The proposed change signifies a shift in the oversight of historic preservation reviews and could streamline the process for project proposals related to Hawaiian lands. By allowing the DHHL to directly oversee the impact analyses on historic properties or burial sites, supporters of the bill argue that it could facilitate better management of heritage and cultural sites relevant to Native Hawaiian interests. This could potentially expedite project approvals and enhance the efficiency of the regulatory framework governing land use and historic preservation in Hawaii.
Summary
House Bill 970 aims to amend Section 6E-8 of the Hawaii Revised Statutes, specifically in relation to the management and preservation of Hawaii's historic properties and burial sites. The bill seeks to empower the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL) to take the lead on reviews of proposals for projects on lands under its jurisdiction. Historically, the DHHL has been required to consult with the Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR) before advancing any projects that may impact such sites; however, HB970 proposes to allow DHHL to assume direct responsibility for these reviews.
Contention
There may be concerns regarding the efficacy and thoroughness of reviews conducted solely by the DHHL without mandatory consultation with the DLNR. Critics of the bill might argue that independent reviews by DHHL could lack the multi-perspective oversight that current regulations provide. The balance between promoting development and protecting cultural heritage is pivotal in this context, and stakeholders may have differing views on how best to achieve that balance.