Massachusetts 2025-2026 Regular Session

Massachusetts House Bill H2411 Compare Versions

Only one version of the bill is available at this time.
OldNewDifferences
11 1 of 1
22 HOUSE DOCKET, NO. 3035 FILED ON: 1/16/2025
33 HOUSE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . No. 2411
44 The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
55 _________________
66 PRESENTED BY:
77 Patricia A. Duffy, (BY REQUEST)
88 _________________
99 To the Honorable Senate and House of Representatives of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts in General
1010 Court assembled:
1111 The undersigned legislators and/or citizens respectfully petition for the adoption of the accompanying bill:
1212 An Act reducing non-ionizing radiation in early to higher education.
1313 _______________
1414 PETITION OF:
1515 NAME:DISTRICT/ADDRESS :DATE ADDED:Kirstin Beatty149 Central Park Drive, Holyoke, MA
1616 01040
1717 1/16/2025 1 of 12
1818 HOUSE DOCKET, NO. 3035 FILED ON: 1/16/2025
1919 HOUSE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . No. 2411
2020 By Representative Duffy of Holyoke (by request), a petition (accompanied by bill, House, No.
2121 2411) of Kirstin Beatty relative to reducing non-thermal non-ionizing radiation exposures from
2222 technology and electricity. Public Health.
2323 The Commonwealth of Massachusetts
2424 _______________
2525 In the One Hundred and Ninety-Fourth General Court
2626 (2025-2026)
2727 _______________
2828 An Act reducing non-ionizing radiation in early to higher education.
2929 Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Court assembled, and by the authority
3030 of the same, as follows:
3131 1 SECTION 1. The legislature finds and confirms all of the following:-
3232 2 Whereas, several countries prohibit wireless in public schools; California and several
3333 3countries limit strong fields from electricity in public schools - yet Massachusetts has done
3434 4nothing.
3535 5 Whereas, fields and poor power quality from electricity can be limited through shielding,
3636 6filters, and other design, but wireless is essentially unshielded and unregulated.
3737 7 Whereas, only 50 studies led the U.S. Surgeon General to warn the public of tobacco's
3838 8cancer risks, but hundreds and perhaps thousands of studies show harm caused by non-thermal
3939 9non-ionizing radiation, which includes both electricity and wireless.
4040 10 Whereas, FCC wireless guidelines fail to acknowledge wireless harm, despite numerous
4141 11studies showing concrete harm such as based on examination of blood, cells, human 2 of 12
4242 12epidemiology, animal autopsy, and extended animal exposure studies, the latter including from
4343 13research by the U.S. National Toxicological Program and the Italian Ramazzini Institutes
4444 14indicating heart damage, DNA damage, and tumors including deadly glioblastomas.
4545 15 Whereas, strong fields and poor power quality from electricity can harm health, with
4646 16numerous statistical findings of increased cancer as well as other diseases -- in 2002 the
4747 17International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classed these frequencies as possibly
4848 18carcinogenic based on increased leukemia risks in epidemiological studies but epidemiological
4949 19studies also show increased neurological diseases such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)
5050 20and Alzheimer's.
5151 21 Whereas, approximately a thousand studies show non-ionizing radiation that is a million
5252 22times below legal limits set by the FCC still disrupts calcium function, and because calcium is
5353 23essential to cell signaling this effect disrupts many biological processes.
5454 24 Whereas, the federal government fosters wireless schools by subsidizing only wireless
5555 25connectivity through its federal E-rate program, despite studies showing that youth are more
5656 26susceptible to harm than adults and despite evidence of increased mental health disturbance and
5757 27learning disabilities from exposures.
5858 28 Whereas, the mission of the department and board of elementary and secondary
5959 29education fails to acknowledge any role in fostering environmental health, and thus the drive to
6060 30use technology is unchecked by physical and mental health considerations.
6161 31 Resolved, that the policy goals of this act shall be to actively reduce non-thermal non-
6262 32ionizing radiation exposures from technology and electricity by establishing a process for public 3 of 12
6363 33schools and higher education; providing guidance and evaluation through state boards; and
6464 34rectifying the public education mission to include attention to environmental health.
6565 35 SECTION 2. Chapter 71 of the General Laws is hereby amended by adding after section
6666 3697 the following new section:-
6767 37 Section 98. (a) Definitions. As used in this section, the following words shall have the
6868 38following meanings:
6969 39 "Collocation" means the act of siting facilities on an existing structure without the need to
7070 40construct11a new support structure and without a substantial change in the size of an existing
7171 41wireless service facility.
7272 42 "Distributed antenna system" means a network system consisting of one or more nodes
7373 43connected by a fiber system to a wireless service provider's base transceiver station or other
7474 44location.
