EXPLANATION-Matter enclosed in bold-faced brackets [thus] in this bill is not enacted and is intended to be omitted in the law. FIRST REGULAR SESSION [PERFECTED] SENATE SUBSTITUTE FOR SENATE BILL NO. 266 103RD GENERAL ASSEMBLY INTRODUCED BY SENATOR FITZWATER. 0642S.02P KRISTINA MARTIN, Secretary AN ACT To repeal section 161.670, RSMo, and to enact in lieu thereof one new section relating to assessment of virtual school students. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Missouri, as follows: Section A. Section 161.670, RSMo, is repealed and one new 1 section enacted in lieu thereof, to be known as section 161.6 70, 2 to read as follows:3 161.670. 1. Notwithstanding any other law, prior to 1 July 1, 2007, the state board of education shall establish 2 the "Missouri Course Access and Virtual School Program" to 3 serve school-age students residing in the state. The 4 Missouri course access and virtual school program shall 5 offer nonclassroom-based instruction in a virtual setting 6 using technology, intranet, or internet methods of 7 communication. Any student under the age of twenty -one in 8 grades kindergarten thro ugh twelve who resides in this state 9 shall be eligible to enroll in the Missouri course access 10 and virtual school program pursuant to subsection 3 of this 11 section. 12 2. (1) For purposes of calculation and distribution 13 of state school aid, students enrolled in the Missouri 14 course access and virtual school program shall be included 15 SS SB 266 2 in the student enrollment of the school district in which 16 the student is enrolled under the relevant provisions of 17 subsection 3 of this section for such enrollment. Student 18 attendance for full-time virtual program students shall only 19 be included in any district pupil attendance calculation 20 under chapter 163 using current -year pupil attendance for 21 such full-time virtual program pupils. For the purpose of 22 calculating average daily attendance in full -time virtual 23 programs under this section, average daily attendance shall 24 be defined as the quotient or the sum of the quotients 25 obtained by dividing the total number of hours attended in a 26 term by enrolled pupils bet ween the ages of five and twenty - 27 one by the actual number of hours that the program was in 28 session in that term, and the provisions of section 162.1250 29 shall not apply to such funding calculation. Such 30 calculation shall be generated by the virtual pro vider and 31 provided to the host district for submission to the 32 department of elementary and secondary education. Such 33 students may complete their instructional activities, as 34 defined in subsection 4 of this section, during any hour of 35 the day and during any day of the week. The hours attended 36 for each enrolled pupil shall be documented by the pupil's 37 weekly progress in the educational program according to a 38 process determined by the virtual program and published 39 annually in the virtual program's e nrollment handbook or 40 policy. To the average daily attendance of the following 41 school term shall be added the full -time equivalent average 42 daily attendance of summer school students. In the case of 43 a host school district enrolling one or more full -time 44 virtual school students, such enrolling district shall, as 45 part of its monthly state allocation, receive no less under 46 the state aid calculation for such students than an amount 47 SS SB 266 3 equal to the state adequacy target multiplied by the 48 weighted average daily attendance of such full -time 49 students. Students residing in Missouri and enrolled in a 50 full-time virtual school program operated by a public 51 institution of higher education in this state shall be 52 counted for a state aid calculation by the depart ment, and 53 the department shall pay, from funds dedicated to state 54 school aid payments made under section 163.031, to such 55 institution an amount equal to the state adequacy target 56 multiplied by the weighted average daily attendance of such 57 full-time students. 58 (2) The Missouri course access and virtual school 59 program shall report to the district of residence the 60 following information about each student served by the 61 Missouri course access and virtual school program: name, 62 address, eligibility for free or reduced-price lunch, 63 limited English proficiency status, special education needs, 64 and the number of courses in which the student is enrolled. 65 The Missouri course access and virtual school program shall 66 promptly notify the resident district when a student 67 discontinues enrollment. A "full-time equivalent student" 68 is a student who is enrolled in the instructional equivalent 69 of six credits per regular term. Each Missouri course 70 access and virtual school program course shall count as one 71 class and shall generate that portion of a full -time 72 equivalent that a comparable course offered by the school 73 district would generate. 74 (3) Pursuant to an education services plan and 75 collaborative agreement under subsection 3 of this section, 76 full-time equivalent students may be allowed to use a 77 physical location of the resident school district for all or 78 some portion of ongoing instructional activity, and the 79 SS SB 266 4 enrollment plan shall provide for reimbursement of costs of 80 the resident district fo r providing such access pursuant to 81 rules promulgated under this section by the department. 