North Carolina 2023-2024 Regular Session

North Carolina House Bill H91

Introduced
2/13/23  

Caption

Create Pretrial Release Study Committee.-AB

Impact

If enacted, HB 91 could significantly influence state laws related to pretrial detention and release policies. By creating a dedicated committee tasked with developing uniform guidelines, the bill aims to address the variability in current practices that can lead to unequal treatment of defendants based on location. Standardized procedures may improve the overall justice process, reducing the likelihood of unjust detention and ensuring that defendants are treated fairly, regardless of the jurisdiction. The impact could extend to associated legal and correctional systems, potentially redefining how pretrial processes are managed throughout the state.

Summary

House Bill 91, titled 'Create Pretrial Release Study Committee', aims to establish a legislative committee to explore and recommend uniform standards for pretrial release procedures across North Carolina. The bill acknowledges existing discrepancies in how pretrial releases are handled and seeks a systematic approach to ensure consistent treatment of criminal defendants. Specifically, the committee will examine statewide standards for pretrial release programs, policies for defendants who fail to appear in court, conditions for pretrial release without jail time, and potential electronic monitoring programs funded by the state. By addressing these issues, the bill aspires to harmonize pretrial processes, enhancing fairness and efficiency within the criminal justice system.

Sentiment

The sentiment surrounding HB 91 appears to be cautiously optimistic, with support from various legislative members who recognize the need for reform in pretrial processes. Advocates of the bill argue that a uniform approach can enhance the integrity of the justice system and protect the rights of defendants. However, discussions may also highlight concerns regarding the implications of statewide regulations imposed on local jurisdictions, emphasizing the balance necessary between state guidelines and local judicial discretion. The debate is likely to draw attention to the broader implications for equity and justice in pretrial matters.

Contention

Notable points of contention surrounding HB 91 may include concerns about the effectiveness of a statewide committee in addressing local needs and the potential for bureaucratic hurdles in implementing uniform standards. Critics may argue that such a one-size-fits-all approach could overlook the unique contexts and challenges faced by different jurisdictions. Additionally, there could be discussions regarding the financial implications of funding electronic monitoring programs and the prioritization of state resources in relation to local law enforcement and judicial systems. Addressing these issues will likely shape the legislative discourse as the bill progresses.

Companion Bills

No companion bills found.

Previously Filed As

NC H1004

AI Study Committee/Funds

NC H953

Study Committee on ADA/APD/PAC Pay

NC SJR56

Study Commission on Financial Obligations in Pretrial Services and Alternative Courts, created

NC H113

Create Committee on Medicaid Sustainability

NC H813

The Pretrial Integrity Act

NC SB0070

Bail and release review commission.

NC AB42

Bail: pretrial release.

NC SB10

Pretrial release or detention: pretrial services.

NC H983

Orphan Roads Study Committee

NC SB331

AN ACT relating to pretrial release.

Similar Bills

NJ AR96

Changes membership of Budget and Labor Committees; clarifies that bill or resolution may be listed on committee agenda for purposes of amendment.

MI HB4326

Campaign finance: contributions and expenditures; provision related to officeholders raising funds when facing a recall; modify, and require candidate to establish a separate account used for recall purposes. Amends secs. 3, 11, 12, 21, 24 & 52 of 1976 PA 388 (MCL 169.203 et seq.) & adds sec. 21b.

MI HB4870

Campaign finance: contributions and expenditures; funds donated to a candidate for recall efforts; require candidate to establish a separate account used for recall purposes. Amends secs. 3, 11, 12, 21, 24 & 52 of 1976 PA 388 (MCL 169.203 et seq.) & adds sec. 21b.

MN HC6

A concurrent resolution recognizing wild rice as sacred and central to the culture and health of Indigenous Peoples in Minnesota and critical to the health and identity of all Minnesota citizens and ecosystems and establishing a commitment to passing legislation to protect wild rice and the freshwater resources upon which it depends.

CA SB602

Advisory bodies.

CA SB1048

Advisory bodies.

CA AB3239

Advisory bodies.

KS HR6003

Providing temporary rules of the House of Representatives for the 2023 session until permanent rules are adopted.