Texas House Bill HB2657

Texas 2009 - 81st Regular

• Out of House Committee: 4/21/09

Caption

Relating to disciplinary action taken against certain public school students on the basis of serious and persistent misbehavior.

Impact

If enacted, HB 2657 could significantly alter the landscape of school discipline in Texas. The bill outlines specific behaviors identified as 'serious and persistent misbehavior,' including aggressive actions, extortion, and other serious offenses. This stipulation aims to standardize how school districts handle cases of misconduct, thereby potentially reducing ambiguity in the application of disciplinary measures across various districts. The expectation is that this will result in a more consistent approach to school discipline while protecting the welfare of students and school staff.

Summary

House Bill 2657 addresses disciplinary actions taken against public school students for serious and persistent misbehavior. The bill proposes amendments to the Education Code, notably enhancing the authority of school districts to define and manage conduct that warrants disciplinary measures such as removal from classrooms or expulsion from school altogether. It aims to clarify the conditions under which students can face these consequences, emphasizing the importance of maintaining a safe and conducive learning environment in schools.

Contention

There are potential points of contention surrounding HB 2657. Advocates argue that the bill is necessary to empower schools to take swift action against violence and disruption, which threatens the educational environment. However, critics may worry that stricter definitions and easier paths to expulsion could disproportionately affect vulnerable student populations, particularly those with disabilities or those who have previously faced disciplinary challenges. This concern raises questions about equity and the potential for increased dropout rates among already at-risk students, prompting a debate about the balance between school safety and fair treatment.