7575 45 “Mobile service” means the same as defined in 47 USC § 153(33), as may be amended.
7676 46 “Non-ionizing radiation” means electric and magnetic fields emitted from frequencies
7777 47ranging from 0 hertz through 300 gigahertz.
7878 48 “Small cell network" means a network consisting of one or more nodes connected,
7979 49directly or indirectly, by fiber to a wireless service provider's mobile switching center or other
8080 50point of interconnection.
8181 51 “Structure” means a pole, tower, base station, or other building, whether or not it has an
8282 52existing antenna facility, that is used or to be used for the provision of personal wireless service
8383 53(whether on its own or commingled with other types of services). 4 of 12
8484 54 “Telecommunications service” means the offering of telecommunications for a fee
8585 55directly to the public, or to such classes of users as to be effectively available directly to the
8686 56public, regardless of the facilities used.
8787 57 (b) To the extent possible and within its means, every public school shall eliminate man-
8888 58made non-ionizing radiation emissions known or likely to be harmful. To the extent possible and
8989 59within its means, every public school shall establish measures and take action to reduce man-
9090 60made non-ionizing radiation emissions which are (1) potentially harmful; (2) unintentional; or
9191 61(3) of unknown effect.
9292 62 (c) Initial measures. Every public or independent school shall insure, as long as any
9393 63wireless antennas exist on school property and transmit, that such antennas are set to emit the
9494 64minimum of power density possible for the minimum time necessary with the minimum of
9595 65pulsing and data.
9696 66 Every public school shall prioritize prompt replacement of wireless broadband and
9797 67telecommunications connectivity in favor of hard-wired access, and shall educate its students and
9898 68staff on reducing non-ionizing radiation exposures at school and at home for better health.
9999 69 Upon resetting any existing wireless antennas to end or minimize transmissions, every
100100 70public school shall establish routine monitoring systems to insure wireless transmissions do not
101101 71restart.
102102 72 (d) Continuing measures. Every public school shall set objectives to methodically reduce
103103 73all non-ionizing radiation exposures, reasonable deadlines to meet these objectives, and shall
104104 74keep public records of progress towards each objective as well as a public record of why any
105105 75objectives have not been obtained. 5 of 12
106106 76 (e) Wireless Infrastructure. All public public schools and associated school districts shall
107107 77prohibit use of school property for construction of facilities to provide telecommunications
108108 78service and other mobile services including, but not limited to, (1) site distributed antenna
109109 79systems and small cell networks; (2) any structure; and (3) collocation of distributed antenna
110110 80systems and small cell networks on existing wireless communications infrastructure. Where such
111111 81facilities are preexisting the public school district shall seek, to the extent within its means and
112112 82with the support of the Commonwealth, removal of such facilities.
113113 83 (f) Accountability. Administration and good faith progress towards all of the objectives
114114 84of this section shall be a component of any public school or district review.
115115 85 SECTION 3. Chapter 15A of the General Laws is hereby amended by adding after
116116 86Section 15 the following section:-
117117 87 Section 15A. (a) Definitions. As used in this section, the following words shall have the
118118 88following meanings:
119119 89 "Collocation" means the act of siting facilities on an existing structure without the need to
120120 90construct a new support structure and without a substantial change in the size of an existing
121121 91wireless service facility.
122122 92 "Distributed antenna system" means a network system consisting of one or more nodes
123123 93connected by a fiber system to a wireless service provider's base transceiver station or other
124124 94location.
125125 95 “Mobile service” means the same as defined in 47 USC § 153(33), as may be amended. 6 of 12
126126 96 “Non-ionizing radiation” means electric and magnetic fields emitted from frequencies
127127 97ranging from 0 hertz through 300 gigahertz.
128128 98 “Small cell network" means a network consisting of one or more nodes connected,
129129 99directly or indirectly, by fiber to a wireless service provider's mobile switching center or other
130130 100point of interconnection.
131131 101 “Structure” means a pole, tower, base station, or other building, whether or not it has an
132132 102existing antenna facility, that is used or to be used for the provision of personal wireless service
133133 103(whether on its own or commingled with other types of services).
134134 104 “Telecommunications service” means the offering of telecommunications for a fee
135135 105directly to the public, or to such classes of users as to be effectively available directly to the
136136 106public, regardless of the facilities used.
137137 107 (b) To the extent feasible, every public or independent institution of higher education
138138 108located in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts and authorized to grant degrees pursuant to any
139139 109general or special law shall eliminate exposures to man-made non-ionizing radiation known or
140140 110likely to be harmful. To the extent feasible, every institution shall establish measures and take
141141 111action to reduce exposures to man-made non-ionizing radiation which is (1) potentially harmful;
142142 112(2) unintentional; or (3) of unknown effect.
