4133S.06C 1 SENATE COMMITTEE SUBSTITUTE FOR SENATE BILLS NOS. 681 & 662 AN ACT To repeal sections 161.097, 167.268, 167.640, 167.645, and 170.014, RSMo, and to enact in lieu thereof eight new sections relating to educational outcomes. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Missouri, as follows: Section A. Sections 161.097, 167.268, 167.640, 167.645, and 170.014, RSMo, are repealed and eight new sections enacted in lieu thereof, to be known as sections 161.097, 161.214, 161.241, 167.268, 167.640, 167.645, 170.014, and 186.080, to read as follows: 161.097. 1. The state board of education shall establish standards and procedures by which it will evaluate all teacher training institutions in this state for the approval of teacher education programs. The state board of education shall not require teacher training institutions to meet national or regional accreditation as a part of its standards and procedures in making those evaluations, but it may accept such accreditations in lieu of such approval if standards and procedures set thereby are at least as stringent as those set by the board. The state board of education's standards and procedures for evaluating teacher training institutions shall equal or exceed those of national or regional accrediting associations. 2. There is hereby established within the department of elementary and secondary education the "Missouri Advisory Board for Educator Preparation", hereinafter referred to as "MABEP". The MABEP shall advise the state board of education and the coordinating board for higher education regarding matters of mutual interest in the area of quality 2 educator preparation programs in Missouri. The advisory board shall include at least three active elementary or secondary classroom teachers and at least three fac ulty members within approved educator preparation programs. The classroom teacher members shall be selected to represent various regions of the state and districts of different sizes. The faculty representatives shall represent institutions from var ious regions of the state and sizes of program. The advisory board shall hold regular meetings that allow members to share needs and concerns and plan strategies to enhance teacher preparation. 3. Upon approval by the state board of education of the teacher education program at a particular teacher training institution, any person who graduates from that program, and who meets other requirements which the state board of education shall prescribe by rule, regulation and statute shall be grante d a certificate or license to teach in the public schools of this state. However, no such rule or regulation shall require that the program from which the person graduates be accredited by any national or regional accreditation association. 4. The state board of education shall, in consultation with MABEP, align literacy and reading instruction coursework for teacher education programs in early childhood, kindergarten to fifth grade elementary teacher certification, middle school communicatio n arts, high school communication arts, and all reading and special education certificates to include the following: (1) Teacher candidates shall receive classroom and clinical training in: (a) The core components of reading, including phonem ic awareness, phonics, fluency, comprehension, morphology, syntax, and vocabulary; 3 (b) Oral and written language development; and (c) Identification of reading deficiencies, dyslexia, and other language difficulties; (2) Teacher candidates shall also have training on: (a) The selection and use of reading curricula and instructional materials; (b) The administration and interpretation of assessments; (c) How to translate assessment results into effective practice in the classroom specific to the needs of students; and (d) Additional best practices in the field of literacy instruction as recommended by the literacy advisory council pursuant to section 186.080. 5. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that te rm is defined in section 536.010, that is created under the authority delegated in this section shall become effective only if it complies with and is subject to all of the provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section 536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable and if any of the powers vested with the general assembly pursuant to chapter 536 to review, to delay the effective date, or to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently held unconstitutional, then the grant of rulema king authority and any rule proposed or adopted after August 28, 2014, shall be invalid and void. 161.214. 1. For purposes of this section, the following terms shall mean: (1) "Board", the state board of education; (2) "Department", the department of elementary and secondary education; (3) "School innovation team", a group of natural persons officially authorized by: 4 (a) A single elementary or secondary school; (b) A group of two or more elementary or sec ondary schools within the same school district that share common interests, such as geographical location or educational focus, or that sequentially serve classes of students as they progress through elementary and secondary education; (c) A group of two or more elementary or secondary schools not within the same school district that share common interests, such as geographical location or educational focus, or that sequentially serve classes of students as they progress through elementary and secondary education; (d) A single school district; or (e) A group of two or more school districts that share common interests, such as geographical location or educational focus, or that sequentially serve classes of students as they progr ess through elementary and secondary education; (4) "School innovation waiver", a waiver granted by the board to a single school, group of schools, single school district, or group of school districts pursuant to this section, in which the school , group of schools, school district, or group of school districts is exempt from a specific requirement imposed by chapter 160, chapter 161, chapter 162, chapter 167, chapter 170, or chapter 171, or any regulations promulgated thereunder by the board o r the department. Any school innovation waiver granted to a school district or group of school districts shall be applicable to every elementary and secondary school within the school district or group of school districts unless the plan specifically provides otherwise. 