Missouri Senate Bill SJR30

Missouri 2022 Regular Session

• Introduced: 1/5/22
• Refer: 1/10/22

Caption

Provides for gubernatorial appointment of members of the nonpartisan judicial commissions

Impact

If enacted, SJR30 would significantly alter the existing framework for judicial appointments in Missouri. The proposed structure is designed to eliminate political influence in the nomination process, as it involves citizen members in the selection of candidates. By moving towards a more accountable and transparent system, the amendment aligns with a broader trend of reforming judicial appointment processes across the nation, which can enhance public trust in the justice system and promote impartiality among judges.

Summary

SJR30 proposes an amendment to the Missouri Constitution aimed at restructuring the process of judicial appointments by introducing nonpartisan judicial commissions. The bill seeks to repeal section 25(d) of article V and replace it with provisions that establish these commissions to nominate candidates for judicial vacancies. According to the proposed amendment, the commissions will be responsible for submitting qualified candidates for appointment by the governor, ensuring a system rooted in transparency and citizen involvement.

Contention

However, the bill has garnered differing opinions among lawmakers and the public. Proponents argue that creating nonpartisan commissions will help mitigate issues related to cronyism and partisanship in judicial appointments, thereby ensuring that judges are selected based on merit rather than political affiliation. Critics, on the other hand, express concerns about potential drawbacks, such as the risk of bureaucratic inefficiency and the possibility that nonpartisan commissions may not resolve the underlying political tensions surrounding judicial appointments. There is also worry about the implications for minority representation within the commissions.