82 (4) In no case shall more than the full -time 83 equivalency of a regular term of attendance for a single 84 student be used to claim state aid. Full-time equivalent 85 student credit completed shall be reported to the department 86 of elementary and secondary education in the manner 87 prescribed by the department. Nothing in this section shall 88 prohibit students from enrolling in additional courses under 89 a separate agreement that includes terms for paying tuition 90 or course fees. 91 (5) A full-time virtual school program serving full - 92 time equivalent students shall be considered an attendance 93 center in the host school district and shall participate in 94 the statewide assessment system as defined in section 95 160.518. The academic performance of students enrolled in a 96 full-time virtual school program shall be assigned to the 97 designated attendance center of the full -time virtual school 98 program and shall be conside red in like manner to other 99 attendance centers. The academic performance of any student 100 who disenrolls from a full -time virtual school program and 101 enrolls in a public school or charter school shall not be 102 used in determining the annual performance rep ort score of 103 the attendance center or school district in which the 104 student enrolls for twelve months from the date of 105 enrollment. 106 (6) For the purposes of this section, a public 107 institution of higher education operating a full -time 108 virtual school program shall be subject to all requirements 109 applicable to a host school district with respect to its 110 full-time equivalent students. 111 SS SB 266 5 3. (1) A student who resides in this state may enroll 112 in Missouri course access and virtual school program cours es 113 of his or her choice as a part of the student's annual 114 course load each school year, with any costs associated with 115 such course or courses to be paid by the school district or 116 charter school if: 117 (a) The student is enrolled full -time in a public 118 school, including any charter school; and 119 (b) Prior to enrolling in any Missouri course access 120 and virtual school program course, a student has received 121 approval from his or her school district or charter school 122 through the procedure described under subdivision (2) of 123 this subsection. 124 (2) Each school district or charter school shall adopt 125 a policy that delineates the process by which a student may 126 enroll in courses provided by the Missouri course access and 127 virtual school program that is substantially similar to the 128 typical process by which a district student would enroll in 129 courses offered by the school district and a charter school 130 student would enroll in courses offered by the charter 131 school. The policy may include consultation with the 132 school's counselor and may include parental notification or 133 authorization. The policy shall ensure that available 134 opportunities for in -person instruction are considered prior 135 to moving a student to virtual courses. The policy shall 136 allow for continuous enrollment throughout the school year. 137 If the school district or charter school disapproves a 138 student's request to enroll in a course or courses provided 139 by the Missouri course access and virtual school program, 140 the reason shall be provid ed in writing and it shall be for 141 good cause. Good cause justification to disapprove a 142 student's request for enrollment in a course shall be a 143 SS SB 266 6 determination that doing so is not in the best educational 144 interest of the student, and shall be consistent with the 145 determination that would be made for such course request 146 under the process by which a district student would enroll 147 in a similar course offered by the school district and a 148 charter school student would enroll in a similar course 149 offered by the charter school, except that the determination 150 may consider the suitability of virtual courses for the 151 student based on prior participation in virtual courses by 152 the student. Appeals of any course denials under this 153 subsection shall be considered und er a policy that is 154 substantially similar to the typical process by which 155 appeals would be considered for a student seeking to enroll 156 in courses offered by the school district and a charter 157 school student seeking to enroll in courses offered by the 158 charter school. 159 (3) For students enrolled in any Missouri course 160 access and virtual school program course in which costs 161 associated with such course are to be paid by the school 162 district or charter school as described under this 163 subdivision, the school district or charter school shall pay 164 the content provider directly on a pro rata monthly basis 165 based on a student's completion of assignments and 166 assessments. If a student discontinues enrollment, the 167 district or charter school may stop making mo nthly payments 168 to the content provider. No school district or charter 169 school shall pay, for any one course for a student, more 170 than the market necessary costs but in no case shall pay 171 more than fourteen percent of the state adequacy target, as 172 defined under section 163.011, as calculated at the end of 173 the most recent school year for any single, year -long course 174 SS SB 266 7 and no more than seven percent of the state adequacy target 175 as described above for any single semester equivalent course. 