Maine 2023-2024 Regular Session

Maine House Bill LD1098

Introduced
3/9/23  
Refer
3/9/23  
Refer
3/9/23  

Caption

An Act to Restore Religious and Philosophical Exemptions Regarding Immunization Requirements

Impact

If passed, LD1098 would significantly impact state health regulations by allowing parents and educators to claim exemptions based on their beliefs without having to adhere to the immunization mandates that were reinforced following the removal of such exemptions in 2019. This change is likely to affect public health initiatives aimed at maintaining herd immunity within school populations and could lead to an increased risk of vaccine-preventable diseases, raising concerns among healthcare professionals and public health advocates.

Summary

LD1098, titled 'An Act to Restore Religious and Philosophical Exemptions Regarding Immunization Requirements,' proposes to reinstate exemptions for immunization requirements based on religious or philosophical beliefs. The bill seeks to reverse a previous decision made in 2019 that eliminated such exemptions for students in public, private, and postsecondary education, as well as for employees of nursery schools and certain healthcare facilities. By reintroducing these exemptions, the bill reflects a shift toward accommodating individuals who hold specific belief systems opposing mandated immunization on personal grounds.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding LD1098 appears to be divided. Supporters argue that the bill respects individual freedoms and parental rights when it comes to medical decisions for their children. They emphasize personal beliefs as critical components of public policy. Conversely, opponents express significant concern regarding the public health implications of reinstating such exemptions, viewing the measure as a threat to community health and safety. The debate thus highlights the ongoing tension between personal liberties and public health responsibilities.

Contention

Notable points of contention include the debate surrounding the balance of individual rights against collective health benefits. Critics warn about potential outbreaks of diseases that could arise from lower vaccination rates in schools, while supporters believe that families should have the autonomy to make healthcare choices based on their beliefs. The legislative history also indicates a closely contested voting process, with the preliminary vote showing 19 in favor and 11 against, reflecting a contentious atmosphere among lawmakers regarding the implications of the bill.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

ME LD51

An Act to Restore Religious and Philosophical Exemptions to Immunization Requirements

ME LD174

An Act to Restore Religious Exemptions to Immunization Requirements

ME LD1209

An Act to Reinstate the Religious and Philosophical Vaccine Exemptions for Private Schools and Virtual Public Charter Schools

ME HB1453

Vaccine exemption; authorize for religious, philosophical or conscientious reasons.

ME HB1506

Vaccine exemption; authorize for religious, philosophical or conscientious reasons.

ME HB1571

Vaccine exemption; authorize for religious, philosophical or conscientious reasons.

ME HB1487

Vaccine exemption; authorize for religious, philosophical or conscientious reasons.

ME SB535

Creating religious and philosophical exemptions for school attendance vaccines

ME SB474

Require acceptance of religious and personal medical exemptions to required immunizations

ME SB382

Requiring acceptance of religious or conscience exemptions to immunizations

Similar Bills

TX SB769

Relating to methods for the recovery of system restoration costs incurred by electric utilities following hurricanes, tropical storms, ice or snow storms, floods, and other weather-related events and natural disasters.

TX HB1378

Relating to methods for the recovery of system restoration costs incurred by electric utilities following hurricanes, tropical storms, ice or snow storms, floods, and other weather-related events and natural disasters.

TX HB1510

Relating to the response and resilience of certain electricity service providers to major weather-related events or other natural disasters; granting authority to issue bonds.

LA HB667

Reorganizes and recodifies the Miscellaneous Health Provisions chapter of Title 40 of the La. Revised Statutes

TX SB1255

Relating to a state intercept credit enhancement program for certain bonds issued by school districts.

LA HCR84

Directs the La. State Law Institute to reorganize and recodify the Miscellaneous Health Provisions chapter of Title 40 of the La. Revised Statutes

TX SB1782

Relating to the response and resilience of certain utilities to major weather-related events or natural disasters.

TX SB942

Relating to local option methods for financing transportation projects and services.