Louisiana 2020 2nd Special Session

Louisiana House Bill HCR23

Introduced
10/5/20  
Refer
10/5/20  
Refer
10/5/20  
Engrossed
10/13/20  
Engrossed
10/13/20  
Refer
10/14/20  
Passed
10/19/20  

Caption

Memorializes the United States Senate to confirm the nomination of Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the United States Supreme Court

Impact

This resolution, while non-binding, represents a formal stance from the Louisiana legislature urging affirmation of Barrett's nomination. HCR23 acts as a declaration of support for Barrett, highlighting her Louisiana roots and her esteemed academic and professional credentials. By customizing the resolution to spotlight Barrett's potential role on the Supreme Court, it connects the state’s identity with national judicial processes, potentially enhancing local pride and interest in federal judicial appointments.

Summary

House Concurrent Resolution No. 23 (HCR23) seeks to memorialize the United States Senate to take action necessary for confirming President Donald Trump's nomination of Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the United States Supreme Court. The resolution was introduced in the context of filling the seat left vacant by the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. It emphasizes Barrett's qualifications and commendable judicial record, reflecting a strong belief in the integrity of the judiciary and the preservation of constitutional values.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HCR23 is predominantly positive within the circles that support Barrett’s confirmation. Legislators articulated a strong belief that her appointment would uphold constitutional integrity and align with conservative judicial philosophies. However, it is likely that opposition existed outside the legislature, as Barrett’s nomination was a subject of national debate, with concerns about her potential impact on key legal and social issues, such as abortion and healthcare.

Contention

While the resolution itself did not present specific points of contention within the text, the context of Barrett's nomination was fraught with controversy. Critics of her nomination expressed fears over her judicial philosophy and certain past rulings, which could significantly affect landmark decisions on civil rights and social welfare. Moreover, the timing of her nomination, just weeks before a presidential election, raised further political tensions, with many arguing it was inappropriate to proceed with the confirmation process under such circumstances.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

LA S2865

Senate Resolution Congratulating The Honorable Ketanji Brown Jackson On Being Confirmed To The United States Supreme Court

LA HR116

Commends Shelly Dick on her confirmation as the first female judge for the United States District Court, Middle District of Louisiana

LA SR00011

Resolution Memorializing The United States Senate To Conduct Confirmation Hearings For The President's Nominee To Fill The Vacancy On The United States Supreme Court.

LA H8106

House Resolution Congratulating The Honorable Ketanji Brown Jackson On Being Confirmed To The United States Supreme Court

LA AR139

Commemorates appointment of Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson as Associate Justice of United States Supreme Court.

LA SR11

Memorializes Congress to confirm a Supreme Court Justice to fill the late Justice Antonin Scalia's seat upon receiving a nomination from President Barack Obama.

LA HCR85

Requests that the United States Supreme Court Justices Ginsburg and Kagan recuse themselves in the case of Obergefell v. Hodges

LA HCR16

Commends Madame Chief Justice Bernette Joshua Johnson of the Louisiana Supreme Court on her retirement

LA SCR106

Commends Chief Judge Felicia Toney Williams upon her ascension to the position in the Second Circuit Court of Appeal.

LA AR39

Urges Rutgers, The State University to memorialize United States Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg by naming a building on campus after her.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.