Minnesota 2023-2024 Regular Session

Minnesota House Bill HF1931

Introduced
2/16/23  

Caption

Law on use of force in self-defense clarified, common law duty to retreat outside the home eliminated, boundaries of dwelling expanded, and presumption created.

Impact

If enacted, HF1931 would have significant implications on state laws concerning self-defense. It modifies existing provisions in Minnesota Statutes, particularly sections 609.06 and 609.065, creating a presumption in favor of self-defense. The adjustments would allow individuals to use reasonable force, including deadly force, if they believe it is necessary to prevent great bodily harm or death. This change may lead to a shift in how self-defense cases are prosecuted and defended in Minnesota.

Summary

House File 1931 seeks to clarify Minnesota's laws regarding self-defense, specifically eliminating the common law duty to retreat when a person is outside their home. The bill affirms that individuals have the right to defend themselves without the obligation to retreat first, broadening the scope of 'dwelling' for self-defense purposes. This aims to empower individuals to feel confident in protecting themselves in various situations, not limited to just their homes.

Contention

The proposal has sparked debate among lawmakers and the public. Critics argue that eliminating the duty to retreat outside the home could lead to unnecessary violence and escalate conflicts, while supporters suggest it enhances personal safety and individual rights. The discussion reflects broader concerns about how self-defense laws can be interpreted and applied in practice, especially in urban areas where encounters may lead to violence.

Additional_notes

The bill is set to take effect on August 1, 2023, if passed, marking a shift in Minnesota's approach to self-defense laws, which could have lasting legal and social ramifications.

Companion Bills

MN SF1767

Similar To Force in self-defense law clarification; common law duty to retreat in cases of self-defense outside the home elimination; boundaries of dwelling for purposes of self-defense expansion; presumption of right to self-defense creation

Previously Filed As

MN SF1767

Force in self-defense law clarification; common law duty to retreat in cases of self-defense outside the home elimination; boundaries of dwelling for purposes of self-defense expansion; presumption of right to self-defense creation

MN HF3130

Law on use of force in self-defense clarified, common law duty to retreat in cases of self-defense outside the home expanded, and presumption of right to self-defense created.

MN HF1288

Law on use of force in defense of home and person clarified, self-defense and defense of home laws codified and extended, common law duty to retreat outside the home eliminated, boundaries of dwelling expanded, presumption created, and rights available to a person in that person's dwelling extended to others defending against forced entry.

MN HF661

Law on use of force in defense of home and person clarified, self-defense and defense of home laws codified and extended, common law duty to retreat outside the home eliminated, boundaries of dwelling expanded, presumption created, and rights available to a person in that person's dwelling extended to others defending against forced entry.

MN HF356

Law on use of force in defense of home and person clarified, self-defense and defense of home laws codified and extended, common law duty to retreat outside the home eliminated, boundaries of dwelling expanded, presumption created, and rights available to a person in that person's dwelling extended to others defending against forced entry.

MN HF658

Law on use of force in defense of home and person clarified, self-defense and defense of home laws codified and extended, common law duty to retreat outside the home eliminated, boundaries of dwelling expanded, presumption created, and rights available to a person in that person's dwelling extended to others defending against forced entry.

MN HF893

Law on use of force in defense of home and person clarified, self-defense and defense of home laws codified and extended, common law duty to retreat eliminated in certain cases, boundaries of dwelling expanded, presumption created, and rights extended to others defending against entry.

MN HF786

Law on use of force in defense of home and person clarified, self-defense and defense of home laws codified and extended, common law duty to retreat eliminated in certain cases, boundaries of dwelling expanded, presumption created, and rights extended to others defending against entry.

MN HF5368

Law on use of force in defense of home and person clarified, Minnesota's self-defense and defense of home laws codified and extended, common law duty to retreat in cases of self-defense outside the home eliminated, boundaries of dwelling expanded for purposes of self-defense, and other self defense provisions modified.

MN SF5412

Use of force in defense of home and person law clarification; Minnesota's self-defense of home laws extension and codification; common law duty to retreat in cases of self-defense outside the home elimination; boundaries of dwelling expansion for purposes of self-defense; presumption in the case of a person entering a dwelling or occupied vehicle by stealth or force creation; rights available to a person in that person's dwelling to a person defending against entry of that person's occupied vehicle extension

Similar Bills

CA AB352

Crimes: criminal threats.

CT HB05742

An Act Concerning Threatening Of A Judge.

CA AB237

Crimes: threats.

CA AB1133

California Endangered Species Act: experimental populations.

CT HB05495

An Act Concerning Enhanced Penalties For Threatening A Judge.

CA AB2330

Endangered species: incidental take: wildfire preparedness activities.

CA AB2421

Employer-employee relations: confidential communications.

CA AB550

The California Endangered Species Act: take of species: renewable electrical generation facilities.