New Jersey 2024-2025 Regular Session

New Jersey Senate Bill SCR43

Introduced
1/9/24  
Refer
1/9/24  
Report Pass
3/14/24  

Caption

Proposes constitutional amendment to make State trustee of public natural resources and guarantee to the people other environmental rights.

Impact

If passed, this resolution would amend Article I of the New Jersey Constitution, adding a new paragraph that guarantees every person the right to a clean and healthy environment. This includes specific rights to pure water, clean air, safe climate, and ecologically healthy habitats. Advocates of the amendment argue that it would enhance legal protections for natural resources and empower citizens to hold the state accountable for environmental stewardship. Furthermore, the state would be required to take proactive measures to conserve and maintain natural resources, reinforcing the concept of environmental protection as a public duty.

Summary

Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 43 (SCR43) proposes a constitutional amendment in New Jersey aimed at ensuring the right to a clean and healthy environment for all residents. The proposed amendment seeks to define the state as the trustee of public natural resources, which include waters, air, flora, fauna, and public lands, and obligate it to protect these resources for both present and future generations. This legislative initiative reflects a growing acknowledgment of environmental rights and aims to enshrine these principles within the state constitution.

Sentiment

Overall, sentiment around SCR43 seems to be supportive among environmental advocacy groups and those who prioritize ecological sustainability. The emotional appeal of guaranteeing environmental rights resonates with many constituents who have experienced the adverse effects of pollution and environmental degradation. However, there may also be concerns among certain sectors regarding the implications of this amendment, specifically about the regulatory challenges it could impose on development and land use, which could lead to governmental pushback.

Contention

Notable points of contention regarding SCR43 center around the practical implications of enacting such an amendment. Opponents may raise concerns about how the amendment could affect economic development, public land use, and private property rights. They might argue that while the intent to protect natural resources is commendable, the potential for increased litigation over environmental claims and regulations could hinder business activities and local governance. Balancing environmental rights with economic interests remains a critical aspect of the ongoing discourse surrounding this proposed amendment.

Companion Bills

NJ ACR119

Same As Proposes constitutional amendment to make State trustee of public natural resources and guarantee to the people other environmental rights.

NJ ACR72

Carry Over Proposes constitutional amendment to make State trustee of public natural resources and guarantee to the people other environmental rights.

NJ SCR15

Carry Over Proposes constitutional amendment to make State trustee of public natural resources and guarantee to the people other environmental rights.

Previously Filed As

NJ SCR15

Proposes constitutional amendment to make State trustee of public natural resources and guarantee to the people other environmental rights.

NJ ACR72

Proposes constitutional amendment to make State trustee of public natural resources and guarantee to the people other environmental rights.

NJ ACR119

Proposes constitutional amendment to make State trustee of public natural resources and guarantee to the people other environmental rights.

NJ HJR119

Proposing a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the right to a clean and healthy environment.

NJ HJR27

Proposing a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the right to a clean and healthy environment.

NJ HJR142

Proposing a constitutional amendment guaranteeing the right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment.

NJ HJR23

Natural Resources and the Public Estate Amendment

NJ SJ00036

Resolution Proposing A State Constitutional Amendment Concerning Environmental Rights.

NJ HJR17

Natural Resources and the Public Estate Amendment

NJ HCR88

Encouraging The State Of Hawaii To Adopt A Proposed Constitutional Amendment, And The Electorate To Ratify The Proposed Amendment, Guaranteeing All Individuals The Right To A Clean And Healthy Environment And A Stable Climate.

Similar Bills

CA AB2813

Government Investment Act.

CA SB345

Law enforcement agencies: public records.

CA AB1253

Education finance: school bonds: citizens’ oversight committees.

NJ SCR57

Proposes constitutional amendment to require payments by State to State-administered retirement systems and establish in Constitution right of public employees to pension benefit; provides for enforcement of funding obligations and benefit rights.

NJ SCR97

Proposes constitutional amendment to require payments by State to State-administered retirement systems and establish in Constitution right of public employees to pension benefit; provides for enforcement of funding obligations and benefit rights.

CA AB219

Property taxes: revenue allocations.

CA AB1726

Crimes: sentences.

NJ ACR50

Proposes an amendment to Constitution specifying a method of providing for the maintenance and support of a thorough and efficient system of free public schools and allocating all income tax receipts to school districts.