5 2. Any school innovation team seeking a school innovation waiver may submit a plan to the board for one or more of the following purposes: (1) Improving student readiness for employment, higher education, vocational trai ning, technical training, or any other form of career and job training; (2) Increasing the compensation of teachers; or (3) Improving the recruitment, retention, training, preparation, or professional development of teachers. 3. Any plan for a school innovation waiver shall: (1) Identify the specific provision of law for which a waiver is being requested and provide an explanation for why the specific provision of law inhibits the ability of the school or school district to acco mplish the goal stated in the plan; (2) Demonstrate that the intent of the specific provision of law can be addressed in a more effective, efficient or economical manner and that the waiver or modification is necessary to implement the plan; (3) Include measurable annual performance targets and goals for the implementation of the plan; (4) Specify the innovations to be pursued in meeting one or more of the goals listed in subsection 2 of this section; (5) Demonstrate parental , school employee, and community and business support for, and engagement with, the plan; and (6) Be approved by at least the minimum number of people required to be on the school innovation team prior to submitting the plan for approval. 4. (1) In evaluating a plan submitted by a school innovation team under subsection 2 of this section, the board shall consider whether the plan will: 6 (a) Improve the preparation, counseling, and overall readiness of students for postsecondary life ; (b) Increase teacher salaries in a financially sustainable and prudent manner; or (c) Increase the attractiveness of the teaching profession for prospective teachers and active teachers alike. (2) The board may approve any plan submi tted under subsection 2 of this section if it determines that: (a) The plan successfully demonstrates the ability to address the intent of the provision of law to be waived in a more effective, efficient or economical manner; (b) The waivers or modifications are demonstrated to be necessary to stimulate improved student readiness for postsecondary life, increase teacher salaries, or increase the attractiveness of the teaching profession for prospective teachers and active teachers; (c) The plan has demonstrated sufficient participation from among the teachers, principals, superintendent, faculty, school board, parents, and the community at large; and (d) The plan is based upon sound educational practices, does not endanger the health and safety of students or staff, and does not compromise equal opportunity for learning. (3) The board may propose modifications to the plan in cooperation with the school innovation team. 5. Any waiver granted under this section shall be effective for a period of no longer than three school years beginning the school year following the school year in which the waiver is approved. Any waiver may be renewed. No more than one school innovation waiver shall be in effect with 7 respect to any one elementary or secondary school at one time. 6. This section shall not be construed to allow the state board of education to authorize the waiver of any statutory requirements relating to teacher certification, teacher tenure, or any requirement imposed by federal law. 7. The board may promulgate rules implementing the provisions of this section. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that term is defined in section 536.010, that is created under the authority delegated in thi s section shall become effective only if it complies with and is subject to all of the provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section 536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable and if any of the powers vested with the general assemb ly pursuant to chapter 536 to review, to delay the effective date, or to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently held unconstitutional, then the grant of rulemaking authority and any rule proposed or adopted after August 28, 2022, shall be invali d and void. 161.241. 1. The state board of education, in collaboration with the coordinating board for higher education and the commissioner's advisory council under section 186.080, shall develop a plan to establish a comprehensive system of services for reading instruction. 2. The state board of education shall establish and periodically update a statewide literacy plan that supports high quality, evidence -based reading instruction for all students. 3. The state board of education shall create an office of literacy. The commissioner of education shall coordinate staff with roles relating to literacy and align staff work around supporting best practices in reading instruction. 8 4. The state board of education sh all align literacy and reading instruction coursework for teacher education programs as required under subsection 4 of section 161.097. 5. Subject to appropriation, the department of elementary and secondary education shall recruit and employ quality teacher trainers with expertise in reading instruction and provide opportunities for evidence -based professional development in reading instruction available for all active teachers. 6. The department shall maintain and publish data on reading outcomes, provided that the report shall not include individually identifiable student data. 7. The department shall publish criteria and examples to help districts and schools select and use evidence -based reading curricula and instructional m aterials. Additionally, the department shall publish a list of curricula that ensure instruction is explicit, systematic, diagnostic and based on phonological awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, comprehension, morphology, syntax, and semantics. This shall be a resource to districts. 8. The department shall provide online tools and training for active teachers on evidence -based reading instruction. 