitions in the Annual Financial Report 29 (AFR) and the Louisiana Accounting and Uniform Governmental Handbook as 30 reported to the Department of Education: Page 21 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 1. Sales and use taxes, less any tax collection fee paid by the school 2 system 3 2. Ad valorem taxes, less any tax collection fee paid by the school 4 system 5 3. Earnings from sixteenth section lands owned by the school system 6 d. The exclusion of any portion of local revenues specifically dedicated by 7 the legislature or by voter approval to capital outlay or debt service shall be 8 applicable only to a charter school housed in a facility or facilities provided by the 9 system in which the charter school is located. 10 e. The projected local revenues shall be divided by the Total School District 11 Membership Count including the Recovery School District Student Membership 12 Count, both operated and charter schools, plus the Student Membership Count of the 13 system of prior jurisdiction. If any New Type 2 Charter School student resides 14 within the physical boundaries of the system of prior jurisdiction, this school the 15 student attends shares in the local revenues of the system of prior jurisdiction. As 16 a result, the New Type 2 Charter School Student Membership Count of the students 17 residing in the jurisdiction will be added to the Recovery School District and the 18 system of prior jurisdiction Student Membership Count. 19 f. The Local Cost Allocation for the Recovery School District is determined 20 by multiplying the local revenue per pupil times the number of Recovery School 21 District students used in the MFP final allocation. 22 Formula: 23 Local Cost Allocation 24 Equals 25 Projected Local Revenues from District of Prior Jurisdiction Per Pupil 26 Multiplied By 27 Recovery School District Student Membership Count 28 g. Once the local amount is determined, it is adjusted to a monthly amount 29 that is transferred from the MFP monthly allocation of the city, parish, or other local 30 public school board of prior jurisdiction to the Recovery School District. Page 22 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 h. Based on the October 1 Student Membership Count, the local revenue 2 allocation per student will be recalculated and there will be a corresponding 3 adjustment in the local revenue allocation. No recalculation of the local revenues per 4 student will occur as a result of the February 1 Student Count adjustment. 5 i. During the third quarter of the fiscal year, the local revenue allocation per 6 student shall be adjusted to reflect actual prior year local revenue data. 7 j. A final reconciliation will occur based upon the receipt of the annual 8 audited financial statements of the system of prior jurisdiction. If an increase or 9 decrease in local revenue collections exists, the state superintendent may establish 10 a payment schedule. In the event that the fiscal status of the system of prior 11 jurisdiction or the Recovery School District changes during the fiscal year or on or 12 before the final reconciliation, the state superintendent may adjust the local revenue 13 based on the revenues identified. 14 3. Monies appropriated to the Recovery School District, except for administrative 15costs, that are attributable to the transfer of a school from a prior school system and monies 16allocated or transferred from the prior system to the Recovery School District shall be 17expended solely on the operation of schools transferred from the prior system to the 18jurisdiction of the Recovery School District. 19 B. NEW TYPE 2 CHARTER SCHOOLS 20 A New Type 2 Charter school is a Type 2 Charter school approved after July 1, 21 2008 by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education. 22 1. State Cost Allocation 23 a. Any New Type 2 Charter School shall annually be provided a State Cost 24 Allocation as determined by applying the formula contained in R.S. 17:3995. 25 b. The State Cost Allocation equals the number of students multiplied by the 26 State Cost Allocation Per Pupil for the system in which the student resides. 27 c. Mid-Year Adjustments shall adhere to the guidelines established in this 28 document. 29 2. Local Cost Allocation Page 23 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 a. Any New Type 2 Charter school shall annually be provided a Local Cost 2 Allocation by applying the funding formula contained in R. S. 17:3995. 3 b. The Local Cost Allocation equals the number of students multiplied by the 4 Local Per Pupil for the system in which the student resides. 5 c. One exception to R. S. 17:3995 is that the Local Cost allocation will be 6 funded with a transfer of the MFP monthly amount representing the Local Per Pupil 7 from the city or parish school system in which the attending students reside. 8 d. The city or parish where students attending the New Type 2 Charter 9 school reside is the local taxing authority and shall provide the local support for the 10 students. 11 e. Mid-Year Adjustments will adhere to the guidelines established in this 12 document. 