Montana 2023 Regular Session

Montana House Bill HB533

Introduced
2/14/23  

Caption

Prohibit discrimination by nonpublic school receiving tax credit scholarships

Impact

The bill amends existing laws, specifically Sections 15-30-3102 and 15-30-3103 of the Montana Code Annotated. It establishes clearer guidelines for what constitutes a 'qualified education provider'. For example, accredited, provisional accreditation, or non-accredited status must be explicitly disclosed to parents, ensuring transparency. Additionally, the bill mandates that student scholarship organizations must ensure compliance with these rules and guarantees that scholarships are broadly available to eligible students regardless of the specific provider they choose.

Summary

House Bill 533, introduced by E. Stafman, seeks to revise the laws surrounding tax credit scholarships in Montana, particularly focusing on the qualifications and limitations of educational providers receiving such scholarships. Notably, the legislation prohibits qualified education providers from promoting certain viewpoints related to race, religion, or culture as part of their instruction. This is designed to ensure that schools maintain a neutral educational environment while accepting tax benefits through scholarship programs.

Contention

A point of contention surrounding HB 533 is the interpretation of 'certain viewpoints' and how it may affect the curriculum presented at qualified education providers. Critics argue that the legislation could restrict academic freedom and the ability of educators to teach comprehensive courses that address historical and social issues. Proponents, on the other hand, argue that the bill is necessary to protect students from biased instruction and to create educational environments that respect diversity without imposing certain ideologies on students.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

MT HB442

Require testing for nonpublic schools receiving tax credit scholarships

MT HB441

Implement report cards for nonpublic schools receiving tax credit scholarships

MT HB408

Revise student scholarship organization and innovative education tax credits

MT HB393

Schools, failing, scholarships for students assigned to in order to attend another public or nonpublic school, income tax credits for contributions to scholarship granting organizations increased, Sec. 16-6D-9 am'd.

MT SB261

Schools, failing, scholarships for students assigned to in order to attend another public or nonpublic school, income tax credits for contributions to scholarship granting organizations increased, Sec. 16-6D-9 am'd.

MT SB253

Revise administrative and certification processes for student scholarship organizations

MT HB2014

STOs; scholarships; corporate tax credits

MT HB1607

Prohibiting unlawful discrimination in public and nonpublic schools.

MT SB630

Relating to scholarships for use at participating nonpublic schools.

MT H0387

Prohibited Discrimination Based on Hairstyle

Similar Bills

UT HB0398

Special Needs Opportunity Scholarship Program Amendments

UT SB0107

Education Scholarship Amendments

UT SB0062

Special Needs Opportunity Scholarship Program Amendments

CA AB2480

Income taxes: credit: Scholarship Tax Credit Program Act.

AL HB442

To create the Alabama Fits All Scholarship Program; require the State Board of Education to contract with a program manager to administer the program; to authorize the program manager to establish scholarship accounts on behalf of eligible students; to prohibit a program manager from accepting scholarship funds in certain circumstances; to require fiscal safeguards and accountability measures; to require eligible schools and service providers to meet certain standards to be eligible to receive scholarship funds; to authorize the program manager to distribute scholarship funds; to require the State Board of Education to provide limited oversight of the program manager, including an appeal process for the program manager's administrative decisions; to prohibit certain regulations of eligible schools and eligible service providers; to require criminal history background information checks for employees and officers of a program manager; to provide for program funding; and to require the program manager and the board to submit reports on the program to the Legislature.

MS HB747

Mississippi Scholarship Act; create to provide scholarships to K-12 public school students.

MS HB874

Mississippi Scholarship Act; create to provide scholarships to K-12 public school students.

UT HB0529

Utah Fits All Scholarship Program Amendments