143143 113 (c) Initial measures. Institutions shall take the following initial steps. Every institution
144144 114shall insure, as long as any wireless antennas exist on school property and transmit, that such
145145 115antennas are set to emit the minimum of power density possible for the minimum time necessary
146146 116with the minimum of pulsing and data. 7 of 12
147147 117 Every institution shall prioritize prompt replacement of wireless broadband and
148148 118telecommunications connectivity in favor of hard-wired access, and shall educate its students and
149149 119staff on reducing non-ionizing radiation exposures at school and at home for better health.
150150 120 Upon resetting any existing wireless antennas to end or minimize transmissions, every
151151 121institution shall establish routine monitoring systems to insure wireless transmissions do not
152152 122reset.
153153 123 (d) Continuing measures. Every institution shall set objectives to methodically reduce all
154154 124non-ionizing radiation exposures, reasonable deadlines to meet these objectives, and shall keep
155155 125public records of progress towards each objective as well as a public record of why any
156156 126objectives have not been obtained.
157157 127 (e) Wireless Infrastructure. All institutions shall prohibit use of campus property for
158158 128construction of facilities to provide telecommunications service and other mobile services
159159 129including, but not limited to, (1) site distributed antenna systems and small cell networks; (2) any
160160 130structure; and (3) collocation of distributed antenna systems and small cell networks on existing
161161 131wireless communications infrastructure. Where such facilities are preexisting the institution shall
162162 132seek, to the extent within its means and with the support of the Commonwealth, removal of such
163163 133facilities.
164164 134 SECTION 4. Chapter 71 of the General Laws is hereby amended by adding after section
165165 13597 the following section:-
166166 136 Section 99. (a) The department of elementary and secondary education, working with the
167167 137board of elementary and secondary education, shall develop guidance and recommendations to 8 of 12
168168 138assist schools in reducing man-made non-ionizing radiation exposures which are (1) known or
169169 139likely to be harmful; (2) potentially harmful; (3) unintentional; or (4) of unknown effect.
170170 140 (b) Development. Guidelines shall be based on current science independent of industry
171171 141influence and shall adopt a cautionary stance. Guidelines shall provide varying approaches in
172172 142order to account for the variable financial abilities and circumstances of school districts. The
173173 143department shall consider practices that protect the health and safety of public school students
174174 144and staff, and may consult with experts provided the following conditions are met: (1) the expert
175175 145is acknowledged and named in publication of relevant findings; (2) the expert has an appropriate
176176 146professional and educational background for the expertise provided; and (3) the expert is free of
177177 147conflicts of interest and free of industry clients, the latter excepting engineers contracted with
178178 148industry only to reduce non-ionizing radiation exposures.
179179 149 The department shall annually review and update guidance affecting, but not limited to,
180180 150the purchase, installation, and use of broadband services, digital devices, electrical equipment,
181181 151lighting, and telecommunications services.
182182 152 (c) Adoption. From the recommendations, the board of elementary and secondary
183183 153education shall select those which can quickly and easily be adopted without a financial burden
184184 154and require adoption as soon as can be arranged. For the remainder, the board of elementary and
185185 155secondary education shall set reasonable deadlines for adoption, and shall prioritize measures
186186 156which dramatically reduce detrimental exposures and improve health. The board of elementary
187187 157and secondary education shall annually review and update as necessary.
188188 158 Regardless of board guidance, any school in the Commonwealth shall be allowed to set
189189 159more stringent goals to further reduce non-ionizing radiation exposures. 9 of 12
190190 160 (d) The board of elementary and secondary education shall develop a procedure to
191191 161evaluate the administration and good faith efforts of public schools to reduce non-ionizing
192192 162radiation in accordance with state and federal law. The evaluation shall be designed in a manner
193193 163which limits the digital reporting requirements and bureaucratic burden.
194194 164 (e) If financial or other obstacles block the intent of this section, the secretary of
195195 165education shall submit to the Governor and the state legislature an explanation.
196196 166 SECTION 5. Chapter 15A of the General Laws is hereby amended by adding after
197197 167section 44 the following section:-
198198 168 Section 45. (a) To assist public and independent institutions authorized to grant degrees
199199 169pursuant to any general or special law, the board of higher education shall develop guidance and
200200 170recommendations in reducing man-made non-ionizing radiation exposures which are (1) known
201201 171or likely to be harmful; (2) potentially harmful; (3) unintentional; or (4) of unknown effect.
