Utah 2024 Regular Session

Utah House Bill HB0464

Introduced
2/5/24  
Refer
2/9/24  
Report Pass
2/15/24  
Engrossed
2/23/24  
Refer
2/23/24  
Report Pass
2/26/24  
Enrolled
3/11/24  

Caption

Social Media Amendments

Impact

The bill introduces significant changes to existing legislation regarding electronic communication harassment and the rights of minors. It creates a civil cause of action for minors or their parents against social media companies if a minor experiences negative mental health outcomes due to excessive use of these platforms. The legislation also allows a rebuttable presumption in favor of the minor if mental health issues arise from their social media use, which companies can contest by demonstrating compliance with the outlined mitigation strategies.

Summary

House Bill 0464, also known as the Social Media Amendments, primarily addresses the potential harms associated with social media use by minors. It establishes a legal framework aimed at protecting minors from adverse mental health outcomes linked to excessive social media usage. By defining terms related to social media services and their impact on minors, the bill underscores the risks associated with algorithmically curated content and engagement-driven design elements that are known to increase user engagement, particularly affecting young users.

Sentiment

Overall, the sentiment surrounding HB0464 is mixed. Proponents argue that it is a necessary response to the escalating mental health crisis among minors fueled by social media, emphasizing the state's obligation to protect its young residents. Conversely, critics raise concerns regarding the feasibility of the requirements imposed on social media companies and fear it may stifle innovation or lead to unintended consequences, such as overregulation of online platforms. The law could provoke contentious debates regarding parental rights and the role of guardians in overseeing children's online activities.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the appropriateness of defining thresholds for excessive social media use and specifying the extent of liability for social media companies. The provisions requiring parental consent and restricting usage during specific hours highlight the ongoing tension between parental oversight and the independence of minors in navigating social environments. Additionally, the bill's approach to penalizing social media platforms for algorithms that purportedly contribute to mental health issues raises questions about the balance between user safety and the operational flexibility of these platforms.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

UT HB0311

Social Media Usage Amendments

UT SB0152

Social Media Regulation Amendments

UT SB0016

Transgender Medical Treatments and Procedures Amendments

UT HB0324

Workplace Violence Protective Orders Amendments

UT HB0040

Native American Child and Family Amendments

UT SB0129

Judiciary Amendments

UT HB0122

Sex Offender Registry Amendments

UT SB0137

Medical Cannabis Amendments

UT HB0524

Social Media Usage Modifications

UT HB0281

Social Credit Score Amendments

Similar Bills

MS HB1267

Political communication; require to contain disclaimer if generated by artificial intelligence algorithms.

HI SB59

Relating To Algorithmic Discrimination.

HI HB1607

Relating To Algorithmic Discrimination.

HI SB2524

Relating To Algorithmic Discrimination.

VA HB2047

Virginia Residential Landlord and Tenant Act; algorithmic pricing devices, report.

MA H1136

Improving the health insurance prior authorization process

MA S1403

Relative to reducing administrative burden

NC H644

Social Media Algorithmic Control in IT Act