New Jersey 2022-2023 Regular Session

New Jersey Senate Bill S118

Introduced
1/11/22  

Caption

Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

Impact

The bill introduces a mandatory six-month term of imprisonment or community service for those convicted of theft, robbery, or burglary during emergency situations. This stipulation is a significant enhancement to the legal consequences associated with these offenses, reflecting the state's commitment to deterring such crimes when societal stability is compromised. Furthermore, this measure ensures that the harsh penalties apply regardless of the circumstances leading to the emergencies, creating a uniform approach to crime during crises.

Summary

Senate Bill S118 aims to amend the existing Disaster Control Act by establishing mandatory penalties for individuals committing crimes such as burglary, theft, or robbery during a state of emergency. These crimes, commonly associated with looting, will incur additional penalties aside from those dictated under general state law. The legislation emphasizes the seriousness of crimes occurring during emergencies, recognizing that such acts can greatly undermine the safety and welfare of the community during vulnerable times.

Conclusion

As S118 moves through the legislative process, its implications for state law and community safety will be carefully scrutinized. The balance between deterrence of crime and ensuring fair treatment under the law during emergencies presents a crucial debate among lawmakers. The final outcome of this bill will likely shape responses to criminal activity during future crises and could set a precedent for similar legislation in other jurisdictions.

Contention

Although the bill is intended to reinforce public safety during emergencies, there may be concerns regarding its implementation. Opponents could argue that the bill's punitive measures may lead to overreach, particularly if misapplied in scenarios where motivations for theft could be linked to desperation during a crisis. This raises ethical questions about justice and whether the loss of property should result in mandatory imprisonment or community service, regardless of intent. Moreover, critics might emphasize the need for a balanced approach that takes into account individual circumstances during emergencies.

Companion Bills

NJ A1610

Same As Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

Previously Filed As

NJ S447

Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

NJ A755

Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

NJ A1610

Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

NJ S3006

Establishes crimes of home invasion burglary and residential burglary.

NJ A4299

Establishes crimes of home invasion burglary and residential burglary.

NJ A1039

Upgrades penalties for certain crimes committed during a state of emergency.

NJ A2640

Upgrades penalties for certain crimes committed during a state of emergency.

NJ S399

Broadens riot; enhances penalties for certain crimes committed during riot; creates new crimes of mob intimidation and cyber-intimidation by publication; establishes duty in municipality to permit law enforcement to respond appropriately.

NJ S1206

Broadens riot; enhances penalties for certain crimes committed during riot; creates new crimes of mob intimidation and cyber-intimidation by publication; establishes duty in municipality to permit law enforcement to respond appropriately.

NJ A3471

Upgrades penalties for theft of certain law enforcement and emergency vehicles.

Similar Bills

NJ A755

Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

NJ A1610

Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

NJ S447

Establishes mandatory penalties for committing burglary and theft during a state of emergency.

CA SB265

Crimes: looting.

CA ABX112

Crimes: looting.

CA AB271

Crimes: looting.

CA AB1595

Theft: burglary: natural or manmade disasters.

CA AB3078

Theft: burglary: natural or manmade disasters.