South Dakota 2023 Regular Session

South Dakota House Bill HB1182

Introduced
1/30/23  

Caption

Allow the parole of inmates sentenced to life imprisonment without parole for crimes committed under age twenty-one.

Impact

The bill aims to modernize the approach to sentencing and parole, particularly for young offenders, by recognizing their potential for rehabilitation. By allowing for discretionary parole consideration, HB1182 shifts the focus from punitive measures to second chances, suggesting that individuals who made youthful mistakes can be re-evaluated for reintegration into society. The implications for state criminal laws could alter how similar cases are handled in the future, potentially reducing the number of individuals serving life sentences for actions committed in their youth.

Summary

House Bill 1182 focuses on granting parole eligibility to inmates sentenced to life imprisonment for offenses committed when they were between the ages of eighteen and twenty-one. This legislation arises from the acknowledgment that young adults may possess less maturity and judgment, leading to a reconsideration of their sentences. Under HB1182, inmates sentenced for crimes that are not classified as Class A felonies become eligible for parole after serving a minimum of 25 years, provided the Board of Pardons and Paroles assesses various factors related to their age, behavior, and circumstances surrounding their offense.

Contention

However, the introduction of HB1182 has stirred debate within legislative circles. Proponents argue that it addresses the issues of youth immaturity and the justice system's tendency to impose harsh sentences without accounting for developmental factors. Opponents may voice concerns about public safety and the severity of crimes committed by offenders who should remain incarcerated. Additionally, the criteria laid out for parole consideration, such as mental health assessments and compliance with institutional rules, may prompt discussions about the practical application of the bill and the resources needed for thorough evaluations.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

SD SB172

Revise provisions regarding eligibility for parole for certain persons sentenced to life imprisonment.

SD HB1554

Parole eligibility; authorize for certain youth who committed offense while under age 18 and received life or life without parole sentence.

SD SB43

Prohibiting Life Without Parole For A Child

SD A3322

Requires administrative review for purposes of parole discharge of certain parolees sentenced to life imprisonment.

SD HB638

Allowing an older prisoner serving a sentence of life without parole to be eligible for parole upon meeting certain criteria.

SD A4358

Requires administrative review for purposes of parole discharge of certain parolees sentenced to life imprisonment.

SD HB705

Violent offenders, certain; may be paroled by Parole Board if sentencing judge authorizes parole consideration.

SD HB952

Violent offenders, certain; may be paroled by Parole Board if sentencing judge authorizes parole consideration.

SD S0021

Juvenile Life Without Parole

SD HB5567

Relating to allowing medical or geriatric parole for certain inmates

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.