Maryland 2023 Regular Session

Maryland House Bill HB758 Latest Draft

Bill / Chaptered Version Filed 05/18/2023

                             	WES MOORE, Governor 	Ch. 702 
 
– 1 – 
Chapter 702 
(House Bill 758) 
 
AN ACT concerning 
 
Sexual Assault Evidence Collection Kits – Preservation and Storage 
 
FOR the purpose of altering requirements for the storage and preservation of sexual assault 
evidence collection kits; authorizing the Attorney General to direct a certain person 
to comply with provisions of this Act; authorizing the Attorney General to apply to a 
certain court for an order to show cause under certain circumstances requiring 
sexual assault evidence collection kits collected before a certain date to be retained 
and transferred in a certain manner; requiring the Maryland Sexual Assault 
Evidence Kit Policy and Funding Committee, on or before a certain date, to make a 
report on certain recommendations, in consultation with the Consumer Protection 
Division of the Office of the Attorney General; and generally relating to the 
preservation and storage of sexual assault evidence collection kits.  
 
BY repealing and reenacting, with amendments, 
 Article – Criminal Procedure 
Section 11–926 
 Annotated Code of Maryland 
 (2018 Replacement Volume and 2022 Supplement) 
 
 SECTION 1. BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF MARYLAND, 
That the Laws of Maryland read as follows: 
 
Article – Criminal Procedure 
 
11–926. 
 
 (a) (1) In this section the following words have the meanings indicated. 
 
 (2) “Child advocacy center” has the meaning stated in § 13–2201 of the 
Health – General Article. 
 
 (3) “HEALTH CARE PROVIDER ” MEANS A PERSON WHO I S LICENSED, 
CERTIFIED, OR OTHERWISE AUTHORI ZED UNDER THE HEALTH OCCUPATIONS 
ARTICLE TO PROVIDE HE ALTH CARE IN THE ORD INARY COURSE OF BUSINESS OR 
PRACTICE OF A PROFES SION OR IN AN APPROV ED EDUCATION OR TRAI NING 
PROGRAM. 
 
 (4) (3)  “Hospital” has the meaning stated in § 19–301 of the Health – 
General Article. 
  Ch. 702 	2023 LAWS OF MARYLAND  
 
– 2 – 
 (4) “QUALIFIED HEALTH CARE PROVIDER” HAS THE MEANING 
STATED IN § 11–1007 OF THIS ARTICLE.  
 
 (5) (I) “SEXUAL ASSAULT EVIDEN CE COLLECTION KIT ” MEANS 
PHYSICAL EVIDENCE CO LLECTED: 
 
 1. BY A QUALIFIED HEALTH CARE PROVIDER ; 
 
 2. FROM THE BODY OR CLO THING OF A LIVING OR 
DECEASED PERSON ; 
 
 3. IN RELATION TO FOLLOWING AN ALLEGATION OR 
SUSPICION OF SEXUAL ASSAULT; AND 
 
 4. FOR THE PURPOSE OF P RESERVING THE PHYSIC AL 
EVIDENCE FOR USE IN A CRIMINA L INVESTIGATION . 
 
 (II) “SEXUAL ASSAULT EVIDEN CE COLLECTION KIT ” DOES NOT 
INCLUDE PHYSICAL EVIDENCE CO LLECTED BEFORE JANUARY 1, 1975 A  
SELF–ADMINISTERED SEXUAL ASSAULT EVIDENCE COL LECTION KIT.  
 
 (b) A QUALIFIED health care provider that performs a sexual assault evidence 
collection kit exam on a victim of sexual assault shall provide the victim with: 
 
 (1) contact information for the investigating law enforcement agency that 
the victim may contact about the status and results of the kit analysis; and 
 
 (2) written information describing the laws and policies governing the 
testing, preservation, and disposal of a sexual assault evidence collection kit. 
 
 (c) An investigating law enforcement agency that receives a sexual assault 
evidence collection kit, within 30 days after a request by the victim from whom the evidence 
was collected, shall provide the victim with: 
 
 (1) information about the status of the kit analysis; and 
 
 (2) all available results of the kit analysis except results that would impede 
or compromise an ongoing investigation. 
 
 (d) (1) A sexual assault evidence collection kit OR A SELF–ADMINISTERED 
SEXUAL ASSAULT EVIDEN CE COLLECTION KIT shall be transferred to a law enforcement 
agency: 
 
 (i) by a hospital or a child advocacy center within 30 days after the 
exam is performed; or   	WES MOORE, Governor 	Ch. 702 
 
– 3 – 
 
 (ii) by a government agency in possession of a kit, unless the agency 
is otherwise required to retain the kit by law or court rule. 
 