176 (4) (a) A student who lives in this state may enroll 177 in a virtual program of their choice as provided in this 178 subdivision, and the provisions of subdivisions (1) to (3) 179 of this subsection shall not apply to such enrollment in a 180 full-time virtual program. Each host school district 181 operating a full-time virtual program under this section 182 shall adopt, operate and implement an enrollment policy as 183 specified by the provisions of this subdivision. The 184 student, the student's parent or guardian if the student is 185 not considered homeless, the virtual program, the host 186 district, and the resident district shall collaborate in 187 good faith to implement the enrollment policy regarding the 188 student's enrollment, and the resident school district and 189 the host school distri ct may mutually agree that the 190 resident district shall offer or continue to offer services 191 for the student under an agreement that includes financial 192 terms for reimbursement by the host school district for the 193 necessary costs of the resident school dis trict providing 194 such services. An enrollment policy specified under this 195 subsection shall: 196 a. Require a student's parent or guardian, if the 197 student is not considered homeless, to apply for enrollment 198 in a full-time virtual program directly with the virtual 199 program; 200 b. Specify timelines for timely participation by the 201 virtual program, the host district, and resident district; 202 provided that the resident district shall provide any 203 relevant information and input on the enrollment within te n 204 business days of notice from the virtual program of the 205 enrollment application; 206 SS SB 266 8 c. Include a survey of the reasons for the student's 207 and parent's interests in participating in the virtual 208 program; 209 d. Include consideration of available opp ortunities 210 for in-person instruction prior to enrolling a student in a 211 virtual program; 212 e. Evaluate requests for enrollment based on meeting 213 the needs for a student to be successful considering all 214 relevant factors; 215 f. Ensure that, for any enrolling student with a 216 covered disability, an individualized education program and 217 a related services agreement, in cases where such agreement 218 is needed, are created to provide all services required to 219 ensure a free and appropriate public education, including 220 financial terms for reimbursement by the host district for 221 the necessary costs of any virtual program, school district, 222 or public or private entity providing all or a portion of 223 such services; 224 g. Require the virtual program to determine whether an 225 enrolling student will be admitted, based on the enrollment 226 policy, in consideration of all relevant factors and provide 227 the basis for its determination and any service plan for the 228 student, in writing, to the student, the student's parent or 229 guardian, the host district, and the resident district; and 230 h. Provide a process for reviewing appeals of 231 decisions made under this subdivision. 232 (b) The department shall publish an annual report 233 based on the enrollments and enrollment sur veys conducted 234 under this subdivision that provides data at the statewide 235 and district levels of sufficient detail to allow analysis 236 of trends regarding the reasons for participation in the 237 virtual program at the statewide and district levels; 238 SS SB 266 9 provided that no such survey results will be published in a 239 manner that reveals individual student information. The 240 department shall also include, in the annual report, data at 241 the statewide and district levels of sufficient detail to 242 allow detection and ana lysis of the racial, ethnic, and 243 socio-economic balance of virtual program participation 244 among schools and districts at the statewide and district 245 levels, provided that no such survey results will be 246 published in a manner that reveals individual studen t 247 information. 248 (5) In the case of a student who is a candidate for A+ 249 tuition reimbursement and taking a virtual course under this 250 section, the school shall attribute no less than ninety -five 251 percent attendance to any such student who has complet ed 252 such virtual course. 253 (6) The Missouri course access and virtual school 254 program shall ensure that individual learning plans designed 255 by certified teachers and professional staff are developed 256 for all students enrolled in more than two full -time course 257 access program courses or a full -time virtual school. 258 (7) Virtual school programs shall monitor individual 259 student success and engagement of students enrolled in their 260 program and, for students enrolled in virtual courses on a 261 part-time basis, the virtual school program shall provide 262 regular student progress reports for each student at least 263 four times per school year to the school district or charter 264 school, provide the host school district and the resident 265 school district ongoing acc ess to academic and other 266 relevant information on student success and engagement, and 267 shall terminate or alter the course offering if it is found 268 the course is not meeting the educational needs of the 269 students enrolled in the course. 