Massachusetts 2023-2024 Regular Session

Massachusetts House Bill H1629

Introduced
2/16/23  

Caption

Relative to sentencing guidelines

Impact

One of the key impacts of H1629 is the introduction of a sentencing guidelines grid that will classify offenses by seriousness level and integrate different levels of intermediate sanctions. This aims to create a uniform approach to sentencing that can reduce disparities and improve fairness in the judicial process. Additionally, the bill outlines specific criteria for judges to follow when deciding on sentences, which includes considerations for both aggravating and mitigating factors. This systematic approach is intended to provide clearer guidance to judges and enhance the overall effectiveness of the corrections system.

Summary

House Bill H1629, titled 'An Act relative to sentencing guidelines,' aims to introduce a structured sentencing framework for criminal offenses in Massachusetts. The bill establishes definitions and parameters for terms related to sentencing, including 'adjudication of delinquency,' 'conviction,' and 'criminal history group' among others. The framework seeks to standardize how sentences are determined based on the severity of criminal offenses and the offender's prior record. The provisions are designed to enhance the consistency and predictability of sentencing practices across the state.

Contention

However, H1629 may face contention, particularly around its provisions related to mandatory minimum sentences and the restrictions on judges' discretion. Critics are concerned that while the bill aims to standardize practices, it may inadvertently limit judicial discretion by enforcing stricter guidelines that do not account for unique circumstances of each case. Proponents argue that these guidelines are necessary for ensuring consistency and reducing recidivism, but opponents believe they could lead to overly punitive measures and fail to address the rehabilitative needs of offenders.

Companion Bills

MA H4517

Replaced by Study Order

Similar Bills

KS HB2583

Increasing the criminal penalties for harming or killing certain dogs and horses and requiring restitution for such offense to include certain expenses.

MN HF4277

Mandatory minimum sentences for offenses involving possession or use of firearm or other dangerous weapon eliminated, victim crime reporting requirements modified, Task Force on Mandatory Minimum Sentences created, grants related to alleviating gun violence established, and money appropriated.

MN SF4324

Public safety provisions modification, grants authorization for emergency needs of gun victims, focused deterrence models to reduce group-related homicide and gun violence grant authorization, Violent Crime Coordinating Council additional position added and appropriations

KS SB414

Requiring certain persons on a third or subsequent conviction of driving under the influence to participate in a multidisciplinary model of services for substance use disorders, removing the requirement that municipal courts collect fingerprints from persons convicted of violating certain municipal ordinance provisions, amending the crime of aggravated endangering a child to increase the criminal penalties when bodily harm to the child results and when a child is in certain environments associated with fentanyl-related controlled substances, increasing the criminal penalties for unlawful distribution of fentanyl-related controlled substances, eliminating the element of concealment from the crime of breach of privacy related to installing or using a device to photograph or record another identifiable person under or through the clothing being worn by that other person or another identifiable person who is nude or in a state of undress, excluding certain types of incarceration time from being included in the allowance for time spent incarcerated when calculating a criminal defendant's sentence and updating the general terms of supervision for offenders on probation and postrelease supervision.

OR HB3497

Relating to sentencing; providing for criminal sentence reduction that requires approval by a two-thirds majority.

OR SB1070

Relating to domestic abuse survivor defendants; prescribing an effective date; providing for criminal sentence reduction that requires approval by a two-thirds majority.

VA SB424

Probation violation guidelines; use of sentencing revocation report and discretionary sentencing.

VA HB1318

Probation violation guidelines; use of sentencing revocation report and discretionary sentencing.