Michigan House Bill HB4217

Michigan 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 3/8/23
• Refer: 3/8/23

Caption

Elections: other; electoral votes; require to be chosen from each congressional district. Amends sec. 45 of 1954 PA 116 (MCL 168.45). TIE BAR WITH: HB 4216'23

Impact

The impact of HB4217 on state laws centers around the mechanics of presidential elections in Michigan. By redefining how a vote for presidential candidates is interpreted, the bill seeks to streamline the voting process and reduce potential confusion among voters. Furthermore, it aligns with a broader national conversation regarding the electoral college and the way electoral votes are awarded based on party alignment rather than individual candidates. This amendment is significant for both voters and political parties as it affects how votes translate into electoral outcomes.

Summary

House Bill 4217 seeks to amend the Michigan election law, specifically section 45 of the 1954 PA 116, regarding the manner in which voters cast their votes for presidential candidates. The bill proposes that marking a cross (X) or a check mark under a political party's name during the general election shall not be viewed as a direct vote for the party's presidential candidates. Instead, it will count as a vote for the entire list of presidential electors associated with that political party. This amendment intends to clarify the voting process and ensure that votes align with the electors certified by political parties.

Contention

Discussion around HB4217 may attract contention primarily regarding its implications for voter choice. Critics of the bill could argue that it detracts from the direct accountability of presidential candidates to voters and strengthens the power of political parties over individual voter preferences. This could lead to debates on the democratic principle of voting for individuals as opposed to party lists, raising concerns about how this change may affect voter engagement and trust in the electoral process in Michigan.