Louisiana 2021 Regular Session

Louisiana Senate Bill SCR45

Introduced
5/4/21  
Introduced
5/4/21  
Refer
5/5/21  
Refer
5/5/21  
Report Pass
5/18/21  
Report Pass
5/18/21  
Passed
5/19/21  
Passed
5/19/21  
Engrossed
5/20/21  
Engrossed
5/20/21  
Refer
5/24/21  
Refer
5/25/21  
Refer
5/25/21  
Refer
5/26/21  

Caption

Creates the Survivor Informed Task Force.

Impact

The establishment of the Survivor Informed Task Force is a significant step in addressing a pressing issue within the Louisiana legal system, specifically the incarceration rates of individuals with traumatic backgrounds. The task force is directed to analyze current procedures by law enforcement and courts to appropriately screen for trauma and abuse, thereby recommending systemic changes that could lead to more trauma-informed practices within the criminal justice system. These changes may ultimately lead to policy recommendations that enhance the protection of survivors and offer them viable pathways to relief.

Summary

SCR45 creates the Survivor Informed Task Force tasked with studying the connections between trauma, abuse, and subsequent incarceration among individuals, particularly focusing on secondary survivors of domestic and intimate partner violence. The task force is responsible for recommending legislation that addresses the realities faced by those impacted by trauma and abuse. This initiative aims to provide alternatives to incarceration and to support legislative changes aimed at protecting survivors who might otherwise face criminal charges for their actions related to self-defense or coercion by an abuser.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding SCR45 reflects a growing awareness of the plight of trauma survivors within the criminal justice system. Supporters express optimism that the task force will provide necessary insights and highlight systemic issues that have historically led to further victimization of survivors of abuse. However, there may also be contention regarding the execution of recommended reforms and how they will be integrated into existing laws.

Contention

Notably, while the task force aims to address the incarceration of survivors, some discussions likely revolve around the balance of justice for victims versus accountability for those who may have committed crimes under duress. There are challenges in ensuring that the legal definitions of self-defense are adequate and equitable, particularly for marginalized groups disproportionately affected by domestic violence. The effectiveness of possible legislative changes, including those reflecting practices seen in other states, will be critical areas of focus moving forward.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Similar Bills

LA SR145

Creates a task force relative to admissibility of expert testimony for victims of domestic violence under certain circumstances.

LA HCR97

Requests a study of case law and best practices to better understand other approaches to parole

LA SR150

Requests the Louisiana State Law Institute to study and make recommendations on the general provisions of justification and use of force or violence in defense as applied to abuse survivors.

LA HR51

Provides relative to study of compassionate release, medical treatment furlough, and medical parole requirements

LA HR83

Recognizes April 26, 2022, as Survivors of Violence Lobby Day at the state capitol

LA HR198

Requests the House Committee on the Administration of Criminal Justice to study the issue of non-capital felony sentencing

LA SR183

Creates a commission to study and make recommendations relative to non-unanimous jury verdicts in Louisiana to determine the number and distribution of such cases, and to inform the Senate of the findings.

LA HB744

Provides relative to the rights of sexual assault victims