New Jersey 2022-2023 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A199

Introduced
1/11/22  

Caption

Exempts law enforcement and certain other emergency personnel from liability for breaking into motor vehicle to rescue animal under certain circumstances.

Impact

The implementation of A199 has the potential to alter current protocols for animal rescue, providing a legal safeguard for responders who may face legal repercussions when performing these urgent rescues. The law would ensure that first responders can act swiftly without the fear of incurring damages for breaking a window or damaging a vehicle in their efforts to save an animal. This could lead not only to quicker response times but also to a greater willingness among emergency responders to intervene in situations where animals are at risk.

Summary

Assembly Bill A199 introduces important legal protections for law enforcement and emergency personnel in New Jersey, specifically regarding their ability to rescue animals left in motor vehicles under dangerous conditions. The bill states that these first responders will be immune from liability if they break into a vehicle to rescue an animal that they reasonably believe is in immediate jeopardy of health or life. This measure is intended to facilitate quick intervention in situations where an animal might suffer from heat exhaustion or other health dangers due to extreme temperatures or neglect.

Contention

Despite the well-meaning intentions behind A199, some stakeholders have raised concerns regarding the potential for misuse of the law. Critics may argue that the bill could lead to situations where vehicles are broken into unnecessarily, which could result in damage and potential conflict with vehicle owners. Additionally, the lack of strict guidelines on when it is deemed 'reasonable' for emergency personnel to break into a vehicle could lead to inconsistencies in application and enforcement of the law.

Overall_significance

Ultimately, A199 serves as an important legislative step towards enhancing animal welfare while balancing the rights and responsibilities of both responders and vehicle owners. By codifying this immunity, the bill acknowledges the critical role that timely intervention plays in saving animals from perilous situations, while also prompting discussions about the broader implications of emergency responses in everyday scenarios.

Companion Bills

NJ S2482

Same As Exempts law enforcement and certain other emergency personnel from liability for breaking into motor vehicle to rescue animal under certain circumstances.

Previously Filed As

NJ S860

Exempts law enforcement and certain other emergency personnel from liability for breaking into motor vehicle to rescue animal under certain circumstances.

NJ S2482

Exempts law enforcement and certain other emergency personnel from liability for breaking into motor vehicle to rescue animal under certain circumstances.

NJ A4703

Establishes exemption from liability for breaking into motor vehicle to rescue animal under certain circumstances.

NJ A2821

Provides immunity from civil and criminal liability for rescue of animal from motor vehicle under inhumane conditions.

NJ A3637

Provides immunity from civil and criminal liability for rescue of animal from motor vehicle under inhumane conditions.

NJ S80

Provides immunity from civil and criminal liability for rescue of animal from motor vehicle under inhumane conditions.

NJ S1938

Provides immunity from civil and criminal liability for rescue of animal from motor vehicle under inhumane conditions.

NJ SB188

Relating to civil liability for removing certain individuals or animals from a motor vehicle and criminal liability for removing certain animals from a motor vehicle.

NJ A1263

Upgrades penalty for assault on law enforcement to second degree crime under certain circumstances.

NJ A4730

Upgrades penalty for assault on law enforcement to second degree crime under certain circumstances.

Similar Bills

No similar bills found.