13 3. Virtual Charter schools may receive, as approved by the State Board of 14 Elementary and Secondary Education, a lesser percentage of the state and local 15 amount calculated in R.S. 17:3995. 16 4. Where student attendance is from multiple school systems, the Department 17 of Education shall determine the Local Cost Allocation based on students reported 18 by the schools. The student membership count of the New Type 2 charter schools 19 shall be included in the membership count of the city or parish school board in which 20 the student resides to determine the Local Cost Allocation. 21 5. In the first year of operation, a New Type 2 Charter school shall be allocated 22 funding based on an estimated student count since a February 1 student count does 23 not exist. The allocation will be finalized based on the October 1 student count. 24 6. The exclusion of any portion of local revenues specifically dedicated by the 25 legislature or by voter approval to capital outlay or debt service shall be applicable 26 only to a charter school housed in a facility or facilities provided by the district in 27 which the charter school is located. Page 24 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 C. LOUISIANA SCHOOL FOR MATH, SCIENCE AND THE ARTS 2 (LSMSA) AND NEW ORLEANS CENTER FOR CREATIVE ARTS (NOCCA). 3 1. The Louisiana School for Math, Science and the Arts (LSMSA) and New 4 Orleans Center for Creative Arts (NOCCA) shall be provided both a State and Local 5 allocation. 6 2. State Cost Allocation 7 a. The State Cost Allocation shall be based on the State Cost Allocation 8 Per Pupil for the city or parish school system where the attending 9 students reside. 10 3. Local Cost Allocation 11 a. The Local Cost Allocation will be based on the Local Cost Allocation 12 Per Pupil for the city or parish school system where the attending 13 students reside. 14 b. For any student enrolled in LSMSA or NOCCA, the Local Cost 15 Allocation shall be funded by the State. Where student attendance is 16 from multiple school systems, the Department of Education shall 17 determine the Local Cost Allocation based on students reported by 18 the schools. 19 III.FORMULA PROCEDURES 20 A. Preliminary Allocation 21 1. The minimum foundation program formula for the upcoming fiscal 22 year adopted by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary 23 Education, along with a preliminary allocation schedule representing 24 the estimated cost of the proposed formula, shall be submitted to the 25 Joint Legislative Committee on the Budget and to the House and 26 Senate Education Committees for consideration no later than March 27 15. 28 2. This preliminary allocation shall utilize student and other input data 29 available at the time. Page 25 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 B. Final Allocation 2 Final allocations for the fiscal year in which the formula takes effect will be 3 determined no later than June 30 of the preceding fiscal year. The latest 4 available data will be utilized to calculate the final allocation except that 5 student count estimates will be utilized for school systems or charter schools 6 opening for the first time in the fiscal year beginning July 1. For first-year 7 city, parish or other public school systems or schools, the final allocation will 8 be based on the October 1 count, once available. 9 IV.FORMULA PAYMENTS 10 A.PAYMENT PROCEDURES 11 1. The Total MFP State Cost Allocation for city, parish, and other school 12 systems and schools will be converted to monthly payments from July 13 through June each year except payments will be made on Level 4 allocations 14 as data becomes available. 15 B.REQUESTED PAYMENT ADJUSTMENTS 16 1. If the city, parish, or other school systems and schools have documented 17 growth in students prior to the actual Mid-Year Student Counts in October 18 and February, a temporary change to the final allocation may be requested. 19 The State Superintendent is authorized to approve or deny this revision. 20 a. Sufficient documentation will be requested to substantiate this requested 21 allocation adjustment. 22 b. The adjusted allocation will remain in effect until the actual October or 23 February Mid-Year Student Count. Once the Mid-Year Student Count is 24 final, reconciliation will be completed and payments adjusted accordingly. 25 C. PAYMENT ADJUSTMENTS F OR AUDIT FINDINGS 26 1. Review and/or audit of the systems' or schools' data used in determining 27 their Minimum Foundation Program allocation may result in changes in final 28 statistical information. The Minimum Foundation Program allocation 29 adjustments necessary as a result of these audit findings will be made in the Page 26 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 following school year. These adjustments are applicable to the following: 2 city or parish school systems, Recovery School District, Type 2 Charter 3 schools, Louisiana State University and Southern University Lab schools, 4 Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) schools, Louisiana School for Math, Science 5 and the Arts (LSMSA), and New Orleans Center for Creative Arts 6 (NOCCA). 