9. There is hereby created in the state treasury the "Evidence-based Reading Instruc tion Program Fund". The fund shall be administered by the department and used to reimburse school districts and charter schools for efforts to improve student literacy, including, but not limited to: initiatives that provide optional training and mat erials to teachers regarding best practices in reading pedagogies; resources for parents and guardians to assist them in teaching their children to read; funding for reading tutoring programs outside of regular school hours; stipends 9 for teachers who undergo additional training in reading instruction, which may also count toward professional development requirements; and funding for summer reading programs. The fund shall consist of moneys appropriated annually by the general assembly from general revenue to such fund, any moneys paid into the state treasury and required by law to be credited to such fund and any gifts, bequests or donations to such fund. The fund shall be kept separate and apart from all other moneys in the state treasury and shall be paid out by the state treasurer pursuant to chapter 33. Notwithstanding the provisions of section 33.080 to the contrary, moneys in the fund at the end of the biennium shall not be transferred to the credit of the general revenue fund. All interest and moneys earned on the fund shall be credited to the fund. 167.268. 1. Each [local] school district and charter school shall have on file a policy for reading [intervention] success plans [for any pupils of the district in grades kindergarten through three pursuant to the provisions of this section. Such plans shall identify strategies to be followed by the district teachers to raise a pupil identified as reading below grade level by recognized methods to reading at gr ade level by the end of the third grade. Recognized methods of identification may include but need not be limited to the scores of the pupil obtained through any established standardized testing program currently administered by the district, observat ions of classroom teachers, and documented classroom performance]. Each school district and charter school shall provide all parents and guardians of students, including parents of students who are identified as having a substantial deficiency in re ading under subsection 1 of 10 section 167.645, with a plan that includes suggestions for regular parent-guided home reading. 2. [The state board of education ] The department of elementary and secondary education shall develop guidelines to assist districts and charter schools in formulating policies for reading [intervention] success plans. Such guidelines may include, but are not limited to, measures of reading proficiency, strategies for addressing reading deficiencies, timelines for measurin g pupil improvement in reading, and information on screening [for and treatment] of [auditory] dyslexia[, and information on the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test and the Auditory Discrimination in Depth Program ]. Such guidelines may also identify performance levels for pupils identified as handicapped or severely handicapped and conditions under which such pupils [are] may be exempt from the provisions of this section and section 167.645. 3. [Each local school district enrolling a pu pil identified as reading below grade level shall develop an individual plan of reading intervention for such pupil. The individual pupil's plan may include individual or group reading development activities. The plan may be developed after consultation with the pupil's parent or legal guardian] Each school district and charter school shall provide intensive reading instruction to students as provided in section 167.645 . 167.640. 1. School districts [may] shall adopt a policy with regard to student promotion which may require remediation as a condition of promotion to the next grade level for any student identified by the district as failing to master skills and competencies established for that particular grade level by the district board of education. School districts may also require parents or guardians of 11 such students to commit to conduct home -based tutorial activities with their children or, in the case of a student with disabilities eligible for services pursuant to sections 162.670 to 162.1000, the individual education plan shall determine the nature of parental involvement consistent with the requirements for a free, appropriate public education. 2. Such remediation shall recognize that different students learn differently and shall employ methods designed to help these students achieve at high levels. Such remediation may include, but shall not necessarily be limited to, a mandatory summer school program focused on the areas of deficiency or other such activities conducted by the school district outside of the regular school day. Decisions concerning the instruction of a child who receives special educational services pursuant to sections 162.670 to 162.1000 shall be made in accordance with the child's individualized education plan. 3. School districts providing remediation pursuant to this section or section 167.245 outside of the traditional school day may count extra hours of instruction in the calculation of average daily attendanc e as defined in section 163.011. 167.645. 1. [For purposes of this section, the following terms mean: (1) "Reading assessment", a recognized method of judging a student's reading ability, with results expressed as reading at a particular grade level. The term reading assessment shall include, but is not limited to, standard checklists designed for use as a student reads out loud, paper-and-pencil tests promulgated by nationally recognized organizations and other recognized m ethods of determining a student's reading accuracy, expression, fluency and comprehension in order to make a determination of the 12 student's grade-level reading ability. Assessments which do not give a grade-level result may be used in combination with other assessments to reach a grade -level determination. Districts are encouraged but not required to select assessment methods identified pursuant to section 167.346. Districts are also encouraged to use multiple methods of assessment; (2) "Summer school", for reading instruction purposes, a minimum of forty hours of reading instruction and practice. A school district may arrange the hours and days of instruction to coordinate with its regular program of summer school. 