Massachusetts 2023-2024 Regular Session

Massachusetts House Bill H4993 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.

Old	New	Differences
1	1	1 of 2
2	2	HOUSE DOCKET, NO. 5307 FILED ON: 8/8/2024
3	3	HOUSE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . No. 4993
4	4	OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR
5	5	COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS
6	6	STATE HOUSE · BOSTON, MA 02133
7	7	(617) 725-4000
8	8	MAURA T. HEALEY
9	9	GOVERNOR
10	10	KIMBERLEY DRISCOLL
11	11	LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR
12	12	August 8, 2024
13	13	To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives,
14	14	Pursuant to Article LVI, as amended by Section 3 of Article XC, of the Amendments to
15	15	the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, I am returning to you for amendment
16	16	House Bill No. H.2049, “An Act relative to the Auburn Water District.”
17	17	H.2049 would authorize the Auburn Water District to transfer, sell, convey, or otherwise
18	18	dispose of 59 acres of land in the Town of Auburn determined by the District to be no longer
19	19	needed for water supply purposes. The Bill authorizes the District to transfer the land subject to
20	20	G. L. c. 30B, § 16. I agree with the determination made by the Clerks of the House and Senate
21	21	that this Bill is subject to Article 97 of the Massachusetts Constitution. It appears that much of
22	22	the 59 acres of land at issue may be protected under Article 97.
23	23	The Bill does not ensure mitigation or compensation for removing land from the
24	24	protections of Article 97 and therefore is inconsistent with the provisions of G. L. c. 3, § 5A and
25	25	the “No Net Loss” Policy established by the Executive Office of Energy and Environmental
26	26	Affairs, both of which protect against the loss of public lands due to conversion to other
27	27	purposes. The law and policy ordinarily require that any transfer of public lands subject to
28	28	Article 97 be mitigated by dedicating or acquiring replacement land for Article 97 purposes. As
29	29	the Bill does not identify or require Auburn Water District to dedicate replacement land, or
30	30	require any other specific mitigation, it does not comply with this law or policy and would result
31	31	in a net decrease of protected land in the Commonwealth.
32	32	The Bill also does not ensure compliance with the Department of Environmental
33	33	Protection’s (MassDEP) procedures for reviewing proposed dispositions of watershed land.
34	34	Under G. L. c. 40, § 41 and 310 CMR 22.24, water districts seeking to dispose of land used for 2 of 2
35	35	water supply purposes but no longer necessary for public water supply must seek approval from
36	36	MassDEP, which may be granted following public notification and hearing. Through this
37	37	important approval process, MassDEP protects public health and welfare by ensuring that the
38	38	disposition of watershed land will meet minimum drinking water standards and will not
39	39	adversely impact the quantity or quality of the water supply.
40	40	For the reasons stated above, I recommend that H.2049 be struck in its entirety and
41	41	replaced with the following:-
42	42	SECTION 1. Notwithstanding chapter 585 of the acts of 1947, as amended by chapter
43	43	150 of the acts of 1981, or section 5A of chapter 3 of the General Laws, but subject to section 16
44	44	of chapter 30B of the General Laws, the Auburn water district may transfer, sell, convey or
45	45	otherwise dispose of all or portions of the property located adjacent to 295 Leicester street in the
46	46	town of Auburn, which was acquired by the district by deed recorded at the Worcester district
47	47	registry of deeds in book 25575, page 87, said portion consisting of approximately 59 acres of
48	48	land located off of the southeastern sideline of Leicester street in the town of Auburn and
49	49	determined by the district to be not needed for water supply purposes; provided, however, that
50	50	this section shall not apply to any land or interest in land subject to Article 97 of the amendments
51	51	to the constitution of the commonwealth and unless all required approvals of the department of
52	52	environmental protection are obtained pursuant to section 41 of chapter 40 of the general laws
53	53	and any other applicable law or regulation.
54	54	SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon its passage.
55	55	Respectfully submitted,
56	56	Maura T. Healey,
57	57	Governor