Louisiana House Bill HB359

Louisiana 2017 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/31/17
• Refer: 3/31/17
• Refer: 4/10/17
• Report Pass: 5/8/17
• Engrossed: 5/31/17

Caption

Provides for a flat tax rate for purposes of calculating individual income tax, increases the amount of the earned income tax credit, and modifies other income tax credits and deductions (RE +$5,000,000 GF RV See Note)

Impact

The proposed changes are designed to streamline tax calculations and reduce complexities for taxpayers. Supporters argue that these modifications could incentivize economic activity by simplifying tax obligations and improving compliance. However, the repeal of federal tax deductibility and changes to deductions and credits may burden higher-income residents and those with dependents, potentially leading to public discontent regarding the bill's fairness. Given the contingent nature of its effectiveness, these changes are also predicated on other constitutional amendments being passed.

Summary

House Bill 359 intends to modify Louisiana's individual income tax structure by introducing a flat tax rate of 3.95%, replacing the existing graduated rate system. The initial threshold where no tax is assessed would be raised to $12,500, effectively providing relief for lower-income taxpayers. Moreover, the bill stipulates that deductions for federal income taxes paid would no longer be permitted in state tax calculations. This significantly modifies how residents and estates calculate their taxable income and deductions in Louisiana, emphasizing simplicity and uniformity in tax liability assessments.

Sentiment

Sentiments around HB 359 are mixed. There is a strong advocacy from some legislators and business groups who believe that a flat tax rate can catalyze economic growth by making the tax system less complicated. Conversely, criticism arises from various civil groups and opponents who claim that these changes disproportionately affect lower and middle-income families, especially in repealing federal deductions, which could result in higher effective tax rates for these demographics. Hence, the discussions surrounding the bill reflect fundamental differences in opinions regarding tax equity.

Contention

One of the key points of contention is the impact on tax equity; opponents are particularly concerned about the eliminated deductibility of federal taxes, which they argue disproportionately affects those with lower incomes and may reduce the overall tax benefits previously available. Additionally, there is debate over whether the flat tax rate adequately addresses the financial needs of families, particularly those with dependents who will now receive a lower deduction compared to previous provisions. The effectiveness of the proposed bill hinges on successful amendments to the state's constitution, adding a layer of uncertainty to its potential impacts.