2. For purposes of this section, methods of reading assessment shall be determined by each school district. Unless a student has been determined in the current school year to be reading at grade level or above, each school district shall administer a reading asses sment or set of assessments to each student within forty -five days of the end of the third-grade year, except that the provisions of this subsection shall not apply to students receiving special education services under an individualized education plan pursuant to sections 162.670 to 162.999, to students receiving services pursuant to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 whose services plan includes an element addressing reading or to students determined to have limited English proficiency or to students who have been determined, prior to the beginning of any school year, to have a cognitive ability insufficient to meet the reading requirement set out in this section, provided that districts shall provide reading improvement plans for s tudents determined to have such insufficient cognitive ability. The assessment required by this subsection shall also be required for students who enter a school district in grades 13 four, five or six unless such student has been determined in the current school year to be reading at grade level or above. 3. Beginning with school year 2002 -03, for each student whose third-grade reading assessment determines that such student is reading below second -grade level, the school district shall design a reading improvement plan for the student's fourth-grade year. Such reading improvement plan shall include, at a minimum, thirty hours of additional reading instruction or practice outside the regular school day during the fourth -grade year. The school district shall determine the method of reading instruction necessary to enforce this subsection. The school district may also require the student to attend summer school for reading instruction as a condition of promotion to fourth grade. The department of elementary and secondary education may, from funds appropriated for the purpose, reimburse school districts for additional instructional personnel costs incurred in the implementation and execution of the thirty hours of additional reading instruction minus the revenue generated by the school district through the foundation formula for the additional reading instruction average daily attendance. 4. Each student for whom a reading improvement plan has been designed pursuant to subs ection 3 of this section shall be given another reading assessment, to be administered within forty -five days of the end of such student's fourth-grade year. If such student is determined to be reading below third -grade level, the student shall be required to attend summer school to receive reading instruction. At the end of such summer school instruction, such student shall be given another reading assessment. If such student is determined to be reading below third -grade 14 level, the district sha ll notify the student's parents or guardians, and the student shall not be promoted to fifth grade. No student shall be denied promotion more than once solely for inability to meet the reading standards set out in this section. 5. The process described in subsections 3 and 4 of this section shall be repeated as necessary through the end of the sixth grade, with the target grade level rising accordingly. Mandatory retention in grade shall not apply to grades subsequent to fourth grade. 6. The mandatory process of additional reading instruction pursuant to this section shall cease at the end of the sixth grade. The permanent record of students who are determined to be reading below the fifth -grade level at the end of sixth grade shal l carry a notation advising that such student has not met minimal reading standards. The notation shall stay on the student's record until such time as the district determines that a student has met minimal reading standards. 7. Each school district shall be required to offer summer school reading instruction to any student with a reading improvement plan. Districts may fulfill the requirement of this section through cooperative arrangements with neighboring districts; provided that such dis tricts shall timely make all payments provided pursuant to such cooperative agreements. 8. A school district may adopt a policy that requires retention in grade of any student who has been determined to require summer school instruction in readin g and who does not fulfill the summer school attendance requirement. 9. Nothing in this section shall preclude a school district from retaining any student in grade when a 15 determination is made in accordance with district policy that retention is in the best interests of the student. 10. The state board of education shall not incorporate information about the number of students receiving additional instruction pursuant to this section into any element of any standard of the Missouri schoo l improvement program or its successor accreditation program; provided, however, each district shall make available, upon the request of any parent, patron, or media outlet within the district, the number and percentage of students receiving remediation pursuant to this section. The information shall be presented in a way that does not permit personal identification of any student or educational personnel. 11. Each school district shall make a systematic effort to inform parents of the method s and materials used to teach reading in kindergarten through fourth grade, in terms understandable to a layperson and shall similarly inform parents of students for whom a reading improvement plan is required pursuant to this section ] Each school district and charter school shall assess all students enrolled in kindergarten through grade three at the beginning and end of each school year for their level of reading or reading readiness on state -approved reading assessments. Additionally all school districts and charter schools shall assess any newly enrolled student in grades one through five for their level of reading or reading readiness on a reading assessment from the state -approved list. At the beginning of the school year, each school district and charter school shall provide a reading success plan to any student who: (1) Exhibits a substantial deficiency in reading which creates a barrier to the child's progress learning to read. 16 The identification of such deficiency may be ba sed upon the most recent assessments