Maine Senate Bill LD723

Maine 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 2/16/23
• Refer: 2/16/23
• Failed: 3/9/23

Caption

An Act to Protect Consumers by Prohibiting Discrimination by Insurers Based on Certain Information

Impact

The enactment of LD723 would lead to significant changes in how insurers assess risk and price their products. By eliminating the use of certain demographic and socioeconomic factors, the legislation is expected to foster a more equitable environment in which consumers are evaluated based on their actual risk rather than biased assumptions. This could have a positive effect on the accessibility of insurance for individuals who may otherwise face higher costs due to the factors outlined in the bill.

Summary

LD723, titled 'An Act to Protect Consumers by Prohibiting Discrimination by Insurers Based on Certain Information', aims to prevent insurance companies from using consumer credit report information to set premium rates. Specifically, the bill prohibits insurers from charging higher premiums based on an individual's race, ethnicity, religion, gender, income, lack of credit history, or zip code. The intention is to promote fairness in insurance pricing and protect consumers from discriminatory practices that could arise from biased data use.

Sentiment

The general sentiment around LD723 appears to be supportive, especially among consumer advocacy groups and legislators who prioritize social equity. Proponents argue that the bill is a much-needed reform that addresses longstanding disparities in insurance practices. Conversely, there may be concerns from the insurance industry regarding potential impacts on profit margins and the viability of risk assessment methodologies, suggesting a mix of support and apprehension.

Contention

Notable points of contention are likely to arise from the insurance industry, which might argue that certain risk-related factors (including those banned by the bill) are critical for ensuring the sustainability and functionality of their business models. Critics may express concern that the prohibition could lead to less precise risk assessments and potentially higher overall premiums for all consumers, as insurers may need to adjust their pricing strategies. This tension highlights the balancing act between consumer rights and the economic realities of the insurance market.