270 SS SB 266 10 (8) The department of elementary and secondary 271 education shall monitor the aggregate performance of 272 providers and make such information available to the public 273 under subsection 11 of this section. 274 (9) Pursuant to rules to be promulgated by the 275 department of elementary and secondary education, when a 276 student transfers into a school district or charter school, 277 credits previously gained through successful passage of 278 approved courses under the Missouri course access and 279 virtual school program shall be accepte d by the school 280 district or charter school. 281 (10) Pursuant to rules to be promulgated by the 282 department of elementary and secondary education, if a 283 student transfers into a school district or charter school 284 while enrolled in a Missouri course acce ss and virtual 285 school program course or full -time virtual school, the 286 student shall continue to be enrolled in such course or 287 school. 288 (11) Nothing in this section shall prohibit home 289 school or FPE school students, private school students, or 290 students wishing to take additional courses beyond their 291 regular course load from enrolling in Missouri course access 292 and virtual school program courses under an agreement that 293 includes terms for paying tuition or course fees. 294 (12) Nothing in this subsection shall require any 295 school district, charter school, virtual program, or the 296 state to provide computers, equipment, or internet access to 297 any student unless required under the education services 298 plan created for an eligible student under subdivi sion (4) 299 of this subsection or for an eligible student with a 300 disability to comply with federal law. An education 301 services plan may require an eligible student to have access 302 SS SB 266 11 to school facilities of the resident school district during 303 regular school hours for participation and instructional 304 activities of a virtual program under this section, and the 305 education services plan shall provide for reimbursement of 306 the resident school district for such access pursuant to 307 rules adopted by the department un der this section. 308 (13) The authorization process shall provide for 309 continuous monitoring of approved providers and courses. 310 The department shall revoke or suspend or take other 311 corrective action regarding the authorization of any course 312 or provider no longer meeting the requirements of the 313 program. Unless immediate action is necessary, prior to 314 revocation or suspension, the department shall notify the 315 provider and give the provider a reasonable time period to 316 take corrective action to avoid revocation or suspension. 317 The process shall provide for periodic renewal of 318 authorization no less frequently than once every three years. 319 (14) Courses approved as of August 28, 2018, by the 320 department to participate in the Missouri virtual 321 instruction program shall be automatically approved to 322 participate in the Missouri course access and virtual school 323 program, but shall be subject to periodic renewal. 324 (15) Any online course or virtual program offered by a 325 school district or charter sch ool, including those offered 326 prior to August 28, 2018, which meets the requirements of 327 section 162.1250 shall be automatically approved to 328 participate in the Missouri course access and virtual school 329 program. Such course or program shall be subject to 330 periodic renewal. A school district or charter school 331 offering such a course or virtual school program shall be 332 deemed an approved provider. 333 SS SB 266 12 (16) A host district may contract with a provider to 334 perform any required services involved with delive ring a 335 full-time virtual education. 336 4. (1) As used in this subsection, the term 337 "instructional activities" means classroom -based or 338 nonclassroom-based activities that a student shall be 339 expected to complete, participate in, or attend during any 340 given school day, such as: 341 (a) Online logins to curricula or programs; 342 (b) Offline activities; 343 (c) Completed assignments within a particular program, 344 curriculum, or class; 345 (d) Testing; 346 (e) Face-to-face communications or meet ings with 347 school staff; 348 (f) Telephone or video conferences with school staff; 349 (g) School-sanctioned field trips; or 350 (h) Orientation. 351 (2) A full-time virtual school shall submit a 352 notification to the parent or guardian of any stude nt who is 353 not consistently engaged in instructional activities and 354 shall provide regular student progress reports for each 355 student at least four times per school year. 356 (3) Each full-time virtual school shall develop, 357 adopt, and post on the school 's website a policy setting 358 forth the consequences for a student who fails to complete 359 the required instructional activities. Such policy shall 360 state, at a minimum, that if a student fails to complete the 361 instructional activities after receiving a not ification 362 under subdivision (2) of this subsection, and after 363 reasonable intervention strategies have been implemented, 364 that the student shall be subject to certain consequences 365 SS SB 266 13 which may include disenrollment from the school. Prior to 366 any disenrollment, the parent or guardian shall have the 367 opportunity to present any information that the parent deems 368 relevant, and such information shall be considered prior to 369 any final decision. 