or teacher observation; or (2) Has been identified as being at risk of dyslexia in the statewide dyslexia screening or has a formal diagnosis of dyslexia. For the purposes of this section, a substantial reading deficiency shall refer to a student who is one or more grade level or levels behind in reading or reading readiness; provided that nothing in this section shall be interpreted to prevent a school district or charter school from offering a reading success plan to any student based on an assessment completed at the start and end of the school year or teacher observation. For any student entering the school district or charter school after the start of the school year, such student shall be provided a reading success plan in the event the student has been identified as having a substantial reading deficiency based on the student's most recent assessment or otherwise being identified through teacher observation. The student's reading proficiency shall be reassessed by reading assessments on the state - approved list. The student shall continue to be provided with intensive reading instruction under a reading success plan until the reading deficiency is remedied. 2. The district or charter school shall notify the parent or guardian of any student in kindergarten through grade three who exhibits a substantial deficiency in reading, as described in subsection 1 of this section, at least annually in writing, and in an appropriate, alternative manner for the parent or other guardian if necessary, of the following: (1) That the child has been identified as having a substantial deficiency in reading; 17 (2) A description of the services currently provided to the child; (3) A description of the proposed supplemental instructional services and supports that the school district will provide to the child that are designed to remediate the identified area of reading deficiency. For students identified being at risk of dyslexi a or those that have a diagnosis of dyslexia the district shall provide an explanation that the instruction that will be used to teach the child reading shall be explicit, systematic, and diagnostic and based on phonological awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, comprehension, morphology, syntax, and semantics; (4) Strategies for parents and guardians to use in helping the child succeed in reading proficiency, including but not limited to the promotion of parent -guided home reading. 3. If the school district or charter school provides a summer reading program under this section, the district or charter school shall notify the parent or guardian of each student who exhibits a substantial deficiency in reading of the opportunity to attend the summer reading program. 4. If a student has a substantial reading deficiency at the end of third grade, the student's parent or guardian and appropriate school staff shall discuss whether the student should be retained in grade level, b ased on a consideration of all relevant factors, including the reading deficiency, the student's progress in other subject areas, and the student's overall intellectual, physical, emotional, and social development. A decision to promote or retain a student with a substantial reading deficiency at the end of grade three shall be made only after direct personal consultation with the student's parent or guardian and after 18 the formulation of a specific plan of action to remedy the student's reading de ficiency. 5. Each school district or charter school shall do all of the following: (1) Provide students who are identified as having a substantial deficiency in reading under subsection 1 of this section, have been identified as being at ris k of dyslexia in the statewide dyslexia screening or have a formal diagnosis of dyslexia with intensive instructional services and supports specified in a reading success plan, as appropriate according to student need, free of charge, to remediate the identified areas of reading deficiency, including additional scientific, evidence -based reading instruction and other strategies prescribed by the school district or charter school which may include but are not limited to the following: (a) Small group or individual instruction; (b) Reduced teacher-student ratios; (c) More frequent progress monitoring; (d) Tutoring or mentoring; (e) Extended school day, week, or year; and (f) Summer reading programs; (2) For any student with a formal diagnosis of dyslexia or for a student who was found to be at risk of dyslexia in the statewide dyslexia screening, the school district or charter school shall provide evidence -based reading instruction that addresses phonology, sound-symbol association, syllable instruction, morphology, syntax, and semantics provided through systematic, cumulative, explicit and diagnostic methods; (3) At regular intervals, but no less than four times per year in a manner that reflects progress through each school term, notify the parent or guardian of academic and 19 other progress being made by the student and give the parent or guardian other useful information. (4) In addition to required reading enhancement and acceleration strategies, provide all parents of students, including parents of students who are identified as having a substantial deficiency in reading under subsection 1 of this section, with a plan that includes suggestions for regular parent-guided home reading. 6. Each school district and charter school shall ensure that intensive reading instruction through a reading development initiative shall be provided to each kindergarten through grade five student who is assessed as exhibiting a substantial def iciency in reading. In addition to the requirements otherwise provided, such instruction will also comply with all of the following criteria: (1) Be provided to all kindergarten through grade five students who exhibit a substantial deficiency in reading under this section. The assessment initiative shall measure phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension; (2) Be provided during regular school hours; (3) Provide a reading curriculum that meets the requirements of section 170.014, and at a minimum has the following specifications: (a) Assists students assessed as exhibiting a substantial deficiency in reading to develop the skills to read at grade level; (b) Provides skill development in phonem ic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension; (c) Includes a scientifically based and reliable assessment; (d) Provides initial and ongoing analysis of each student's reading progress; and 20 (e) Provides a curriculum in core academic subjects to assist the student in maintaining or meeting proficiency levels for the appropriate grade in all academic subjects. 