Missouri 2025 Regular Session

Missouri House Bill HB1389 Compare Versions

OldNewDifferences
11 FIRSTREGULARSESSION
2-HOUSECOMMITTEESUBSTITUTEFOR
3-HOUSEBILLNOS.1389&1040
2+HOUSEBILLNO.1389
43 103RDGENERALASSEMBLY
5-2959H.02C JOSEPHENGLER,ChiefClerk
4+INTRODUCEDBYREPRESENTATIVEKEATHLEY.
5+2959H.01I JOSEPHENGLER,ChiefClerk
66 ANACT
77 Toamendchapter490,RSMo,byaddingtheretoonenewsectionrelatingtotheadmissibility
88 ofevidenceofadefendant'screativeorartisticexpression.
99 BeitenactedbytheGeneralAssemblyofthestateofMissouri,asfollows:
1010 SectionA.Chapter490,RSMo,isamendedbyaddingtheretoonenewsection,tobe
1111 2knownassection490.750,toreadasfollows:
1212 490.750.1.Thissectionshallbeknownandmaybecitedasthe"Restoring
1313 2ArtisticProtectionActof2025".
1414 3 2.Asusedinthissection,theterm"creativeorartisticexpression"meansthe
1515 4expressionorapplicationofcreativityorimaginationintheproductionorarrangement
1616 5offorms,sounds,words,movements,orsymbols,includingmusic,dance,performance
1717 6art,visualart,poetry,literature,film,andothersuchobjectsormedia.
1818 7 3.Exceptasprovidedundersubsection4ofthissection,evidenceofa
1919 8defendant'screativeorartisticexpression,whetheroriginalorderivative,isnot
2020 9admissibleagainstsuchdefendantinacriminalcase.
2121 10 4.Acourtmayadmitevidencedescribedinsubsection3ofthissectionina
2222 11hearingconductedincameraifthestateprovesbyclearandconvincingevidence:
2323 12 (1)(a)Iftheexpressionisoriginal,thatthedefendantintendedaliteralmeaning
2424 13ratherthanafigurativeorfictionalmeaning;or
2525 14 (b)Iftheexpressionisderivative,thatthedefendantintendedtoadopttheliteral
2626 15meaningoftheexpressionasthedefendant'sownthoughtorstatement;
2727 16 (2)Thatthecreativeexpressionreferstothespecificfactsofthecrimealleged;
2828 17 (3)Thattheexpressionisrelevanttoanissueoffactthatisdisputed;and
2929 EXPLANATION—Matterenclosedinbold-facedbrackets[thus] intheabovebillisnotenactedandis
3030 intendedtobeomittedfromthelaw.Matterinbold-facetypeintheabovebillisproposedlanguage. 18 (4)Thattheexpressionhasdistinctprobativevaluenotprovidedbyother
3131 19admissibleevidence.
3232 20 5.Inanyhearingundersubsection4ofthissection,thecourtshallmakeits
3333 21rulingontherecordandshallincludeitsfindingsoffactessentialtoitsruling.
3434 22 6.Ifthecourtadmitsanyevidencedescribedundersubsection3ofthissection
3535 23undertheexceptionundersubsection4ofthissection,thecourtshall:
3636 24 (1)Ensurethattheexpressionisredactedinamannertolimittheevidence
3737 25presentedtothejurytothatwhichisspecificallyexceptedundersubsection4ofthis
3838 26section;and
3939 27 (2)Provideappropriatelimitinginstructionstothejury.
4040 âś”
41-HCSHBs1389&1040 2
41+HB1389 2