 (2) Except as provided in paragraph (3) of this subsection, within [20] 75 
years after the evidence is collected, a law enforcement agency, HEALTH CARE PROVIDER , 
OR HOSPITAL may not destroy or dispose of: 
 
 (i) a sexual assault evidence collection kit; or 
 
 (ii) other crime scene evidence relating to a sexual assault that has 
been identified by the State’s Attorney as relevant to prosecution. 
 
 (3) A law enforcement agency is not required to comply with the 
requirements in paragraph (2) of this subsection if: 
 
 (i) the case for which the evidence was collected resulted in a 
conviction and the sentence has been completed; or 
 
 (ii) all suspects identified by testing a sexual assault evidence 
collection kit are deceased. 
 
 (4) On written request by the victim from whom the evidence was collected, 
a law enforcement agency, A HEALTH CARE PROVID ER, OR A HOSPITAL with custody of 
a sexual assault evidence collection kit or other crime scene evidence relating to a sexual 
assault shall: 
 
 (i) notify the victim no later than 60 days before the date of intended 
destruction or disposal of the evidence; or 
 
 (ii) retain the evidence for 12 months longer than the time period 
specified in paragraph (2) of this subsection or for a time period agreed to by the victim and 
the law enforcement agency, HEALTH CARE PROVIDER , OR HOSPITAL. 
 
 (e) (1) [A] FOR A SEXUAL ASSAULT EVIDENCE COLLECTION KIT IN THE 
CUSTODY OF A LAW ENF ORCEMENT AGENCY , THE sexual assault evidence collection kit 
shall be submitted to a forensic laboratory for analysis unless: 
 
 [(1)] (I) there is clear evidence disproving the allegation of sexual 
assault; 
 
 [(2)] (II) the facts alleged, if true, could not be interpreted to violate a 
provision of Title 3, Subtitle 2, Title 3, Subtitle 3, Title 3, Subtitle 6, or Title 11, Subtitle 3 
of the Criminal Law Article; 
  Ch. 702 	2023 LAWS OF MARYLAND  
 
– 4 – 
 [(3)] (III) the victim from whom the evidence was collected declines to give 
consent for analysis; or 
 
 [(4)] (IV) the suspect’s profile has been collected for entry as a convicted 
offender for a qualifying offense in the Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) maintained 
by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the suspect has pleaded guilty to the offense 
that led to the sexual assault evidence collection kit. 
 
 (2) FOR A SEXUAL ASSAULT EVIDENCE COLLECTION KIT IN THE 
CUSTODY OF A PERSON , OTHER THAN AN EMPLOY EE OF A LAW ENFORCEM ENT 
AGENCY, THE PERSON: 
 
 (I) SHALL STORE THE SEXU	AL ASSAULT EVIDENCE 
COLLECTION KIT IN A MANNER THAT : 
 
 1. REASONABLY PREVENTS UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS TO 
OR TAMPERING WITH TH E SEXUAL ASSAULT EVI DENCE COLLECTION KIT ; AND 
 
 2. IS NOT LIKELY TO RES ULT IN THE DEGRADATI ON OR 
LOSS OF THE SEXUAL A SSAULT EVIDENCE COLL ECTION KIT; OR 
 
 (II) TRANSFER THE SEXUAL ASSAULT E VIDENCE COLLECTION 
KIT TO: 
 
 1. A LAW ENFORCEMENT AG ENCY THAT AGREES TO TAKE 
CUSTODY OF THE SEXUA L ASSAULT EVIDENCE C OLLECTION KIT; OR 
 
 2. ANOTHER PERSON IN TH E STATE WHO WILL STORE 
THE SEXUAL ASSAULT E VIDENCE COLLECTION K IT IN ACCORDANCE WITH ITEM (I) 
OF THIS PARAGRAPH .  
 
 (f) (1) If a victim of sexual assault wishes to remain anonymous and not file a 
criminal complaint, the victim shall be informed that the victim may file a criminal 
complaint at a future time. 
 
 (2) If a provision of subsection (e) of this section is determined to be 
satisfied after the submission of the victim’s sexual assault evidence collection kit for 
analysis, testing may be terminated or not initiated. 
 
