Louisiana 2016 Regular Session

Louisiana House Bill HB1035

Introduced
4/5/16  
Introduced
4/5/16  
Refer
4/6/16  
Refer
4/6/16  
Report Pass
5/18/16  
Report Pass
5/18/16  
Engrossed
6/3/16  
Engrossed
6/3/16  
Refer
6/5/16  

Caption

Requires local school boards to require students in grades four through six to recite a specified passage from the Declaration of Independence (EG NO IMPACT LF EX See Note)

Impact

The enactment of HB 1035 would lead to a state-mandated practice for public schools, altering existing policies that only allowed for voluntary activities related to prayer, meditation, or the Pledge of Allegiance. Supporters argue that incorporating this recitation into the daily routine of students could enhance their understanding of American values and history. It represents a state-level push toward upholding patriotic traditions within educational environments, potentially influencing similar legislative efforts elsewhere.

Summary

House Bill 1035 mandates that local school boards in Louisiana require students in grades four through six to recite a specific passage from the Declaration of Independence at the beginning of each school day. This bill aims to instill a sense of national pride and recognition of fundamental rights among elementary students. The passage, which emphasizes the equality of all men and the rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, has been chosen to introduce students to significant historical texts and foster civic engagement.

Sentiment

Reactions to HB 1035 have been mixed. Proponents, including many of the bill's sponsors, celebrate it as a positive step towards reinforcing patriotism and historical knowledge among young students. Critics, however, express concerns regarding the compulsory nature of the bill, fearing it could infringe on personal freedoms and the individual rights of students who may hold different beliefs or cultural backgrounds. The discussion highlights the ongoing debate around the role of government in educational practices and values taught in schools.

Contention

Key points of contention surrounding HB 1035 include discussions about the implications of mandated recitation on students' rights. Detractors argue that requiring a specific passage might overstep personal freedoms and encourage a uniformity of thought that could suppress diverse viewpoints. Additionally, some educators and parents worry about the appropriateness of imposing such a requirement on young students, which may divert focus from other essential educational content. The bill prompts a broader conversation about patriotism's place in education and the appropriate boundaries of legislative involvement in school curricula.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA SB641

Requires governing authorities of public and state-approved nonpublic schools to require students in grades four through six to recite a specified passage from the Declaration of Independence. (8/1/12)

LA HB145

Requires rather than authorizes that students be given the opportunity to recite the Pledge of Allegiance to the United States Flag in public schools

LA A3634

Requires principals and teachers of public schools to conduct an oral recitation from Declaration of Independence before opening of school each day in grades 3-12; appropriates $10,000.

LA HB887

Creates a residential school for certain at-risk students in grades six through twelve (EN INCREASE GF EX See Note)

LA HB1222

A requirement for public school students to have the opportunity to recite the pledge of allegiance each morning and immunity for liability stemming from the recitation of the pledge of allegiance.

LA HB730

Requires students to have the same two teachers throughout K-4 (OR INCREASE LF EX See Note)

LA SB819

Requiring heart health program in grades three through six

LA HB359

Requires public school governing authorities in Orleans Parish to offer sex education instruction to students in certain grades (EG +$500,000 LF EX See Note)

LA HB115

Removes certain instructional requirements for students in kindergarten through third grade

LA HB913

Requires local school boards to notify parents of school bus drivers' criminal convictions (OR NO IMPACT LF EX See Note)

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.