This bill requires federal agencies to submit zero-based budgets to the Office of Management and Budget and the congressional budget committees. Under the bill, a zero-based budget is a systematic budget analysis in which managers (1) examine current objectives, operations, and costs; (2) consider alternative ways of carrying out programs or activities; and (3) rank different programs or activities by order of importance.The bill also requires federal agencies to submit recommendations to reduce spending by at least 2% from the previous year's levels. The Department of Defense and the National Nuclear Security Administration are exempt from this requirement.
Impact
The implementation of SB181 could potentially transform how federal budgeting operates, moving from traditional incremental budgeting methods to a more rigorous evaluation of each program every sixth year. By mandating that agencies identify unnecessary expenditures and provide recommendations for budget cuts equating to at least 2% of discretionary spending, the bill aims to streamline government operations and eliminate wasteful spending. Effective compliance with this requirement may lead agencies to prioritize programs that create actual impact over those that merely receive continued funding without justification.
Summary
Senate Bill 181 seeks to require federal agencies to submit zero-based budgets every six years. A zero-based budget involves a systematic analysis whereby managers evaluate current objectives, operations, and costs, considering alternative methods for program execution and ranking them by importance. This approach is posited to foster fiscal responsibility within government agencies and ensure that budgetary allocations are justifiable and aligned with the actual needs of programs and activities.
Contention
One notable point of contention surrounding this bill is the exclusion of the Department of Defense and the National Nuclear Security Administration from the zero-based budgeting requirement. Critics argue that this exemption undermines the bill's goals of comprehensive fiscal accountability and could allow for inefficiencies and unexamined spending within the defense sector. Supporters counter that national security priorities necessitate a different approach to budgeting, emphasizing the potential risk of jeopardizing defense preparedness if subjected to stringent budgetary constraints. This tension highlights an ongoing debate about fiscal discipline and the unique financial necessities of defense-related programs.
Budgetary Accuracy in Scoring Interest Costs Act of 2023 or the BASIC Act This bill requires cost estimates prepared by the Congressional Budget Office or the Joint Committee on Taxation to include the costs of servicing the public debt.
Budget Process Enhancement Act This bill modifies the federal budget process to withhold the salaries of Members of Congress and cancel the salaries of certain employees of the Office of Management and Budget when certain budget process requirements are not met. The bill also changes the assumptions that the Congressional Budget Office uses to calculate its baseline for discretionary spending to eliminate certain adjustments for inflation and other factors. (A baseline is a projection of federal spending and receipts during a fiscal year under current law.)
Article I Regulatory Budget Act This bill requires the establishment of a federal regulatory budget to limit the costs of federal regulations. It also establishes requirements for disclosing the projected costs of federal regulations and procedures for enforcing the regulatory budget.
Cost Estimates Improvement Act This bill requires cost estimates prepared by the Congressional Budget Office or the Joint Committee on Taxation to include (1) the cost of servicing the public debt; and (2) a list of any federal agencies, programs, and initiatives with fragmented, overlapping, or duplicative goals or activities covered by the legislation.
A bill to amend the Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974 to require any cost estimate for a bill or joint resolution prepared by the Congressional Budget Office to include the cost to each United States citizen for carrying out such measure, and for other purposes.
To amend the Congressional Budget and Impoundment Control Act of 1974 to require any cost estimate for a bill or joint resolution prepared by the Congressional Budget Office to include the cost to each United States citizen for carrying out such measure, and for other purposes.
A bill to require Federal agencies to impose in-person work requirements for employees of those agencies and to occupy a certain portion of the office space of those agencies, and for other purposes.