Pennsylvania House Bill HB1101

Pennsylvania 2023-2024 Regular Session

• Introduced: 5/5/23
• Refer: 5/5/23

Caption

In public safety, providing for the Pennsylvania Violent Death Reporting System; and imposing duties on the Department of Health.

Impact

The implementation of the HB 1101 is expected to impact state laws significantly by mandating data collection protocols related to violent fatalities. This includes information on context, circumstances, and trends associated with these incidences. An annual report detailing findings will also be published, increasing transparency and providing critical insights for stakeholders, policymakers, and the general public. The legislation emphasizes the use of existing data sources and avoids independent investigations, thereby bolstering the state's approach to managing public health and safety.

Summary

House Bill 1101 aims to establish the Pennsylvania Violent Death Reporting System within the Commonwealth's Department of Health. The purpose of this system is to systematically collect data regarding violent deaths in order to monitor their incidence and causes, analyze trends and patterns, and ultimately recommend preventative measures to reduce such events. By formalizing this reporting mechanism, the bill seeks to provide a comprehensive framework for understanding and addressing violent deaths in Pennsylvania.

Sentiment

Sentiment around the bill appears to be cautiously optimistic, with supporters viewing it as a necessary step toward a better understanding of the violent death landscape in Pennsylvania. Proponents believe that data-driven insights can lead to informed policy decisions that potentially save lives. Opposition may stem from concerns about data privacy and the effectiveness of the proposed measures in truly reducing violent deaths, particularly given the broader context of firearm regulations and public safety.

Contention

While the bill has garnered support for its data collection goals, notable points of contention include fears that the data could be misused or not adequately protect individual privacy, as well as skepticism about the actual effectiveness of reporting in mitigating violence. Additionally, the need for collaboration with various agencies—including law enforcement and social services—raises questions about potential bureaucratic challenges and inter-agency cooperation necessary for successful implementation.