 (g) Except as provided in subsection (e) of this section, an investigating law 
enforcement agency that receives a sexual assault evidence collection kit shall: 
 
 (1) submit the kit and all requested associated reference standards to a 
forensic laboratory for analysis within 30 days of receipt of the kit and all requested 
associated reference standards; and   	WES MOORE, Governor 	Ch. 702 
 
– 5 – 
 
 (2) make use of certified sexual assault crisis programs or other qualified 
community–based sexual assault victim service organizations that can provide services and 
support to survivors of sexual assault. 
 
 (h) (1) (i) A forensic laboratory that receives a sexual assault evidence 
collection kit and all requested associated reference standards for analysis shall determine 
suitability and complete screening, testing, and analysis in a timely manner. 
 
 (ii) Failure to complete the screening, testing, and analysis in a 
timely manner as required in subparagraph (i) of this paragraph may not constitute the 
basis for excluding the analysis or results as evidence in a criminal proceeding. 
 
 (2) Forensic laboratories shall report annually to the Maryland Sexual 
Assault Evidence Kit Policy and Funding Committee regarding the duration required to 
complete testing, beginning with receipt of the kit until a report is prepared, of each sexual 
assault evidence collection kit. 
 
 (i) (1) The eligible results of an analysis of a sexual assault evidence collection 
kit shall be entered into CODIS. 
 
 (2) The DNA collected from a victim under this section may not be used for 
any purpose except as authorized by this section. 
 
 (j) IF A PERSON FAILS TO COMPLY WITH A REQUIR EMENT RELATING TO 
THE STORAGE OF A SEX UAL ASSAULT EVIDENCE COLLECTION KIT UNDER THIS 
SECTION, THE ATTORNEY GENERAL MAY: 
 
 (1) DIRECT THE PERSON TO COMPLY WITH THE REQU IREMENT; AND 
 
 (2) IF THE PERSON D OES NOT COMPLY , APPLY FOR AN ORDER T O 
SHOW CAUSE WHY THE R EQUIREMENT SHOULD NO T BE COMPLIED WITH T O THE 
CIRCUIT COURT FOR TH E COUNTY:  
 
 (I) IF THE PERSON IS AN INDIVIDUAL, WHERE THE INDIVIDUAL 
WORKS OR RESIDES ; OR 
 
 (II) IF THE PERSON IS NOT AN INDIVIDUAL, WHERE THE PERSON 
OR THE SEXUAL ASSAUL T EVIDENCE COLLECTIO N KIT IS LOCATED.  
 
 (K) (j) The Attorney General shall adopt regulations for uniform statewide 
implementation of this section. 
  Ch. 702 	2023 LAWS OF MARYLAND  
 
– 6 – 
 SECTION 2. AND BE IT FURTHER ENACTED, That this Act shall be construed to 
apply to and interpreted to affect physical evidence of sexual assault collected from victims 
before and after October 1, 2023. 
 
 SECTION 3. AND BE IT FURTHER ENACTED, That: 
 
 (a) A sexual assault evidence collection kit collected before January 1, 2000, and 
stored by a hospital or child advocacy center shall be: 
 
 (1) retained consistent with the requirements of § 11–926(d) of the 
Criminal Procedure Article, as enacted by Section 1 of this Act; and 
 
 (2) transferred to a law enforcement agency for testing within 30 days after 
being identified as a sexual assault evidence collection kit, or as directed by the Maryland 
Sexual Assault Evidence Kit Policy and Funding Committee Office of the Attorney General. 
 
 (b) On or before December 1, 2023, the Maryland Sexual Assault Evidence Kit 
Policy and Funding Committee shall issue a report to the Governor and, in accordance with 
§ 2–1257 of the State Government Article, the General Assembly making recommendations 
for: 
 
 (1) guidelines for the transfer of sexual assault evidence collection kits 
collected before January 1, 2000, to be transferred to law enforcement agencies for testing; 
 
 (2) guidance on the use of self–administered sexual assault evidence 
collection kits; and 
 
 (3) in consultation with the Consumer Protection Division of the Office of 
the Attorney General, educating consumers about use of self–administered sexual assault 
evidence collection kits, including information regarding the kits’ admissibility in a 
criminal prosecution and identifying other resources for victims of sexual assault.  
 
 SECTION 3. 4. AND BE IT FURTHER ENACTED, That this Act shall take effect 
October 1, 2023. 
 
Approved by the Governor, May 16, 2023.