Montana 2023 Regular Session

Montana Senate Bill SB458

Introduced
2/22/23  
Refer
2/22/23  
Refer
3/2/23  
Engrossed
3/20/23  
Refer
3/22/23  
Enrolled
4/27/23  

Caption

Define sex in Montana law

Impact

The bill's implications for state laws are significant as it modifies existing Montana statutes to ensure all references to the term 'sex' are uniform. This could bring about changes in how gender-related issues are addressed in various sectors, including employment, education, and healthcare. Furthermore, supporters argue that this clarity may help protect against discrimination and promote equality, particularly for individuals of diverse gender identities. Critics, however, express concern that such definitions may lead to exclusionary practices against non-traditional gender identities and could impact rights gained in previous legislation.

Summary

Senate Bill 458 aims to establish a standardized definition of 'sex' in Montana law, for use across various statutes. The bill reflects a growing trend among states to clarify definitions related to gender and sexuality, potentially impacting areas such as healthcare, civil rights, and education. By providing a common understanding of the term 'sex', SB458 seeks to eliminate ambiguity and create consistency in legal interpretations and applications across Montana's legal framework.

Sentiment

The sentiment around SB458 is sharply divided, reflecting broader societal debates over gender identity, rights, and recognition. Proponents assert that the bill will assist in clarifying legal protections for all individuals, fostering a more equitable society. In contrast, opponents fear that the legislation may reinforce binary gender norms and undermine the rights of those who don't fit within conventional definitions of gender, raising significant ethical and moral dilemmas.

Contention

Notable points of contention include concerns regarding the potential consequences for LGBTQ+ individuals and the fear that this bill could lead to discriminatory practices under a guise of legal clarity. The debate highlights a crucial conflict over how states should define and regulate gender and sexuality, with implications for civil rights and individual liberties in the broader context.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

MT SB437

Revise definition of sex in Montana law

MT SB218

Provide for private right of action for injuries caused by certain medical interventions to treat gender dysphoria

MT SB99

Provide for a youth health protection act

MT HB405

Relating to definitions used in state law; to provide legislative findings; to amend Section 1-1-1, Code of Alabama 1975, to define terms and delete obsolete or unnecessary definitions; to require vital statistics records to identify each individual as male or female at birth; and to make nonsubstantive, technical revisions to update the existing code language to current style.

MT HB121

Provide privacy in certain restrooms, changing rooms, and sleeping quarters

MT SB2812

Definitions; define certain terms including "male" and "female."

MT HB111

Sex-based terms, defined; vital statistics, report sex as male or female at birth required, legislative policy regarding sex and gender identity established

MT HB1474

The definition of female, male, sex, and scrap metal dealer.

MT HB9218

Defining Male and Female Act of 2024

MT HB107

Sex-based terms, defined; vital statistics, report sex as male or female at birth required, legislative policy regarding sex and gender identity established

Similar Bills

MT SB437

Revise definition of sex in Montana law

MS HB522

Disabilities, persons with; modernize terminology used to refer to.

KS HB2359

Enacting the uniform adult guardianship and protective proceedings jurisdiction act and the uniform guardianship, conservatorship and other protective arrangements act.

MS HB98

Disabilities, persons with; modernize terminology used to refer to.

VA HB2535

Uniform Health Care Decisions Act; created, repeals most provisions of Health Care Decisions Act.

MS HB118

Disabilities, persons with; modernize terminology used to refer to.

UT HB0334

Guardianships and Supported Decision-Making Agreements Amendments

MT HB851

Create department of health services