Massachusetts 2023-2024 Regular Session

Massachusetts House Bill H1677 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.

Old	New	Differences
1	1	1 of 1
2	2	HOUSE DOCKET, NO. 1581 FILED ON: 1/18/2023
3	3	HOUSE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . No. 1677
4	4	The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
5	5	_________________
6	6	PRESENTED BY:
7	7	Joan Meschino
8	8	_________________
9	9	To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts in General
10	10	Court assembled:
11	11	The undersigned legislators and/or citizens respectfully petition for the adoption of the accompanying bill:
12	12	An Act to create access to justice.
13	13	_______________
14	14	PETITION OF:
15	15	NAME:DISTRICT/ADDRESS :DATE ADDED:Joan Meschino3rd Plymouth1/9/2023Lindsay N. Sabadosa1st Hampshire1/27/2023David Henry Argosky LeBoeuf17th Worcester1/27/2023Sal N. DiDomenicoMiddlesex and Suffolk1/27/2023David M. Rogers24th Middlesex2/3/2023Jack Patrick Lewis7th Middlesex2/6/2023Michelle M. DuBois10th Plymouth2/7/2023Vanna Howard17th Middlesex2/9/2023James B. EldridgeMiddlesex and Worcester2/10/2023Samantha Montaño15th Suffolk2/13/2023Adrian C. Madaro1st Suffolk2/13/2023Erika Uyterhoeven27th Middlesex2/22/2023Natalie M. Higgins4th Worcester2/23/2023Margaret R. Scarsdale1st Middlesex2/27/2023Patrick Joseph Kearney4th Plymouth3/13/2023 1 of 6
16	16	HOUSE DOCKET, NO. 1581 FILED ON: 1/18/2023
17	17	HOUSE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . No. 1677
18	18	By Representative Meschino of Hull, a petition (accompanied by bill, House, No. 1677) of Joan
19	19	Meschino and others relative to access to justice for persons aggrieved by actions of intentional
20	20	discrimination. The Judiciary.
21	21	The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
22	22	_______________
23	23	In the One Hundred and Ninety-Third General Court
24	24	(2023-2024)
25	25	_______________
26	26	An Act to create access to justice.
27	27	Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court assembled, and by the authority
28	28	of the same, as follows:
29	29	1 SECTION 1. Chapter 12 of the General Laws, as appearing in the 2020 Official Edition,
30	30	2is hereby amended by inserting after section 11N the following section:-
31	31	3 Section 11O.
32	32	4 (a) Definitions. For the purposes of this Section the following terms shall have the
33	33	5following meanings:
34	34	6 “Age” means forty years of age or older unless a different meaning clearly appears from
35	35	7the context.
36	36	8 “Disability” means (a) a physical or mental impairment, including, but not limited to an
37	37	9intellectual, developmental, psychiatric, sensory or learning impairment, which substantially
38	38	10limits one or more major life activities of a person; (b) a record of having such impairment; or (c) 2 of 6
39	39	11being regarded as having such impairment, but such term shall not include current, illegal use of
40	40	12a controlled substance as defined in section one of chapter ninety-four C.
41	41	13 “Major life activities” means functions, including, but not limited to, caring for one’s
42	42	14self, performing manual tasks, walking, seeing, hearing, speaking, breathing, learning, and
43	43	15working.
44	44	16 “Familial status” means one or more individuals (a) being or seeking to become pregnant;
45	45	17(b) being in the process of securing legal custody of a person who has not attained the age of 18
46	46	18years; (c) being the parent or another person with legal custody of an individual who has not
47	47	19attained the age of 18 years and is domiciled with said parent or legal custodian; or (d) being a
48	48	20person with whom an individual who has not attained the age of 18 is domiciled with the written
49	49	21permission of such parent or legal custodian.
50	50	22 “Discriminatory effect” means the following: a program, policy or practice has a
51	51	23discriminatory effect if it is reasonably foreseeable that it will have the effect of excluding or
52	52	24partially excluding from participation, disadvantaging, harming, denying one or more benefits to,
53	53	25causing a disparate impact upon, or otherwise discriminating against a person based on or
54	54	26because of one or more of the person’s protected characteristics, even if not motivated by a
55	55	27discriminatory intent. A disparate impact occurs when a program, policy or practice
56	56	28disproportionately disadvantages persons based on or because of protected characteristics or
57	57	29perpetuates or will tend to perpetuate segregation, even if not motivated by discriminatory intent.
58	58	30A person claiming to be aggrieved by a Unit of Government’s program, policy or practice that
59	59	31has a discriminatory effect may pursue a claim pursuant to subsection (c) of this Section if that
60	60	32person has or predictably will be injured by the program, policy or practice. 3 of 6
61	61	33 “Legally sufficient justification” means the program, policy or practice:
62	62	34 (1) is necessary to achieve one or more identified compelling interests of the Unit of
63	63	35Government and effectively carries out the identified interests;
64	64	36 (2) is narrowly tailored to serve the identified interests;
65	65	37 (3) the identified interests could not be served by a less discriminatory alternative; and,
66	66	38 (4) the justification is supported by evidence that is not hypothetical or speculative.
