Maine 2023-2024 Regular Session

Maine Senate Bill LD148

Introduced
1/10/23  
Refer
1/10/23  

Caption

An Act to Allow Detention of Juveniles for Certain Acts

Impact

If enacted, LD148 would amend existing laws regarding juvenile detention, specifically broadening the justifiable reasons for such detention. This change is expected to have significant implications on how juvenile offenses are addressed by law enforcement and judicial authorities, possibly leading to increased detainments. Proponents argue that the bill emphasizes the need to protect juveniles from harm and prevent future criminal activity, while critics express concerns over the potential negative impacts on juvenile rights and rehabilitation opportunities.

Summary

LD148, an Act to Allow Detention of Juveniles for Certain Acts, proposes amendments that enable the detention of juveniles under specific circumstances, including the lack of an adult supervisor and the necessity to prevent them from committing criminal offenses. The bill aims to address gaps in the current juvenile justice system by expanding the criteria under which a juvenile may be temporarily detained, thereby enhancing protective measures for both the juvenile and the community at large.

Sentiment

The sentiment towards LD148 has been mixed. Supporters view it as a necessary step to strengthen community safety and protect vulnerable juveniles who might be a risk to themselves or others when left unsupervised. Conversely, opponents argue that expanded detention criteria may exacerbate existing issues within the juvenile justice system and infringe on the rights of children, potentially leading to a pipeline towards more severe legal consequences.

Contention

A notable point of contention revolves around whether expanding the grounds for juvenile detention will effectively serve its intended purpose or if it will contribute to an over-reliance on incarceration as a solution to behavioral issues among youth. Debates among legislators have highlighted concerns about the long-term effects on youth and the moral implications of detaining juveniles for preventive reasons, underlining a division in philosophies regarding juvenile justice.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

ME SB448

Juveniles: detention hearings.

ME LD702

An Act Regarding the Detention, Supervision and Transportation of Arrested Juveniles

ME SB1111

Juveniles: detention facilities.

ME LD4

An Act to Update Provisions of the Department of Corrections Laws Regarding Operation and Administration of Jails, Women's Services and Juvenile Detention

ME HB1324

Juvenile delinquency and detention.

ME HB2021

Requiring the secretary for children and families to assess certain children and the secretary of corrections to provide certain services to juveniles in detention, changing the criteria used to refer and admit juveniles to a juvenile crisis intervention center, allowing evidence-based program account money to be used on certain children, requiring the department of corrections to build data systems and allowing for overall case length limit extensions for certain juvenile offenders.

ME A3793

Authorizes home detention for juveniles adjudicated delinquent for certain motor vehicle offenses.

ME LD42

An Act Regarding the Bind-over and Detention of Juveniles

ME SB159

Provides for the detention of seventeen year old juveniles under certain circumstances. (gov sig) (EN NO IMPACT See Note)

ME A5187

Authorizes home detention for juveniles adjudicated delinquent for certain motor vehicle offenses.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.