7. School districts shall report to the department the specific intensive reading interventions and suppo rts implemented by the school district or charter school pursuant to this section as well as the reading assessment data collected for grades kindergarten through five. The department shall annually prescribe the components of required or requested r eports. 8. (1) Each school district and charter school shall address reading proficiency as part of its comprehensive school improvement plan, drawing upon information about children from assessments conducted pursuant to subsection 1 and the prevalence of deficiencies identified by classroom, elementary school, and other student characteristics. As part of its comprehensive school improvement plan or contract, each school district or charter school shall review chronic early elementary abse nteeism for its impact on literacy development. If more than fifteen percent of an attendance center's students are not at grade level in reading by the end of third grade, the comprehensive school improvement plan or contract shall include strategies to reduce that percentage, including school and community strategies to raise the percentage of students who are proficient in reading. (2) Each school district and charter school shall provide professional development services to enhance the skills of elementary teachers in responding to children's unique reading issues and needs and to increase the use of evidence-based strategies. 170.014. 1. This section shall be known as the "Reading Instruction Act" and is enacted to e nsure that all 21 public schools establish reading programs in kindergarten through grade [three] five based in scientific research. "Evidence-based reading instruction" includes practices that have been proven effective through evaluation of the outcomes for large numbers of students and are highly likely to be effective in improving reading if implemented with fidelity. Such programs shall include the essential components of phonemic awareness, phonics, fluency, vocabulary, and comprehension, and all new teachers who teach reading in kindergarten through grade three shall receive adequate training in these areas. 2. [The program described in subsection 1 of this section may include "explicit systematic phonics", which, for the purposes of this section, shall mean the methodology of pronouncing and reading words by learning the phonetic sound association of individual letters, letter groups, and syllables, and the principles governing these associations. 3.] Every public school in the state shall offer a reading program as described in subsection 1 of this section for kindergarten through grade [three] five. 186.080. 1. The commissioner of education shall establish a literacy advisory council. The council shall consist of no more than twenty members, appointed by the commissioner, and shall include members representing the following stakeholder groups: (1) School boards; (2) Charter schools; (3) School superintendents; (4) Elementary and secondary building principals; (5) At least three teachers, including at least two teachers with expertise in reading instruction; (6) At least two special education educators; 22 (7) At least two parents of elementary and secondary school-age pupils who have struggled with literacy proficiency; (8) At least two community members who have struggled with literacy proficiency or supported others who have struggled with literacy proficiency, at least one of whom shall be a high school student; (9) One member from dyslexia advocacy group; (10) Faculty members of institutions of higher education with approved teacher preparation programs; (11) Professionals with expertise in reading instruction, reading interventi ons and how students learn to read including one certified academic language therapist; and (12) Professionals with expertise in educational assessment data analysis. 2. The council shall meet at least twice per year to review best practices in literacy instruction and related policy provisions. The department shall provide necessary staff and resources for the work of the advisory council. 3. The council shall periodically provide recommendations to the commissioner and the state b oard of education regarding any identified improvements to literacy instruction and policy for students. The recommendations may include recommendations for changes to state law, and the commissioner shall furnish any such recommendations to the joint committee on education. 4. The council recommendations shall: (1) Advise the department of elementary and secondary education on how to implement and maintain the statewide literacy plan required under section 161.241 and advise the department, school districts and charter schools on ways to inform and engage parents and other community members about the literacy plan; 23 (2) Provide advice as to what services the department should provide to school districts and charter schools to support implementation of the plan and on staffing levels and resources needed at the department to support the statewide effort to improve literacy; (3) Provide advice regarding the statewide plan for collecting literacy-related data that informs: (a) Literacy instructional practices; (b) Teacher professional development in the field of literacy; (c) What proficiencies and skills should be measured through literacy assessments and how those assessments are incorporated into loc al assessment plans; and (d) How to identify school progress in achieving literacy outcomes, including closing literacy gaps for students from historically underserved populations; (4) Recommend best practices for tiered literacy instruction within a multi-tiered system of supports to best improve and sustain literacy proficiency; (5) Review literacy assessments and outcomes and provide ongoing advice as to how to continuously improve those outcomes and sustain improvement; and (6) Provide a means for members of the public to provide input and ask questions concerning literacy issues.