Louisiana House Bill HB315

Louisiana 2010 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/29/10
• Refer: 3/29/10

Caption

Creates the crime of communicating false information to a law enforcement officer attempting to serve a protective order (OR INCREASE LF EX See Note)

Impact

The passage of HB 315 would amend existing laws by introducing specific penalties for individuals who mislead law enforcement officers in the context of protective orders. Violators could face a fine of up to $500 and imprisonment for up to six months. This legislative change aims to strengthen the enforcement of protective orders and, by extension, provide better protection for victims of domestic abuse and ensure that law enforcement can effectively carry out their duties without being thwarted by deception.

Summary

House Bill 315 aims to create the crime of communicating false information to a law enforcement officer while that officer is attempting to serve a protective order. The bill specifies that it is unlawful for any person to knowingly provide false or misleading statements with the intent to mislead the officer regarding the identification, location, or residence of a person involved in a protective order case. This legislation primarily targets incidents where false information can hinder law enforcement's ability to execute protective orders intended to prevent domestic violence and related threats.

Sentiment

The overall sentiment toward HB 315 is generally supportive among lawmakers and advocates focused on protecting victims of domestic violence. Proponents argue that implementing clear penalties for providing false information will help ensure that protective orders are respected and efficiently served. However, some voice concerns regarding the potential for laws to be misapplied or for individuals to be unduly penalized due to misunderstandings during law enforcement encounters, emphasizing the importance of clear communication and procedural integrity in such matters.

Contention

A notable point of contention arises from the balance between enforcing protective orders and preserving the rights of individuals who may be accused of providing false information. Critics may argue that this law could be used to silence legitimate concerns or create barriers for those facing accusations, especially if they believe they are acting in good faith. Ensuring that enforcement does not disproportionally affect vulnerable populations remains a critical issue highlighted in the discussions surrounding HB 315.