Rhode Island 2023 Regular Session

Rhode Island Senate Bill S0915

Introduced
3/30/23  

Caption

Bail And Recognizance

Impact

The bill significantly alters the existing framework for pretrial release and bail setting. With the elimination of a fixed bail schedule, it empowers courts to tailor conditions based on the specifics of each case. This legislative change is projected to enhance the efficiency of the justice response, ensuring timely attendance at trials while safeguarding public safety. By moving away from standardized financial bail, the bill seeks to address concerns regarding inequities in the justice system that have disproportionately affected lower-income defendants.

Summary

Bill S0915 introduces changes to the state's bail and recognizance laws by allowing individuals charged with misdemeanors to be released without financial bail requirements. This amendment shifts the focus from financial capability to personal assurances, as judges will be tasked with evaluating each case individually to determine the necessity and nature of release conditions. The aim is to facilitate fairer treatment within the bail process, particularly for those who may be financially disadvantaged and unable to post bail, which has often led to pretrial detention simply due to lack of funds.

Conclusion

As S0915 moves through the legislative process, its implications for both defendants and the broader community will likely remain a topic of debate, reflecting the ongoing challenge of reforming bail practices to enhance fairness and integrity within the system. The expected enactment of this bill demonstrates a legislative commitment to evolving1towards a more just and equitable pretrial release system.

Contention

Notably, the bill has sparked discussions regarding the balance between individual rights and community safety. Advocates for the bill argue that it promotes justice by reducing the risk of wrongful detention due to economic circumstances, while critics worry that fewer monetary requirements may lead to higher risks concerning flight or re-offending. The effectiveness of non-monetary conditions imposed by judges could also be scrutinized under the pressures of ensuring compliance from released individuals.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

RI S2365

Bail And Recognizance

RI H7691

Bail And Recognizance

RI S0375

Bail And Recognizance

RI S2399

Bail And Recognizance

RI S2779

Bail And Recognizance

RI H7353

Bail And Recognizance

RI H5563

Bail And Recognizance

RI S2796

Bail And Recognizance

RI S0128

Preliminary Proceedings In District Courts

RI SB63

Bonds and Recognizances; setting of bonds and schedules of bails; provide

Similar Bills

HI SB1278

Relating To Forfeiture Pursuant To Section 804-51, Hawaii Revised Statutes.

HI SB1278

Relating To Forfeiture Pursuant To Section 804-51, Hawaii Revised Statutes.

HI HB980

Relating To Forfeiture Pursuant To Section 804-51, Hawaii Revised Statutes.

CA AB2391

Bail: pretrial release.

LA HB297

Limits the release of defendants on their own recognizance in certain circumstances

MN HF1848

Bail posting data held by law enforcement agencies defined as public, and notices required.

MN SF322

Data held by law enforcement agencies regarding the person or entity that posted bail is public authorization; notice to the agency custody of the arrested or detained person when bail or a bond is posted requirement

MN SF1556

Data held by law enforcement agencies regarding the person or entity that posted bail public status establishment; notice to the agency having custody or the arrested or detained person when bail or a bond is posted requirement