7 V. 70% EXPENDITURE REQUIREMENT 8 To provide for appropriate accountability of state funds while providing city, parish, 9 or local public school systems or schools flexibility in determining specific 10 expenditures, city, parish, or local public school systems or other public schools must 11 ensure that 70% of the city, parish, or local public school system or other public 12 school general fund expenditures are in the areas of instruction and school 13 administration at the school building level as developed by the Department of 14 Education and defined by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education 15 regulations. 16 VI. PAY RAISE REQUIREMENT 17 If a city, parish, or local public school system or school has a net increase from 18 2014-2015 to 2015-2016 in its per student Level 1 and 2 State Cost Allocation, the 19 city, parish, or local public school system or school shall be required to sustain the 20 certificated classroom teacher pay raises provided by appropriation in 2013-2014. 21 If the city, parish, or local public school system or school has established plans to 22 sustain or increase the teacher pay raises provided for by the 2013-2014 23 appropriation prior to the development of this formula, then this provision shall not 24 apply. 25 VII. SEVERABILITY PROVISION 26 If any provision of this minimum foundation formula or the application thereof is 27 held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of this 28 minimum foundation formula which can be given effect without the invalid 29 provisions or applications, and to this end the provisions of this minimum foundation 30 formula are hereby declared severable. The severability provision hereof shall be Page 27 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 1 broadly construed so as to give effect to each and every possible provision or 2 application of this minimum foundation formula which is not specifically held 3 invalid, unlawful, or unconstitutional. 4 THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Legislature of Louisiana does hereby 5approve the formula developed by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education 6pursuant to Article VIII, Section 13(B) of the Constitution of Louisiana to determine the cost 7of a minimum foundation program of education in all public elementary and secondary 8schools as well as to equitably allocate the funds to parish and city school systems, and 9adopted by the board on March 6, 2015. DIGEST The digest printed below was prepared by House Legislative Services. It constitutes no part of the legislative instrument. The keyword, one-liner, abstract, and digest do not constitute part of the law or proof or indicia of legislative intent. [R.S. 1:13(B) and 24:177(E)] HCR 18 Engrossed 2015 Regular Session Carter Provides for legislative approval of the minimum foundation program (MFP) formula for FY 2015-2016 to determine the cost of a minimum foundation program of education in all public elementary and secondary schools as well as to equitably allocate the funds to local public school systems as developed by the State Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) and adopted by the board on March 6, 2015. Proposed formula utilizes four levels to determine MFP funding allocations for city, parish, or other local public school systems or schools as follows: Level 1 - Calculate State and Local Cost Allocation (1)Maintains use of Feb. 1 membership as defined by BESE and provides that each student is counted as 1.0 in the formula. (2)Provides that students counted are enrolled in the following school districts and schools: •Parish and city school systems •Recovery School District Schools, both operated and Type 5 Charter schools •Type 2 Charter schools •LSU and Southern Lab Schools •Office of Juvenile Justice (OJJ) schools (3)Maintains the existing weight of 22% for add-on student units for at-risk and English language learner students. (4)Maintains the existing weight of 150% for Special Education Students with disabilities. (5)Maintains the 60% existing weight for Gifted and Talented Students. (6)Maintains the existing weight of 6% for Career and Technical Education course units. Page 28 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 (7)Maintains the Economy of Scale curvilinear weight of 20% for school systems with a student membership of less than 7,500. Base Per Pupil Amount - Proposed formula provides for a base per pupil funding amount of $4,015, which represents a 1.375% increase. Level 1 continues to determine the proportion of the costs supported by the state and local school systems as follows: (1)Retains provisions that the calculation of the local school system share of the total MFP cost includes a property tax revenue contribution, a sales tax revenue contribution, and an other revenue contribution: (2)Retains provisions specifying that in no event shall the state share of the total Level 1 costs be less than 25% for any district. Level 2 - Incentive for Local Effort - Continues as follows: (1)Retains provisions to provide rewards to school districts that contribute a greater proportion of local