2021 Regular Session ENROLLED SENATE RESOLUTION NO. 100 BY SENATORS FOIL, BARROW AND WARD A RESOLUTION To urge and request the Louisiana State Law Institute to study and make recommendations relative to collateral consequences that can hinder persons with criminal records from obtaining employment or occupational licenses. WHEREAS, there are many barriers associated with a criminal record, including difficulty in finding gainful employment and obtaining occupational licenses; and WHEREAS, while Louisiana law generally prohibits the denial of licensure based upon a criminal conviction that is not "directly related" to the licensed activity, twenty-seven licensing bodies are exempt from these general limitations on conviction-based disqualification, including most health care related boards, and there are no general limitations on the imposition of these structural barriers to employment or business licensure; and WHEREAS, Louisiana law places no general limits on the age of convictions that may be considered by employers or licensing bodies; and WHEREAS, more than five hundred of the employment-related collateral consequences imposed by Louisiana law may be triggered by any felony whatsoever, and more than two hundred may be triggered by any crime at all; and WHEREAS, Louisiana law does not generally require individualized consideration of applicants and their convictions in private employment or licensing determinations; and WHEREAS, few employment and licensing applications provide specific information as to whether or how criminal history is considered, even those that inform applicants that background checks may be required; and WHEREAS, there is scant online information about how criminal history is considered by employers and licensing bodies; and WHEREAS, Louisiana law does not require employers to provide prospective applicants with a list of the specific offenses that may be disqualifying; and Page 1 of 3 SR NO. 100 ENROLLED WHEREAS, Louisiana law does not generally require licensing bodies to identify the specific convictions that may result in a discretionary denial; and WHEREAS, Louisiana law does not generally require or authorize a process for determining pre-application eligibility for employment or licensing; and WHEREAS, although the law governing consideration of convictions for public employment in unclassified positions suggests that an individualized approach should be taken, it falls short of actually requiring it; and WHEREAS, while Louisiana law generally requires occupational and professional licensing bodies to provide applicants who are denied licensure due to a conviction with written notice describing the reasons for denial, this requirement does not apply to the twenty-seven licensing bodies not already subject to the general prohibitions on conviction-based disqualification; and WHEREAS, Louisiana law does not generally provide accessible pathways to appeal or review that are specific to conviction-based licensing or public employment denials; and WHEREAS, although review may be available under the state's general administrative laws, this review process can be complex, costly, and prolonged; and WHEREAS, while long-term relief for persons with a criminal history is most commonly available in the form of expungement, Louisiana does not offer generally applicable near-term relief from structural barriers to employment or licensure, either in the form of certificates of relief or other mechanisms that mitigate the impact of these structural barriers; and WHEREAS, while expungement may be granted without a hearing so long as no objections are brought by law enforcement or the prosecution, it is not automatic and is available only upon petition to the court; and WHEREAS, expungement can be prohibitively costly for some persons, and can be burdensome for those seeking expungement without an attorney because of the documentation and filing requirements, complex eligibility determinations, and the fact that a hearing may be required in some cases; and WHEREAS, although expungement shields the record from public access and prohibits a person from being required to disclose an expunged conviction, Louisiana law Page 2 of 3 SR NO. 100 ENROLLED does not explicitly prohibit employers or licensing bodies from considering convictions that have been expunged, and expungement law specifically gives many licensing bodies the authority to access expunged records; and WHEREAS, the legislature could benefit from a comprehensive review of Louisiana's laws relative to collateral consequences that can hinder a person with a criminal record from obtaining employment or an occupational license. THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Senate of the Legislature of Louisiana does hereby urge and request the Louisiana State Law Institute to review and study Louisiana's laws relative to collateral consequences of a criminal record on a person's ability to obtain employment or an occupational license, in order to determine any need to amend or clarify existing law, or enact new laws, that might negate or mitigate these collateral consequences, and to make recommendations for proposed legislation to further this goal. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this study should include, but not be limited to, recommendations for legislation that would: (1) Allow employers and licensing bodies greater flexibility in deciding whether to employ or grant licenses to persons with convictions, and allow applicants and employees to be free from collateral consequences after a reasonable period of time. (2) Align offenses that trigger collateral consequences with valid public safety concerns. (3) Promote fair, consistent application of discretionary consequences. (4) Promote transparency relative to how an applicant's or employee's criminal record is likely to impact employment and licensing opportunities. (5) Expand the availability and effect of near-term and long-term relief mechanisms. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Louisiana State Law Institute shall submit a report detailing the results of its study and its recommendations for proposed legislation to the legislature no later than February 1, 2022. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a copy of this Resolution be transmitted to the director of the Louisiana State Law Institute. PRESIDENT OF THE SENATE Page 3 of 3