67	67	39 Demonstrating that the program, policy or practice is supported by a legally sufficient
68	68	40justification as defined in this Section is not a defense to a claim of intentional discrimination.
69	69	41 “Person” means one or more individuals, unincorporated or incorporated organizations,
70	70	42partnerships, associations, legal representatives, trustees, tribal governments, or receivers,
71	71	43including individuals or organizations engaged in civil rights testing.
72	72	44 “Prevailing party” means a party who obtains some requested relief through a judicial
73	73	45judgment or court-approved settlement agreement in that party’s favor, or whose pursuit of a
74	74	46claim was a catalyst for a unilateral change in position by the Unit of Government relative to the
75	75	47relief sought.
76	76	48 “Program, policy or practice” means, without limitation, one or more actions, operations,
77	77	49policies, practices, programs, criteria and methods of administration of a Unit of Government.
78	78	50 “Protected characteristic” means race, color, religion, national origin, ethnicity, ancestry,
79	79	51citizenship or immigration status, limited English proficiency, genetic information, sex, gender
80	80	52identity or gender expression, sexual orientation, age, disability, medical condition, familial 4 of 6
81	81	53status, pregnancy, status as a veteran or member of the armed forces, or recipient of public
82	82	54assistance, rental assistance or housing subsidy, or any characteristic protected by the
83	83	55Commonwealth.
84	84	56 “Unit of Government” means any executive office, department, agency or subdivision of
85	85	57the Commonwealth including, without limitation, counties, cities, towns, offices, boards,
86	86	58commissions, and authorities; any persons employed by or contracting with a unit of
87	87	59government, and any programs or activities conducted, operated or administered by, or funded
88	88	60directly or otherwise receiving financial or in-kind assistance from, a unit of government.
89	89	61 (b) No Unit of Government shall directly or indirectly:
90	90	62 (1) exclude or partially exclude from participation, disadvantage, harm, deny one or more
91	91	63benefits to, or otherwise subject a person to discrimination based on or because of one or more of
92	92	64the person’s protected characteristics; or
93	93	65 (2) adopt, implement or without limitation otherwise approve or utilize any program,
94	94	66policy or practice that has a discriminatory effect.
95	95	67 (c) Any person or class of persons claiming to be aggrieved by a violation of subsection
96	96	68(b) may institute and prosecute a civil action in the District, Superior, Housing, Juvenile, Family
97	97	69and Probate, Boston Municipal, or Land Court Department for injunctive and other appropriate
98	98	70equitable relief including an award of actual damages, and for violations of intentional
99	99	71discrimination, an award of punitive damages. This civil action must be filed not later than three
100	100	72years after a violation of subsection (b). Any aggrieved person who prevails in an action
101	101	73authorized by this Section shall be entitled to an award of the costs of the litigation including
102	102	74expert witness fees, reasonable attorneys' fees in an amount to be fixed by the court, and 5 of 6
103	103	75prejudgment and post-judgment interest. The attorney general may, in like manner, also
104	104	76commence a civil action to seek relief for a violation of subsection (b).
105	105	77 (d) Burdens of proof in actions for discriminatory effect brought pursuant to this Section.
106	106	78 (1) The plaintiff has the burden of proving that a challenged program, policy or practice
107	107	79caused or is reasonably likely to cause a discriminatory effect without having to prove intent to
108	108	80discriminate.
109	109	81 (2) Once the plaintiff satisfies the burden of proof set forth in subsection (d)(1) of this
110	110	82Section, the defendant has the burden of proving that the challenged program, policy or practice
111	111	83meets all of the elements of a legally sufficient justification as defined in subsection (a) of this
112	112	84Section.
113	113	85 (3) If the defendant satisfies the burden of proof set forth in subsection (d)(2), the
114	114	86defendant must also prove that there is no other program, policy or practice that has a less
115	115	87discriminatory effect which could serve the identified compelling interest or interests.
116	116	88 (e) A challenged program, policy or practice must be a contributing cause of the
117	117	89discriminatory effect complained of but not necessarily the direct or proximate cause.
118	118	90 (f) Except for claims that are subject to administrative exhaustion within the
119	119	91Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination as set forth in Chapter 151B of the General
120	120	92Laws and other statutes conferring jurisdiction on the Massachusetts Commission Against
121	121	93Discrimination, nothing in this Section is intended to require a person seeking to enforce the
122	122	94protections afforded herein to exhaust any administrative remedies applicable to discrimination
123	123	95claims under this Section or other laws, or to prevent or limit a person from filing a complaint at 6 of 6
124	124	96the Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination under the procedures set out in Chapter
125	125	97151B of the General Laws or any other anti-discrimination law of the Commonwealth and
126	126	98implementing regulations.
127	127	99 (g) This Act is intended to be liberally construed to effectuate the broad, remedial goal of
128	128	100eradicating discrimination by Units of Government, whether intentionally or through an
129	129	101unjustified discriminatory effect, and securing access to the judicial process for aggrieved parties
130	130	102to enforce their rights for all matters that are not actionable under Chapter 151B or other laws
131	131	103within the jurisdiction of the Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination. Any state or
132	132	104federal statute or regulation, which is inconsistent with this goal or any provision of this Section,
133	133	105or which imposes additional obstacles or restrictions on aggrieved parties, shall not apply.