370 (4) If a full-time virtual school disenrolls a student 371 under subdivision (3) of this subsection, the school shall 372 immediately provide written notification to such student's 373 school district of residence. The student's school district 374 of residence shall then provide to the parents or guardian 375 of the student a writ ten list of available educational 376 options and promptly enroll the student in the selected 377 option. Any student disenrolled from a full -time virtual 378 school shall be prohibited from reenrolling in the same 379 virtual school for the remainder of the school y ear. 380 5. School districts or charter schools shall inform 381 parents of their child's right to participate in the 382 program. Availability of the program shall be made clear in 383 the parent handbook, registration documents, and featured on 384 the home page of the school district or charter school's 385 website. 386 6. The department shall: 387 (1) Establish an authorization process for course or 388 full-time virtual school providers that includes multiple 389 opportunities for submission each year; 390 (2) Pursuant to the time line established by the 391 department, authorize course or full -time virtual school 392 providers that: 393 (a) Submit all necessary information pursuant to the 394 requirements of the process; and 395 (b) Meet the criteria described in subdi vision (3) of 396 this subsection; 397 SS SB 266 14 (3) Review, pursuant to the authorization process, 398 proposals from providers to provide a comprehensive, full - 399 time equivalent course of study for students through the 400 Missouri course access and virtual school program . The 401 department shall ensure that these comprehensive courses of 402 study align to state academic standards and that there is 403 consistency and compatibility in the curriculum used by all 404 providers from one grade level to the next grade level; 405 (4) Within thirty days of any denial, provide a 406 written explanation to any course or full -time virtual 407 school providers that are denied authorization; 408 (5) Allow a course or full -time virtual school 409 provider denied authorization to reapply at any point in the 410 future. 411 7. The department shall publish the process 412 established under this section, including any deadlines and 413 any guidelines applicable to the submission and 414 authorization process for course or full -time virtual school 415 providers on its website. 416 8. If the department determines that there are 417 insufficient funds available for evaluating and authorizing 418 course or full-time virtual school providers, the department 419 may charge applicant course or full -time virtual school 420 providers a fee up to, but no greater than, the amount of 421 the costs in order to ensure that evaluation occurs. The 422 department shall establish and publish a fee schedule for 423 purposes of this subsection. 424 9. Except as specified in this section and as may be 425 specified by rule of the state board of education, the 426 Missouri course access and virtual school program shall 427 comply with all state laws and regulations applicable to 428 school districts, including but not limited to the Missouri 429 SS SB 266 15 school improvement program (MSIP), annual performance report 430 (APR), teacher certification, curriculum standards, audit 431 requirements under chapter 165, access to public records 432 under chapter 610, and school accountability report cards 433 under section 160.522. Teachers and administ rators employed 434 by a virtual provider shall be considered to be employed in 435 a public school for all certification purposes under chapter 436 168. 437 10. The department shall submit and publicly publish 438 an annual report on the Missouri course access and virtual 439 school program and the participation of entities to the 440 governor, the chair and ranking member of the senate 441 education committee, and the chair and ranking member of the 442 house of representatives elementary and secondary education 443 committee. The report shall at a minimum include the 444 following information: 445 (1) The annual number of unique students participating 446 in courses authorized under this section and the total 447 number of courses in which students are enrolled in; 448 (2) The number of authorized providers; 449 (3) The number of authorized courses and the number of 450 students enrolled in each course; 451 (4) The number of courses available by subject and 452 grade level; 453 (5) The number of students enrolled in courses broken 454 down by subject and grade level; 455 (6) Student outcome data, including completion rates, 456 student learning gains, student performance on state or 457 nationally accepted assessments, by subject and grade level 458 per provider. This outcome data shall be publ ished in a 459 manner that protects student privacy; 460 (7) The costs per course; 461 SS SB 266 16 (8) Evaluation of in-school course availability 462 compared to course access availability to ensure gaps in 463 course access are being addressed statewide. 