Minnesota 2023-2024 Regular Session

Minnesota House Bill HF3757

Introduced
2/13/24  
Refer
2/13/24  
Report Pass
4/8/24  
Refer
4/8/24  
Report Pass
4/11/24  

Caption

Felony offense established for reporting a fictitious emergency and directing the emergency response to the home of other individuals, and conforming change made.

Impact

The implementation of HF3757, effective from August 1, 2024, would expand the legal framework under which emergency responses are handled in Minnesota. By introducing penalties for false reporting, the bill aims to deter individuals from fabricating emergencies that distract emergency services from genuine calls for help. This legislative move is expected to enhance the overall efficiency of emergency response systems, ensuring that resources remain available for authentic emergencies, thereby preserving public safety and trust.

Summary

House File 3757 introduces significant amendments to Minnesota Statutes regarding public safety, specifically addressing the issue of reporting fictitious emergencies. The bill establishes a felony offense for individuals who intentionally place emergency calls with the intent of prompting a response to the home of specific officials, including elected officials, judges, and peace officers. This legislation marks a proactive approach to discourage and penalize the misuse of emergency resources, which can lead to serious consequences not only for the individuals targeted but also for the public at large.

Contention

While this bill largely enjoys bipartisan support, discussions may arise about its implications for freedom of expression and the potential for overreach. Critics may argue that labeling certain actions as felonies could discourage individuals from reporting emergencies out of fear of legal repercussions. Proponents assert that the bill is crucial for maintaining the integrity of emergency services and protecting officials who could be targeted through frivolous or malicious calls. The challenge remains to strike a balance between maintaining public safety and ensuring individuals can communicate genuine concerns without fear of penalty.

Companion Bills

MN SF3815

Similar To Felony offense establishment for reporting a fictitious emergency and directing the emergency response to the home of certain individuals

Previously Filed As

MN SF3815

Felony offense establishment for reporting a fictitious emergency and directing the emergency response to the home of certain individuals

MN HF247

Criminal penalty established for substantial bodily harm caused by response for fictitious emergency, and restitution provided for public agencies and victims affected by reporting of fictitious emergency.

MN SF682

Criminal penalty provision for substantial bodily harm caused by response for fictitious emergency

MN SF3515

Restitution provision for public agencies and victims affected by the reporting of a fictitious emergency

MN HF478

Crime of carjacking established, and conforming changes made.

MN HF3621

Restitution provided for public agencies and victims affected by the reporting of a fictitious emergency.

MN HF559

Restitution for public agencies and victims affected by the reporting of fictitious emergency provided.

MN HF3950

City attorneys authorized to take actions including filing delinquency petitions for offenses committed by a juvenile, prosecuting felony offenses and gross misdemeanor offenses, and issuing administrative subpoenas in certain cases; and conforming changes made.

MN HF4738

Office of Emergency Medical Services established to replace Emergency Medical Services Regulatory Board, duties specified and transferred, advisory council established, alternative EMS response model pilot program established, conforming changes made, provisions modified relating to ambulance service personnel and emergency medical responders, emergency ambulance service aid provided, report required, and money appropriated.

MN SF3236

Establishing the crime of carjacking and making confirming changes

Similar Bills

CA AB516

Sex offenses: disabled victims.

CA AB2123

District-based elections.

CA AB453

District-based elections.

MI HB4122

Health occupations: health professionals; permanent revocation of license or registration if convicted of sexual conduct under pretext of medical treatment; provide for. Amends sec. 16226 of 1978 PA 368 (MCL 333.16226). TIE BAR WITH: HB 4121'23

CA AB3171

Controlled substances: fentanyl.

CA AB892

Sex offenders: registration: solicitation of a minor.

MN SF1826

Payment rates establishment for certain substance use disorder treatment services

MN HF1994

Payment rates established for certain substance use disorder treatment services, and vendor eligibility recodified for payments from the behavioral health fund.