New Jersey 2024-2025 Regular Session

New Jersey Assembly Bill A1191

Introduced
1/9/24  

Caption

Requires collection of deoxyribonucleic acid sample for certain crimes.

Impact

The introduction of A1191 reflects a significant shift in New Jersey's approach to law enforcement and public safety. By requiring DNA samples from individuals arrested for specific severe crimes, the bill is intended to bolster the state's efforts in fighting violent crime and improving mechanisms for identifying and prosecuting offenders. This measure is expected to enhance existing DNA databases, providing law enforcement with powerful tools to facilitate investigations and improve the likelihood of convictions in serious cases.

Summary

Assembly Bill A1191, introduced in the New Jersey legislature, aims to amend the existing "DNA Database and Databank Act of 1994" by extending the requirement for collection of DNA samples to new categories of offenses. Specifically, the bill mandates that any person arrested for human trafficking, arson, or car-jacking must provide a DNA sample prior to release from custody. This includes individuals convicted of these crimes who are sentenced to imprisonment as well as those who receive sentences other than incarceration, emphasizing a broader scope of legal accountability in serious criminal offenses.

Contention

However, the bill has also sparked discussions about privacy rights and the ethical implications of mandating DNA collection upon arrest, regardless of a conviction. Critics may argue that this approach could lead to potential abuses of power, contested legal rights, and the risk of wrongful associations between individuals and crimes they did not commit. As legislation changes in the realm of criminal justice, balancing public safety with civil liberties remains a key point of contention.

Summary_points

In summary, A1191 aims to improve New Jersey's criminal justice framework by requiring DNA sampling for specific offenses to enhance investigation capabilities. While supporters laud the potential for increased public safety, concerns around privacy and civil rights evoke necessary debate as the state navigates these reformative policies.

Companion Bills

NJ S3088

Same As Requires collection of deoxyribonucleic acid sample for certain crimes.

NJ A4309

Carry Over Requires collection of deoxyribonucleic acid sample for certain crimes.

NJ S3117

Carry Over Requires collection of deoxyribonucleic acid sample for certain crimes.

Similar Bills

NJ A5004

Creates separate crime for items depicting sexual exploitation or abuse of children; concerns computer generated or manipulated sexually explicit images.

NJ S3823

Creates separate crime for items depicting sexual exploitation or abuse of children; concerns computer generated or manipulated sexually explicit images.

NJ S2652

Revises statutory terms pertaining to sexual exploitation or abuse of children.

NJ A3539

Revises statutory terms pertaining to sexual exploitation or abuse of children.

CA AB1602

Crimes: disorderly conduct.

NJ A5304

Upgrades penalties for certain prostitution crimes; creates crimes of leader of prostitution network and participant in prostitution network.

NJ S4160

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.

NJ A5486

Imposes criminal penalties for harboring aliens who have outstanding warrants and are unlawfully present in U.S.