464 11. (1) The department shall be responsible for 465 creating the Missouri course access and virtual school 466 program catalog providing a listing of all courses 467 authorized and available to students in the state, detailed 468 information, including costs per course, about the courses 469 to inform student enrollment decisions, and the ability for 470 students to submit their course enrollments. 471 (2) On or before January 1, 2023, the department shall 472 publish on its website, and distribute to all school 473 districts and charter schools in this state, a guidance 474 document that details the options for virtual course access 475 and full-time virtual course access for all students in the 476 state. The guidance document shall include a complete and 477 readily understood description of the applicable enrollment 478 processes including the opportunity for students to enroll 479 and the roles and responsibilities of the student, parent, 480 virtual provider, school district or districts, and charter 481 schools, as appropriate. The guidance document shal l be 482 distributed in written and electronic form to all school 483 districts, charter schools, and virtual providers. School 484 districts and charter schools shall provide a copy of the 485 guidance document to every pupil and parent or legal 486 guardian of every pupil enrolled in the district or charter 487 school at the beginning of each school year and upon 488 enrollment for every pupil enrolling at a different time of 489 the school year. School districts and charter schools shall 490 provide a readily viewable link to th e electronic version of 491 the guidance document on the main page of the district's or 492 charter school's website. 493 SS SB 266 17 12. Any virtual school or program may administer any 494 statewide assessment required pursuant to the provisions of 495 section 160.518, except for college readiness or workforce 496 readiness assessments provided by a national college and 497 career readiness assessment provider, in a virtual setting 498 that aligns with the student's regular academic 499 instruction. Any administration of a virtual statew ide 500 assessment shall meet the following conditions: 501 (1) The assessment shall be administered to the 502 student at an assigned date and time; 503 (2) The assessment shall be administered during a 504 synchronous assessment session initiated and managed by an 505 employee of the virtual school; 506 (3) The student shall be monitored by an assessment 507 proctor via a camera for the duration of the assessment. If 508 the assessment platform does not allow for integrated camera 509 proctoring, the student shall use two devices during the 510 assessment. The first device shall be used to take the 511 assessment and the second device shall have a functioning 512 camera and be used to monitor the student during the 513 assessment. However, if the assessment platform allows for 514 the proctor to view the student and background, then a 515 second device shall not be required; 516 (4) The virtual school or program shall make every 517 reasonable effort to maintain a student assessment taker to 518 assessment proctor ratio of ten to one or low er; 519 (5) The student shall not exit the assessment platform 520 until instructed to do so by the assigned assessment 521 proctor; and 522 (6) The student's submission of the completed 523 assessment shall be verified by the assessment administrator. 524 SS SB 266 18 13. The state board of education through the 525 rulemaking process and the department of elementary and 526 secondary education in its policies and procedures shall 527 ensure that multiple content providers and learning 528 management systems are allowed, ensure digit al content 529 conforms to accessibility requirements, provide an easily 530 accessible link for providers to submit courses or full -time 531 virtual schools on the Missouri course access and virtual 532 school program website, and allow any person, organization, 533 or entity to submit courses or full -time virtual schools for 534 approval. No content provider shall be allowed that is 535 unwilling to accept payments in the amount and manner as 536 described under subdivision (3) of subsection 3 of this 537 section or does not meet performance or quality standards 538 adopted by the state board of education. 539 [13.] 14. Any rule or portion of a rule, as that term 540 is defined in section 536.010, that is created under the 541 authority delegated in this section shall become effective 542 only if it complies with and is subject to all of the 543 provisions of chapter 536 and, if applicable, section 544 536.028. This section and chapter 536 are nonseverable and 545 if any of the powers vested with the general assembly 546 pursuant to chapter 536 to revie w, to delay the effective 547 date, or to disapprove and annul a rule are subsequently 548 held unconstitutional, then the grant of rulemaking 549 authority and any rule proposed or adopted after August 28, 550 2006, shall be invalid and void. 551