revenue towards the cost of education by increasing local property and sales tax revenues. (2)Limit on Revenue Eligible for Reward is equal to the total state and local cost multiplied by 34%. (3)Continues provision that the Level 2 Reward Factor determines the amount of local support required in Level 2. Establishes the Level 1 Reward Factor at 1.72%. Level 3 -Legislative Allocations Retains Level 3 as "Legislative Allocations" as follows: Continuation of Funding for Pay Raises (1)Continues supplemental pay raises for certificated personnel initiated in 2001-02, 2006-07, 2007-08, and 2008-09 as a per pupil amount. (2)Continues supplemental pay raises for non-certificated support workers initiated in 2002-03, 2006-07, and 2007-08 as a per pupil amount. Hold Harmless Enhancement (1)Continues the 10-year phase-out of hold harmless funding for Concordia, East Baton Rouge, Evangeline, Iberville, Jefferson, Plaquemines, St. Bernard, St. James, and West Feliciana parishes, beginning with a 10% reduction of the revised "over funded" amount in FY 07-08. (2)Retains provision that a Hold Harmless district may choose to reduce the remaining balance by an amount greater than 10%, provided such request is made by June 30th each year. (3)Retains provision that the annual 10% reduction amount will be redistributed to all non-hold harmless districts on a per pupil basis. Support for Increasing Mandated Costs in Health Insurance, Retirement, and Fuel Continues provision that local school systems shall receive a per pupil funding amount of $100 to support increasing mandated costs involving health insurance, retirement, and fuel. Level 4 - Supplementary Allocations Page 29 of 30 HLS 15RS-1078 ENGROSSED HCR NO. 18 Foreign Language Associate Enhancement Retains as follows with regard to foreign language associate teachers: (1)Retains the supplemental allocation of $21,000 for each Foreign Language Associate or a graduate of the Escadrille Louisiane program employed.. Retains provision that the number of these teachers is not to exceed a total of 300 teachers. Specifies that the additional $1,000 is to be used toward the costs of VISA sponsorship. (2)Retains requirement that these teachers be paid by the employing school board at least the state average classroom teacher salary (without PIP) by years of experience and degree beginning with year three. Proposed formula additionally provides that the supplemental allocation must be allocated to the school where the teacher is employed and the funds used to support the total cost of the teacher's salary. (3)Retains requirement that first year teachers be paid an installment incentive of an additional $6,000 and that second and third year teachers shall receive a retention incentive of an additional $4,000. Specifies that these amounts will be provided by the employing school district. Career Development Allocation Supports technical courses required for statewide credentials. Retains that allocation is equal to 6% of the base per pupil amount o for each qualifying course enrollment. Each school system is to receive a minimum amount of $25,000 and other state-approved public schools with students enrolled in grades 9 - 12 will receive a minimum of $10,000 per school. High Cost Services Assistance Provides additional funds for students with disabilities. Retains that the total allocation for public school systems versus other public schools shall be proportional to the share of total qualifying applications submitted by public school systems versus other public schools. Proposed formula increases maximum allocation to $9.4 million and revises the allocation methodology so that all entities within each group, city and parish school systems and other public school systems, shall receive the same percent of the requested allocation. Supplemental Course Allocation Pursuant to present law relative to the Course Choice Program., provides for the cost of secondary course choices specifically approved by BESE. Proposed formula retains the allocation for each public school system and other public school and increases from $26 to $35 the per student enrolled in grades seven through 12. 70% Local General Fund Required Instructional Expenditure at the School Building Level Proposed formula retains the requirement that 70% of general fund expenditures must be in the areas of instruction and school administration at the school building level. Pay Raise Requirement Proposed formula provides that if a city, parish, or local public school system or other public school has a net increase from 2013-2014 to 2014-2015 in its per student Level 1 and 2 State Cost Allocation, the city, parish, or local public school system or other public school shall be required to sustain the certificated classroom teacher pay raises provided by appropriation in 2013-2014. Further provides that if the city, parish, or local public school system or other public school has established plans to sustain or increase the teacher pay raises provided for by the 2013-2014 appropriation prior to the development of proposed formula, then this provision shall not apply. Page 30 of 30