Utah 2023 Regular Session

Utah Senate Bill SB0135

Introduced
1/25/23  
Refer
1/26/23  
Report Pass
1/30/23  
Engrossed
2/8/23  
Refer
2/17/23  
Report Pass
2/22/23  
Enrolled
3/9/23  

Caption

Government Transportation Cost Amendments

Impact

The passage of SB 135 would bring significant changes to state laws related to the cost burden faced by individuals in the criminal justice system. By clarifying the fees incurred through the transportation of defendants, the bill seeks to ensure that costs remain reasonable and directly related to the services provided by the county sheriff. This change aims to mitigate potential economic burdens on individuals who are required to participate in court proceedings, as well as to alter how these costs are reported and collected. Moreover, the bill's amendments to provisions previously addressing transportation costs signal a shift towards providing clearer regulations that could assist both legal practitioners and defendants alike.

Summary

Senate Bill 135, known as the Government Transportation Cost Amendments, aims to revise the existing laws regarding the costs associated with the transportation of individuals who are charged with or convicted of crimes. The bill provides important clarifications on the fees that sheriffs can charge for transporting prisoners to court proceedings in civil actions, while also repealing provisions that previously addressed government transportation costs as part of a criminal sentence. Additionally, the bill amends the requirements for reporting transportation costs to the court clerk, thus streamlining the process and enhancing clarity around these financial obligations.

Sentiment

The general sentiment surrounding SB 135 appears to be neutral to positive among its supporters, with many recognizing the need for clearer guidelines regarding transportation costs in the criminal justice system. This sentiment reflects an understanding that the current system can be convoluted and burdensome for defendants and law enforcement agencies alike. However, as with many legislative proposals, there may be pockets of opposition or concerns about other implications of the bill, specifically regarding the cost-setting authority granted to local sheriffs and the potential for inconsistent fee structures across different jurisdictions.

Contention

A notable point of contention surrounding SB 135 revolves around the authority given to county sheriffs to set fees, as well as the implications of these fee structures on economically disadvantaged defendants. While the bill aims to standardize and regulate these costs, there could be concerns regarding the potential for the billing process to remain opaque or overly burdensome, leading to disparities in treatment based on an individual's financial situation. Additionally, the repeal of previous provisions addressing transportation costs as part of sentencing may lead to questions about the impact on restitution and how transportation expenses are prioritized in relation to other court-ordered fees.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

UT SB0179

Transportation Amendments

UT SB0051

Transportation Amendments

UT HB0430

Local Government Transportation Services Amendments

UT SB0188

Inmate Amendments

UT SB0185

Transportation Amendments

UT SB0195

Transportation Amendments

UT SB117

Reduce Transportation Costs Imposed by Government

UT HB0229

Transportation Funds Amendments

UT SB381

Revises provisions relating to governmental administration. (BDR 20-1076)

UT SB0169

Governmental Immunity Act Amendments

Similar Bills

CA AB394

Public transportation providers.

TX SB1583

Relating to the trapping and transport of surplus white-tailed deer.

TX HB3977

Relating to the capture and transport of certain deer; providing a penalty.

TX SB498

Relating to the trapping and transport of surplus white-tailed deer.

TX HB1025

Relating to the trapping and transport of surplus white-tailed deer.

CA AB820

Homelessness: transport.

CA AB1233

Transportation Inspector General.

CA AB2460

Department of Consumer Affairs: Bureau of Household Goods and Services: household movers.