202202 172 (b) Development. Guidelines shall be based on current science independent of industry
203203 173influence and shall adopt a cautionary stance. Guidelines shall provide varying approaches in
204204 174order to account for the variable circumstances of institutions. The board shall consider practices
205205 175that protect the health and safety of public school students and staff, and may consult with
206206 176experts provided the following conditions are met: (1) the expert is acknowledged and named in
207207 177publication of findings; (2) the expert has an appropriate professional and educational
208208 178background for the expertise provided; and (3) the expert is free of conflicts of interest and free
209209 179of industry clients, the latter excepting engineers contracted with industry only to reduce non-
210210 180ionizing radiation exposures. 10 of 12
211211 181 The board shall annually review and update guidance affecting, but not limited to, the
212212 182purchase, installation, and use of broadband services, digital devices, electrical equipment,
213213 183lighting, and telecommunications services.
214214 184 (c) Adoption. From the recommendations, the board shall select those which can quickly
215215 185and easily be adopted without a financial burden and require adoption as soon as can be
216216 186arranged. For the remainder, the board shall set reasonable deadlines for adoption, and shall
217217 187prioritize measures which dramatically reduce detrimental exposures and improve health. The
218218 188board shall annually review and update as necessary.
219219 189 Regardless of board guidance, any institution in the Commonwealth shall be allowed and
220220 190encouraged to set more stringent goals to further reduce non-ionizing radiation exposures.
221221 191 (d) Accountability. The board shall develop a procedure to evaluate the administration
222222 192and good faith efforts of every public and independent institution of higher education in the
223223 193Commonwealth to reduce non-ionizing radiation in accordance with state and federal law. The
224224 194evaluation shall be designed in a manner which limits the digital reporting and bureaucratic
225225 195burden.
226226 196 SECTION 6. Chapter 15D of the General Laws is hereby amended by adding after
227227 197section 11 the following section:-
228228 198 Section 11A. (a) The board of early education and care shall develop early education
229229 199guidance and recommendations to reduce exposures to man-made non-ionizing radiation
230230 200exposures which are (1) known or likely to be harmful; (2) potentially harmful; (3) unintentional;
231231 201or (4) of unknown effect. The board of early education and care may choose to coordinate with
232232 202the department of elementary and secondary education. 11 of 12
233233 203 (b) Development. Guidelines shall be based on current science independent of industry
234234 204influence and shall adopt a cautionary stance. Guidelines shall provide varying approaches in
235235 205order to account for the variable conditions of early education facilities. The board shall consider
236236 206practices that protect the health and safety of public school students and staff, and may consult
237237 207with experts provided the following conditions are met: (1) the expert is acknowledged and
238238 208named in publication of relevant findings; (2) the expert has an appropriate professional and
239239 209educational background for the expertise provided; and (3) the expert is free of conflicts of
240240 210interest and free of industry clients, the latter excepting engineers contracted with industry only
241241 211to reduce non-ionizing radiation exposures.
242242 212 With respect to wireless, the board of early education and care shall prioritize
243243 213establishing hard-wired over wireless connections and elimination of wireless transmitters near
244244 214or in child care areas. With respect to fields from electricity, the board shall support measures to
245245 215limit proximity to children and field strength.
246246 216 The board of early education and care shall annually review and update guidance
247247 217affecting, but not limited to, the purchase, installation, and use of broadband services, digital
248248 218devices, electrical equipment, lighting, and telecommunications services.
249249 219 (c) Adoption. From the recommendations, the board shall select those which can quickly
250250 220and easily be adopted without a financial burden and require adoption as soon as can be
251251 221arranged. For the remainder, the board shall set reasonable deadlines for adoption, and shall
252252 222prioritize measures which dramatically reduce detrimental exposures and improve health. The
253253 223board shall annually review and update as necessary. 12 of 12
254254 224 Regardless of board guidance, any early education facility in the Commonwealth shall be
255255 225allowed to set more stringent goals to further reduce non-ionizing radiation exposures.
256256 226 SECTION 7. Section 1 of chapter 69 of the General Laws is hereby amended by striking
257257 227out the last sentence and inserting in place the following sentence:-
258258 228 It is therefore the intent of this title to ensure: (1) that each public school classroom
259259 229provides the conditions for all pupils to engage fully in learning as an inherently meaningful and
260260 230enjoyable activity without threats to their sense of security or self-esteem, (2) a consistent
261261 231commitment of resources sufficient to provide a high quality public education to every child, (3)
262262 232a respectful process for attending to student academic needs and developing talents; (4) an
263263 233effective system for supporting positive school climates, teacher quality, and professionalism;
264264 234and (5) insuring the environmental health and safety of public school classrooms by supporting
265265 235and developing policies and procedures designed to improve and monitor environmental health
266266 236of public school buildings.